Understanding physical exercise among individuals with substance use disorders using an integrated theoretical perspective of the health action process approach and theory of planned behavior

Yong Meng, Ting Zhu, Wei Chen, Hongjie Zhou, Lanping Tao, Xiaoteng Wang, Mengya Li, Xiaofang Zhang, Dongshi Wang, Xingyue Wu, Shaochen Luo, Cheng HuFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed an integrated psychological model combining the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) and the Health Action Process Approach (HAPA) to understand why individuals with substance use disorders (SUD) struggle to maintain exercise routines. The study finds that while social support and attitudes drive the initial intention to work out, specific "action" and "coping" plans are the essential bridges that translate those intentions into long-term habits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physical exercise is a powerful, non-pharmacological tool for addiction recovery—it reduces cravings, improves mood, and aids brain plasticity. However, there is a massive "intention-behavior gap": while many individuals in recovery want to exercise, adherence rates are notoriously low (often dropping below 50% in clinical trials).

Existing psychological models often fail to capture the full picture. The TPB is excellent at predicting intentions but is "static" and doesn't explain how those intentions become actions. The HAPA model is "stage-based" (distinguishing between non-intenders, intenders, and actors) but often overlooks social influences. This paper integrates both to create a roadmap for the transition from "thinking about exercise" to "staying active."

Methods

The researchers conducted a large-scale cross-sectional survey of 1,197 individuals with SUD in compulsory isolation rehabilitation centers in China.

To analyze the complex web of psychological drivers, they used Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). This allowed them to test an integrated HAPA-TPB model, looking at how variables like self-efficacy (belief in one's ability), social support, and risk perception influence both the motivation phase (forming an intention) and the volition phase (planning and executing the behavior). They also used ANOVA to verify that different psychological factors dominate depending on whether a person is in the "before action," "planning," or "active" stage of exercise.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset collected via self-report questionnaires from 10 compulsory isolation drug rehabilitation centers in Zhejiang Province.

  • Participants: 1,197 individuals (93% male, average age ~37).
  • Measures: Validated scales including the Physical Activity Rating Scale-3 (PARS-3), the Exercise Self-Efficacy Scale, and localized versions of TPB and HAPA scales.
  • Substance Types: The cohort included individuals with stimulant use disorders, heroin use disorders, and polydrug use disorders.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Planning Bridge: The most critical finding is that Action Planning (deciding when, where, and how) and Coping Planning (anticipating obstacles like fatigue or cravings) are the primary mediators. Without these, even the strongest intention rarely leads to actual exercise.
  • Social Norms Matter for Initiation: In the early stages, "Subjective Norms"—the perceived pressure or support from family and rehab staff—were among the strongest predictors of forming an intention to exercise.
  • The Paradox of Risk Perception: Interestingly, the study found a negative correlation between risk perception and behavioral intention. In this specific population, high perceived risk (e.g., fear of health decline) might feel overwhelming or discouraging rather than motivating, which differs from how risk perception often functions in the general public.
  • Direct vs. Indirect Control: While most factors influenced behavior through intentions, Perceived Behavioral Control (the sense of having the resources and ability to exercise) had a direct link to behavior, bypassing the need for a formal "intention" stage.

Key Results

  • Model Fit: The integrated HAPA-TPB model showed strong predictive power, explaining 83% of the variance in behavioral intentions and 12% of the variance in actual exercise behavior.
  • Planning Variance: The model explained roughly 31-33% of the variance in how people formed action and coping plans.
  • Demographics: Age and gender had significant negative effects on exercise behavior; older individuals and women in the study were less likely to form exercise habits, suggesting a need for more tailored interventions for these subgroups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gender Imbalance: The sample was 93% male, making it difficult to generalize the findings to women in recovery.
  • The "Compulsory" Context: Because the participants were in compulsory rehabilitation, their exercise might be influenced by institutional schedules rather than pure personal autonomy. Future research should look at voluntary community-based settings.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The data provides a snapshot in time. The authors suggest future longitudinal studies to track how these psychological factors evolve over months of recovery.
  • Subjective Reporting: Relying on self-reported exercise levels can lead to bias. Future work could integrate objective data from wearable fitness trackers.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study is the first attempt to integrate patterns of physical exercise behavior in individuals with SUD. The HAPA-TPB integration model provides a useful framework for identifying determinants of physical exercise behavioral intentions and behaviors in individuals with SUD and for explaining and predicting the initiation and maintenance of physical exercise behaviors in these individuals. Moreover, the model provides scientific guidance for the enhancement of physical exercise adherence in individuals with SUD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meng2024understanding,
  author = {Yong Meng and Ting Zhu and Wei Chen and Hongjie Zhou and Lanping Tao and Xiaoteng Wang and Mengya Li and Xiaofang Zhang and Dongshi Wang and Xingyue Wu and Shaochen Luo and Cheng Hu},
  title = {{Understanding physical exercise among individuals with substance use disorders using an integrated theoretical perspective of the health action process approach and theory of planned behavior}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1377430},
}
Figure