Uncovering the neurological substrates underlying restlessness in cluster headache - A functional MRI study

Shu‐Ting Chen, Chia‐Chun Chiang, Yung-Lin Chen, S.-h. Tseng, Mei‐Chun Chen, C. Geoffrey Lau, Jr‐Wei WuThe Journal of Headache and Pain 2025 · DOI

Abstract: Our fMRI findings suggest that the neurological substrates of restlessness in CH involve the LC and SNpc rather than the core aggression network. Weakened connectivity from the SNpc to the superior frontal cortex may represent the downstream pathway contributing to restlessness in CH.

Introduction

Cluster headache (CH), often referred to as the "suicide headache," is defined by its excruciating intensity and a unique behavioral hallmark: restlessness. Patients during an attack frequently exhibit agitation, pacing, or rocking. While the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3) identifies restlessness as a core diagnostic feature, its neurological origin has remained poorly understood. This study sought to determine if restlessness is a simple reaction to extreme pain or if it is driven by specific neurological substrates, potentially involving the "core aggression circuit" or other brainstem-mediated pathways.

Methods and Patient Selection

The researchers conducted a prospective study at Taipei Veterans General Hospital and Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital. A total of 64 patients were initially screened, with 24 patients ultimately completing the challenging in-bout fMRI study.

Flowchart of patient recruitment and exclusion criteria for the fMRI study.

Patients were categorized into "restlessness" (N=14) and "non-restlessness" (N=10) groups based on consistent symptoms across multiple bouts. fMRI scans were performed during the ictal (active pain) or peri-ictal phases. To standardize the analysis of unilateral headaches, brain images were "flipped" so that the "pain-side" was consistent across the dataset. The analysis included ROI-to-ROI and ROI-to-voxel functional connectivity assessments, focusing on 32 regions associated with CH pathophysiology and aggression.

Key Insights and Results

The study's findings challenge the hypothesis that restlessness is driven by the traditional aggression circuit (amygdala and hypothalamus). Instead, two key neurological pathways were identified:

  • The LC-SNpc Bridge: There was a significant increase in functional connectivity between the non-pain-side locus coeruleus (LC) and the pain-side substantia nigra pars compacta (SNpc) (p-FDR = 0.016). The LC is a primary source of norepinephrine related to arousal, while the SNpc is a dopaminergic hub for motor control.
  • Loss of Frontal Inhibition: Seed-based analysis revealed decreased connectivity between the pain-side SNpc and the pain-side superior frontal gyrus (SFG) (p = 0.037). The SFG is critical for executive function and impulse control, suggesting that restlessness results from a failure of the frontal cortex to inhibit motor agitation.

Importantly, these findings were independent of headache severity or depression scores, reinforcing the idea that restlessness is a distinct neurological feature of the disease.

Discussion and Future Directions

These results suggest that restlessness in CH is driven by a specific brainstem-frontal circuit. The increased coupling between the LC and SNpc, combined with weakened top-down control from the SFG, provides a neurobiological framework for understanding this distressing symptom.

While the study is limited by a relatively small sample size (N=24) and the logistical difficulty of ictal scanning, it points toward new therapeutic targets. Future research using high-resolution neuromelanin-sensitive imaging may further clarify the role of small brainstem nuclei like the LC in CH pathophysiology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our fMRI findings suggest that the neurological substrates of restlessness in CH involve the LC and SNpc rather than the core aggression network. Weakened connectivity from the SNpc to the superior frontal cortex may represent the downstream pathway contributing to restlessness in CH.
BibTeX
@article{chen2025uncovering,
  author = {Shu‐Ting Chen and Chia‐Chun Chiang and Yung-Lin Chen and S.-H. Tseng and Mei‐Chun Chen and C. Geoffrey Lau and Jr‐Wei Wu},
  title = {{Uncovering the neurological substrates underlying restlessness in cluster headache - A functional MRI study}},
  journal = {The Journal of Headache and Pain},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s10194-025-02209-7},
}
Figure