Understanding College Students’ Engagement in Mobile Reading for Sustainability in Education: A Case Study from China

Tingting Liu, Yingjie Li, Mengqin Feng, Yan Chen, Tianyi ZhangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the factors influencing mobile reading engagement among Chinese college students, revealing that while students have diverse needs (information, academic, social, emotional), their engagement is often hampered by an imbalance between these needs and their actual reading experience, self-efficacy, and adopted strategies. Understanding these nuances is crucial for leveraging mobile reading as a tool for sustainable education and lifelong learning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing prevalence of mobile devices has transformed reading habits, making mobile reading a potential avenue for sustainable education. However, much of the existing research on mobile reading has focused on younger readers and their comprehension, with less attention paid to the specific experiences and engagement factors of college students, particularly in China. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating what influences Chinese college students' engagement with mobile reading from their own perspectives, moving beyond task-based comprehension to a more holistic understanding of their motivations and challenges.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative content analysis approach with an inductive design. This involved conducting in-depth, open-ended interviews with 30 college students in Shanghai who reported reading on mobile devices for less than 2 hours per day. The interviews were transcribed and analyzed to identify patterns, themes, and categories related to students' motivations, experiences, and challenges with mobile reading. This data-driven approach allowed for the exploration of emergent themes without being constrained by a pre-existing theoretical framework.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 30 college students in Shanghai through semi-structured interviews. Prior to the interviews, a pre-questionnaire was administered to a larger group of 624 college students to identify individuals who met the criteria for mobile reading frequency (less than 2 hours per day). This larger group served as a screening pool for selecting the interview participants. No other external datasets were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Entertainment: Contrary to assumptions that mobile reading is primarily for entertainment, this study found that Chinese college students engage with it for a diverse range of needs, including information acquisition, academic purposes, social interaction, and emotional well-being.
  • The "Imbalance" Effect: A central finding is the "imbalance between needs and engagement effect." Students often have strong motivations for mobile reading, but their actual engagement is frequently hindered by factors like their reading experience, self-efficacy, and the strategies they employ.
  • Reading Experience is Multifaceted: Students' reading experience isn't just about the content; it's also about the device, the platform, and the environment. Issues like screen glare, small font sizes, and constant notifications can negatively impact their experience.
  • Self-Efficacy Matters: Confidence in one's ability to read and comprehend on mobile devices is a significant factor. Many students express low self-efficacy due to distractions and the fragmented nature of mobile reading.
  • Strategies are Key to Bridging the Gap: While students face challenges, many actively employ reading strategies (e.g., note-taking, highlighting, summarizing) to mitigate negative effects and improve their comprehension, especially for academic purposes.

Key Results

The study identified four primary motivational needs driving mobile reading engagement:

  • Information Needs: The most frequently cited motivation, encompassing staying updated on current affairs, news, and general knowledge.
  • Academic Needs: Including research, learning materials, and expanding academic knowledge.
  • Social Needs: Connecting with others, sharing recommendations, and participating in reading communities.
  • Emotional Needs: Relaxation, stress relief, and mood regulation.

However, these motivations were often counteracted by challenges related to:

  • Reading Experience: Issues like poor retention, eye strain, and distractions from social media notifications.
  • Reading Self-Efficacy: Students often lacked confidence in their ability to comprehend deeply due to the nature of mobile reading.
  • Reading Strategies: While some students effectively used strategies, others struggled, leading to difficulties in processing information.

Specifically, information needs were the most prevalent motivation across both undergraduate and postgraduate students. Reading self-efficacy and reading experience were identified as the most significant factors affecting engagement. Postgraduate students, on average, mentioned academic needs more frequently than undergraduates.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge the limitations of a small sample size (N=30) and a limited data collection period. The study's focus on students who read for less than 2 hours daily might also limit the generalizability of findings to more frequent mobile readers.

Future work could explore these themes with larger and more diverse participant groups. The authors also suggest the need to improve college students' awareness of copyright and payment for high-quality mobile reading resources, develop their information literacy through library initiatives, and design more interactive and auxiliary reading apps that cater to both academic and social needs. Further research could also investigate how to effectively cultivate students' autonomous reading and learning abilities in the context of mobile technology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mobile reading is viewed as a promising pathway to reading with sustainable education goals. At present, there have been many studies on the mobile reading of young readers and their reading comprehension by testing their task-based comprehension, but not much attention has been paid to the mobile reading of college students in China and the factors of reading engagement from readers’ perspectives. With the aim to investigate the factors that affect college students’ engagement in mobile reading, this study used interviews with open-ended questions and followed a qualitative content analysis design with an inductive and exploratory approach. The participants of this study were thirty college students with diverse majors out of three universities in Shanghai, China. They were selected from a pre-questionnaire, and these students (N = 30) were chosen from those who read on mobile devices for less than 2 h on average per day (N = 276). The results revealed that the college students perceived a variety of factors affecting their engagement in mobile reading, including the following: four motivational needs (information needs, academic needs, social needs, emotional needs), reading experience, reading efficacy, and reading strategies. It has been assumed that the most common factor that leads to the engagement of college students in mobile reading is the intention to be entertained. The investigation of this study has different results. Even the students who spent the minimum average time mobile reading used it with diverse needs in mind. Nevertheless, students’ reading experience, reading self-efficacy, and reading strategies indicated that sometimes they had difficulties engaging in mobile reading. These difficulties resulted from an imbalance between their needs and their engagement: whether they obtained what they needed. Considering that mobile reading could be an effective way to assist college students’ independent learning and sustainable development in future, it is necessary to understand the factors of mobile reading and rethink how to avoid difficulties to improve the mobile reading engagement of college students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023understanding,
  author = {Tingting Liu and Yingjie Li and Mengqin Feng and Yan Chen and Tianyi Zhang},
  title = {{Understanding College Students’ Engagement in Mobile Reading for Sustainability in Education: A Case Study from China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15032848},
}
Figure