Introduction
Formal logic provides a rigorous framework for reasoning, yet it often fails to capture the nuances of human communication. In everyday discourse, individuals frequently employ enthymemes—arguments where certain premises or conclusions are left implicit. For instance, the statement "It is showery, so you will get wet" relies on the unstated knowledge that "showery" implies rain and rain causes wetness. Traditional AI systems struggle with such gaps, requiring exhaustive, manually curated knowledge bases that are often brittle and difficult to scale.
Bridging the Gap with Semantic Distance
To address these limitations, this research introduces a framework that integrates semantic distance measures into deductive argumentation. The core idea is to allow for "fuzzy" matching of logical symbols using word embeddings (e.g., GloVe, Word2Vec) or semantic networks (e.g., WordNet).
Semantic Substitution
The framework employs a Substitution Operator ($\oplus$). This operator allows the system to treat two distinct symbols as equivalent if their semantic distance falls below a predefined threshold ($\tau$). For example, the system can dynamically bridge the gap between "dad" and "father" without needing an explicit rule in the knowledge base. Analysis comparing GloVe distances to WordNet suggests that a threshold of approximately 0.8 serves as an effective "sweet spot" for identifying synonyms.
Abductive Reasoning and Decoding
Beyond simple substitution, the system utilizes abductive reasoning to identify the minimal set of missing premises and symbol swaps required to make an argument logically valid. Once these gaps are filled, the system "decodes" the argument, generating a complete logical proof that includes the necessary bridge formulas (e.g., $eagle \rightarrow bird$).
Evaluation and Results
The feasibility of this approach was tested using GloVe embeddings and synthetic knowledge bases. A key finding was the efficiency of "lazy substitution"—performing swaps only during the reasoning process—which avoids the combinatorial explosion associated with pre-augmenting a knowledge base with all possible synonyms.
Empirical results demonstrate that increasing the "cardinality of substitution" (the number of permitted swaps) significantly enhances the system's inference power. In tests involving a knowledge base of 100 clauses and 10 default rules, the abduction algorithm successfully identified solutions in approximately 0.22 seconds on a standard laptop, highlighting its potential for real-time applications.
Conclusion and Future Directions
By incorporating semantic similarity, deductive argumentation becomes more robust and better aligned with human reasoning. While the current model uses static word embeddings, future work aims to integrate context-aware models like BERT to handle polysemy and to develop methods for quantifying the uncertainty associated with specific decodings.
Summary updated