Abstract
Consumers with online shopping experience often stick to some special websites. Does it mean that long-term relationships between consumers and the websites form? To solve the problem, this paper analyzed the belief and attitude factors influencing online consumer stickiness intention. Based on the relationships between belief-attitude-intention implied in TPB (Theory of Planned Behavior), according to Expectation-Confirmation theory and Commitment-trust theory, we developed a concept model on online consumer stickiness. Six research hypotheses derived from this model were empirically validated using a survey of online shoppers. The results suggest that online consumer stickiness intention is influenced by consumers' commitment to the website (e-vendors) and their overall satisfaction to the transaction process, and commitment's effect is stronger; in turn, both consumers' commitment and overall satisfaction are influenced by consumers' ongoing trust significantly; confirmation has a significant effect on overall satisfaction but has not the same effect on commitment. The findings show that the long-term relationships between consumers and special websites exactly exist during online repeat consumption.
Introduction
In the hyper-competitive world of e-commerce, the cost of acquiring a new customer is significantly higher than retaining an existing one. While early research focused on website features like UI or loading speeds, this paper addresses the deeper psychological "glue" that keeps users coming back. The authors seek to understand if "stickiness"—the repetitive visit and use of a preferred website despite marketing efforts from competitors—is merely a habit or the result of a genuine relationship formation. They tackle the gap in existing literature regarding how beliefs translate into attitudes and, ultimately, the intention to stay.
The Relationship Formation Model
The researchers developed a conceptual model by synthesizing three major theoretical frameworks: the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), Expectation-Confirmation Theory (ECT), and Commitment-Trust Theory. This model maps the flow from beliefs (Confirmation, Ongoing Trust) to attitudes (Overall Satisfaction, Commitment) and finally to the intention of "stickiness."
Defining the Constructs
To ensure empirical rigor, the study utilized established scales to define and measure the key latent variables. Stickiness intention is defined as the consumer's intention to continue repurchasing on their preferred website regardless of marketing efforts or switching costs. Commitment represents the persistent desire to maintain a valuable relationship, while ongoing trust is the belief in the website's reliability.
Methodology and Data
To validate the model, researchers conducted a survey of 400 undergraduate students at a large Chinese university, resulting in 335 usable responses. The sample consisted of 57.4% male respondents with an average age of 25. Respondents evaluated the last e-commerce website they had used multiple times (e.g., Taobao, JD.com). The data was analyzed using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), a multivariate technique used to analyze structural relationships between measured variables and latent constructs.
Key Insights and Results
The SEM analysis provided strong quantitative support for the proposed model, explaining 48% of the variance in stickiness intention. Key findings include:
- Commitment is King: While overall satisfaction is important, commitment is a significantly stronger predictor of stickiness (path coefficient of 0.50). Being "attached" to a brand matters more than just being "happy" with the last order.
- Trust as the Engine: "Ongoing trust" is the primary driver for both satisfaction and commitment, with a massive path coefficient of 0.72 toward commitment.
- The Confirmation Gap: Interestingly, "confirmation" (the realization that a website performed as expected) directly influences satisfaction but does not directly influence commitment. Commitment requires the deeper emotional layer of trust.
Limitations and Future Work
The study relied exclusively on undergraduate students, who are heavy users of e-commerce but may not represent all demographics. Additionally, the model focuses on cognitive and relational factors; future work could incorporate emotional factors like "perceived enjoyment." Finally, as a cross-sectional study, it captures a snapshot in time; longitudinal research would better illustrate how these relationships evolve over years of consumption.
Summary updated