Uncertainty in Contrastive Learning: On the Predictability of Downstream Performance

Shervin Ardeshir, Navid AzizanarXiv 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel methods to quantify the uncertainty of embeddings generated by contrastive learning models. By analyzing the distribution of embeddings and their local consistency, the authors demonstrate that this uncertainty measure can predict a data point's performance on downstream tasks, offering a crucial step towards safer deployment of these powerful models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep learning models, particularly those trained with contrastive learning on massive datasets, achieve remarkable performance. However, deploying these models in safety-critical applications requires understanding when they might fail. Contrastive learning, which learns representations by pulling similar data points together and pushing dissimilar ones apart in an embedding space, lacks explicit labels for individual data points. This makes it challenging to adapt traditional uncertainty estimation techniques, which often rely on direct output probabilities or confidence scores. The core problem this paper tackles is how to reliably estimate the uncertainty of a single data point's embedding from a pre-trained contrastive model, and whether this uncertainty can predict its performance on downstream tasks.

Methods

The authors propose three main uncertainty measures:

  • Per-Sample Feature Variation ($\delta$): This method measures the variability of an embedding when the input data point is subjected to various transformations (augmentations) used during contrastive training. A high variation suggests the model is less certain about the embedding's location. This method is particularly appealing as it only requires access to the pre-trained model and can be applied at inference time without needing the original training data.
  • Embedding Distribution Estimation ($p_{emb}$): This approach focuses on understanding how "familiar" the model is with a particular region of the embedding space. It involves estimating the distribution of embeddings from the training data.
  • Density ($p_{emb}$): This sub-component estimates the density of training data embeddings, indicating how well-represented a region is.
  • Consistency ($p_{emb, \kappa, \tau}^{k,T}$): This sub-component further refines the density by considering the consistency of class labels among the k-nearest neighbors in the embedding space. This requires access to training data labels.
  • Ensembled Embedding Distribution ($p_{emb-ens}$): This method combines the per-sample feature variation with the embedding distribution estimation, treating the different transformations as creating an ensemble of embeddings.

These measures are designed to capture different aspects of uncertainty: aleatoric (inherent difficulty of a sample) and epistemic (model's ignorance about a sample's location).

Datasets

The paper uses the following datasets for training and evaluation:

  • Training Datasets: CIFAR10, CIFAR100.
  • Downstream Tasks/Evaluation Datasets: CIFAR10, CIFAR100, CUBS2011, SVHN.

The authors pre-train models on CIFAR10/CIFAR100 and then evaluate their uncertainty measures on these same datasets (in-distribution) and on CUBS2011 and SVHN (out-of-distribution).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Uncertainty Predicts Downstream Performance: The most significant insight is that uncertainty estimated from the embedding space directly correlates with the model's performance on downstream tasks for that specific data point. This is a crucial finding for making contrastive models more reliable.
  • Feature Variation is a Simple Yet Effective Measure: The per-sample feature variation ($\delta$) is surprisingly effective and computationally efficient, requiring only the pre-trained model. This makes it a practical tool for uncertainty estimation.
  • Density and Consistency Complement Each Other: While density alone can indicate out-of-distribution samples (epistemic uncertainty), incorporating label consistency helps in understanding sample difficulty (aleatoric uncertainty).
  • Out-of-Distribution Detection: The proposed methods, particularly density-based measures, are effective at distinguishing between in-distribution and out-of-distribution samples, a key aspect of epistemic uncertainty.
  • Model Agnosticism: The feature variation method is model-agnostic, meaning it can be applied to any pre-trained contrastive model without needing to retrain or modify it.

Key Results

  • The proposed uncertainty measures, especially $p_{emb}$ and $p_{emb-ens}$, show strong correlations with downstream accuracy, achieving competitive AUROC scores for both aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty detection.
  • For aleatoric uncertainty (predicting sample difficulty), measures like $p_{emb}$ and $p_{emb-ens}$ achieved AUROC scores in the range of 0.7 to 0.9 across various setups.
  • For epistemic uncertainty (out-of-distribution detection), $p_{emb}$ generally performed best, with AUROC scores often exceeding 0.9.
  • The feature variation measure ($\delta$) also showed promising results, particularly for aleatoric uncertainty, demonstrating its utility even without access to training data.
  • The study found that for measures involving GMMs, performance often stabilized beyond a certain number of components (e.g., 20-30), suggesting a practical limit to complexity.
  • The number of augmentations had a diminishing return effect, with 2-3 augmentations often being sufficient for good performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependency on Training Data: Some of the more effective measures (e.g., $p_{emb, \kappa, \tau}^{k,T}$) require access to the labeled training dataset, limiting their applicability to scenarios where this data is available.
  • Assumption of In-Distribution Test Sets: The paper notes that the assumption that all test data from a known dataset is strictly "in-distribution" might not always hold. Future work could explore more nuanced definitions of uncertainty that account for this.
  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: While the paper explores the effect of parameters like the number of GMM components and the consistency threshold ($\tau$), further investigation into optimal hyperparameter selection across diverse scenarios could be beneficial.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors suggest that their work can be extended to decide between different pre-trained models or to guide sample weighting policies during downstream fine-tuning. This opens avenues for practical applications in model selection and training optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

The superior performance of some of today's state-of-the-art deep learning models is to some extent owed to extensive (self-)supervised contrastive pretraining on large-scale datasets. In contrastive learning, the network is presented with pairs of positive (similar) and negative (dissimilar) datapoints and is trained to find an embedding vector for each datapoint, i.e., a representation, which can be further fine-tuned for various downstream tasks. In order to safely deploy these models in critical decision-making systems, it is crucial to equip them with a measure of their uncertainty or reliability. However, due to the pairwise nature of training a contrastive model, and the lack of absolute labels on the output (an abstract embedding vector), adapting conventional uncertainty estimation techniques to such models is non-trivial. In this work, we study whether the uncertainty of such a representation can be quantified for a single datapoint in a meaningful way. In other words, we explore if the downstream performance on a given datapoint is predictable, directly from its pre-trained embedding. We show that this goal can be achieved by directly estimating the distribution of the training data in the embedding space and accounting for the local consistency of the representations. Our experiments show that this notion of uncertainty for an embedding vector often strongly correlates with its downstream accuracy.
BibTeX
@misc{ardeshir2022uncertainty,
  author = {Shervin Ardeshir and Navid Azizan},
  title = {{Uncertainty in Contrastive Learning: On the Predictability of Downstream Performance}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2207.09336},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.09336},
}
Figure