Uncertainty Theory-Based Resilience Analysis for LEO Satellite Communication Systems

Ji Ma, Rui Kang, Ruiying Li, Qingyuan Zhang, Liang Liu, Xuewang WangSymmetry 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel resilience analysis framework for Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite communication systems (LEO-SCS) that accounts for both aleatory (random) and epistemic (uncertainty due to lack of knowledge) uncertainties. By developing an "uncertain satellite network evolution model" and a "belief resilience measure," the authors provide a more realistic assessment of LEO-SCS resilience, crucial for designing robust future satellite networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

LEO satellite communication systems, like Starlink and OneWeb, are increasingly vital for global connectivity. However, their complex nature, with numerous satellites and dynamic interconnections, makes them susceptible to various disruptions, such as satellite failures or signal interruptions. Existing methods for analyzing system resilience often struggle to handle the inherent uncertainties in these systems. Specifically, LEO-SCS face:

  • Aleatory uncertainties: These are natural random variations, such as the timing of satellite failures.
  • Epistemic uncertainties: These arise from a lack of complete knowledge, particularly during the development phase, leading to uncertainty in performance parameters like processing delays.

Current resilience measures typically address only one type of uncertainty or use models that don't fully capture the dynamic topology changes and epistemic uncertainties of LEO-SCS. This gap hinders effective resilience design and strategy development for these critical systems.

Methods

The paper proposes a new approach based on uncertainty theory, a mathematical framework designed to handle epistemic uncertainty. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Belief Resilience Measure: This new measure quantifies system resilience by considering the "chance" that the system meets its service requirements under disruptions, explicitly incorporating both aleatory and epistemic uncertainties. It's built upon the concept of "belief instantaneous availability," which measures the system's ability to perform its function at a given time.
  • Uncertain Satellite Network Evolution Model: This model captures the dynamic nature of LEO-SCS. It accounts for:
  • Dynamic Topology: The network structure changes over time due to satellite movement and failures.
  • Epistemic Uncertainty in Performance: Specifically, processing delays are modeled as uncertain variables, reflecting limited data during development.
  • Satellite Failures and Recoveries: An evolution rule is defined to simulate how satellite failures and the subsequent use of backup strategies (in-orbit and ground) alter the network topology.
  • Resilience Evaluation Method: This method integrates the uncertain network model and the belief resilience measure. It involves simulating the LEO-SCS's end-to-end delay under various disruption scenarios and calculating the belief instantaneous availability to ultimately determine the system's resilience.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses simulated data based on defined parameters for a hypothetical LEO-SCS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Uncertainty Theory is Crucial for LEO-SCS Resilience: The paper strongly advocates for uncertainty theory as the appropriate framework for LEO-SCS resilience analysis, as it can simultaneously handle the random nature of failures and the lack of precise knowledge about system performance.
  • Dynamic Topology and Epistemic Uncertainty are Intertwined: The model's strength lies in its ability to represent how satellite failures dynamically alter the network topology while also acknowledging the inherent uncertainty in processing delays.
  • Recovery Time is the Dominant Factor: The analysis highlights that satellite recovery time, influenced by backup strategies, is the most critical factor affecting system resilience. Faster recovery directly translates to higher resilience.
  • In-Orbit Backups Offer Significant Gains: Increasing the number of in-orbit backups provides substantial resilience improvements, especially in the initial stages (e.g., from 1 to 2 backups). This is because they offer quicker recovery compared to ground backups.
  • Satellite Orbital Lifetime Matters: A longer satellite orbital lifetime reduces the probability of failure, thereby indirectly improving system resilience.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates its methodology using a simulated Walker constellation LEO-SCS with 48 satellites.

  • Belief Instantaneous Availability: Under ideal conditions, availability remains high (0.994-1). However, under actual conditions with satellite failures, availability degrades significantly, with recovery times varying based on backup strategies.
  • Impact of Backup Strategies:
    • When two co-orbiting satellites failed, the system recovered quickly using in-orbit backups. However, when the second satellite failed and the in-orbit backup was already consumed, recovery was significantly delayed by the need for a ground backup.
  • In dual satellite failure scenarios, over 90% of cases involved at least one ground backup, highlighting the reliance on slower recovery mechanisms.
  • Resilience Improvement: Table 6 shows that increasing the number of in-orbit backups and extending satellite orbital lifetimes significantly improves resilience. For instance, with a 7-year satellite lifetime and 3 in-orbit backups, resilience reaches 0.9973.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Real-World Scenarios: The study focuses on specific types of disruptions (satellite failures) and assumes certain distributions for failure and recovery times. Real-world scenarios might involve more complex disruptions and varied uncertainty distributions.
  • Scalability: While the methodology is demonstrated on a 48-satellite system, assessing the resilience of massive LEO constellations (hundreds or thousands of satellites) presents a significant computational challenge.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into quickly and accurately assessing the resilience of these giant satellite systems. Additionally, exploring more sophisticated backup strategies and considering other types of disruptions would be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{ma2022uncertainty,
  author = {Ji Ma and Rui Kang and Ruiying Li and Qingyuan Zhang and Liang Liu and Xuewang Wang},
  title = {{Uncertainty Theory-Based Resilience Analysis for LEO Satellite Communication Systems}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/sym14081568},
}
Figure