Understanding Dual Effects of Social Network Services on Digital Well-Being and Sustainability: A Case Study of Xiaohongshu (RED)

Qingyue Wu, Lei Gu, Mingxiao Zhang, Huimei LiuSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the dual impact of social networking services (SNSs) like Xiaohongshu (RED) on digital well-being and sustainability, using Hartmut Rosa's Resonance Theory. It reveals that while RED fosters resonance across material, spiritual, and social dimensions, it also generates alienation, creating a complex interplay that affects both individual well-being and broader societal sustainability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The proliferation of social networking services (SNSs) has profoundly reshaped how individuals interact with the world and each other. While these platforms offer avenues for connection, recognition, and a sense of belonging, they also present challenges like alienation, addiction, and the spread of misinformation. Existing research has largely focused on dominant Western platforms, leaving a gap in understanding the unique dynamics of emerging platforms, particularly in non-Western contexts. This paper addresses this by investigating Xiaohongshu (RED), a popular Chinese platform, to understand how its specific features and user base contribute to both positive (resonance) and negative (alienation) outcomes for digital well-being and sustainability. The study aims to bridge the gap between understanding individual user experiences and the broader implications for environmental, social, economic, and cultural sustainability.

Methods

The study employs a qualitative research approach, combining netnography and semi-structured interviews. Netnography, or virtual ethnography, involves immersing researchers in the online environment of RED to observe user behavior and understand platform culture. This was complemented by semi-structured interviews with RED users to gather in-depth insights into their experiences, emotions, and perceptions. The data collected was then analyzed using theoretical thematic analysis, guided by Hartmut Rosa's Resonance Theory. This involved identifying themes related to resonance and alienation across material, spiritual, and social dimensions, and examining their impact on digital well-being and sustainability.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from Xiaohongshu (RED). This included:

  • Posts and comments: Approximately 147,000 Chinese characters from 50 selected popular posts across various categories (fashion, beauty, food, etc.) and their associated comments.
  • User interviews: Transcripts from 26 semi-structured interviews with RED users, totaling approximately 31,200 Chinese characters.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing user-generated content and interview data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dual Nature of SNSs: RED, like many SNSs, is not inherently good or bad. It acts as a double-edged sword, simultaneously fostering connection and well-being (resonance) while also creating disconnection and distress (alienation).
  • Resonance as a Multifaceted Experience: Resonance on RED isn't just about liking posts. It manifests in material ways (e.g., informed consumption, experiential purchases), spiritual ways (e.g., self-care, cultural appreciation), and social ways (e.g., finding interest groups, emotional support communities).
  • Alienation as a Consequence of Platform Design: The platform's algorithms, focus on consumption, and the curated nature of content can lead to material alienation (endless consumption cycles), spiritual alienation (information cocoons, loss of autonomy), and social alienation (class perception gaps, cyberbullying).
  • Sustainability is Interconnected: The study highlights that the sustainability of the RED platform itself is intrinsically linked to broader environmental, social, economic, and cultural sustainability. Negative impacts on user well-being and societal cohesion can ultimately harm the platform's long-term viability.
  • The "Good Life" and Resonance: Hartmut Rosa's theory provides a powerful lens to understand that a "good life" is not just about material wealth but about stable, resonant relationships with the world, which SNSs can both facilitate and hinder.

Key Results

The study identified three primary types of resonance on RED:

  • Material Resonance: Driven by commodity consumption (informed purchasing decisions) and experiential consumption (sharing and seeking out experiences).
  • Spiritual Resonance: Fostered through mental self-care (seeking solace and coping strategies), cultural communication (preserving and promoting traditional culture), and the aestheticization of everyday life (finding beauty in ordinary moments).
  • Social Resonance: Manifested in the formation of interest groups (connecting users with shared passions) and emotion communities (providing support and empathy).

Conversely, RED also generates three types of alienation:

  • Material Alienation: Through excessive consumption driven by the platform's commercial focus and the creation of "pseudo-real" spectacles.
  • Spiritual Alienation: Via "information cocoons" created by algorithms, leading to a loss of user autonomy and critical thinking.
  • Social Alienation: Resulting from perception gaps related to social class, tensions between online and offline economies, and the prevalence of cyberbullying.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's focus on RED as a single case study may limit the generalizability of findings due to variations in user demographics, platform design, and cultural contexts across different SNSs. The rapid evolution of SNSs also poses a challenge to the temporal relevance of the findings. While the qualitative approach offers in-depth insights, the authors suggest that future research should expand the sample size to include multiple SNSs and diverse user groups. They also recommend employing mixed-methods approaches that integrate both qualitative and quantitative research to enhance generalizability and provide quantitative validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social networking services (SNSs) address estrangement in cyberspace through their communication, recognition, and resonance features, yet they simultaneously generate new forms of alienation. This dual effect can both advance and hinder sustainability. This phenomenon is particularly evident in Xiaohongshu (RED), a platform widely used in China and beyond, which has evolved from providing consumption guidance to facilitating lifestyle sharing. This paper utilizes Hartmut Rosa’s Resonance Theory to explore resonance and alienation within RED, examining the multifaceted impact of SNSs on digital well-being and sustainability through qualitative methodologies, including netnography and thematic analysis. The study reveals that RED fosters material, spiritual, and social resonance, thereby enhancing digital well-being and sustainability. However, RED also generates alienation in these dimensions, which can impede sustainability. Moreover, the resonance and alienation generated by the RED platform affect not only its own sustainability but also broader environmental, social, economic, and cultural sustainability. Theoretically, this study constructs a sociological framework integrating resonance and alienation within SNSs to interpret digital well-being and sustainability. Practically, it offers recommendations for promoting sustainable practices among SNSs, addressing material, spiritual, and social dimensions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2024understanding,
  author = {Qingyue Wu and Lei Gu and Mingxiao Zhang and Huimei Liu},
  title = {{Understanding Dual Effects of Social Network Services on Digital Well-Being and Sustainability: A Case Study of Xiaohongshu (RED)}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16156709},
}
Figure