Uncertainty Feasible Region Analysis for Microgrids in the Coordination with Distribution System Considering Interactive Power Deviation

Dong Hao, Peng Lu, Xiang Jiang, Xu Chen, Puyan Wang, Junpeng ZhuAlgorithms 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for analyzing the "Uncertainty Feasible Region" (UFR) of microgrids (MGs) when they coordinate with the larger distribution grid. By allowing for controlled deviations in power exchange between the MG and the upper-level grid (ULG), the method effectively expands the MG's operational flexibility and improves its ability to integrate renewable energy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources (like solar and wind) into power grids presents a significant challenge. These sources are intermittent and unpredictable, making traditional grid management more complex. Microgrids (MGs) are seen as a solution, offering localized energy generation, storage, and consumption to enhance grid stability and reliability. However, coordinating MGs with the broader distribution network requires a robust way to understand their operational boundaries under uncertainty. Specifically, the paper addresses the need to quantify the range of acceptable power fluctuations and deviations for MGs operating within a day-ahead scheduling framework, while also considering the dynamic interactions with the upper-level grid (ULG). Existing methods often struggle with high-dimensional problems and may not fully capture the flexibility offered by allowing controlled power deviations between the MG and the ULG.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an Outer Approximation Cutting (OAC) method for UFR analysis. This approach tackles the complexity of high-dimensional feasible regions by iteratively "cutting away" infeasible areas from an initial, larger space. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Two-Stage Operation Model: The paper models the MG operation in two stages: day-ahead (DA) for optimal economic dispatch and intra-day (ID) for dynamic adjustments and UFR analysis.
  • Interactive Power Deviation Factor (IPDF): A novel concept that allows for controlled deviations in the power exchange between the MG and the ULG during the intra-day period. This IPDF essentially treats these deviations as an additional flexible resource for the MG.
  • Robust Optimization and Duality Theory: The UFR problem is framed using robust optimization principles. Duality theory is then employed to transform the problem into a more tractable form, particularly by converting minimization problems into maximization problems and vice-versa.
  • Umbrella Constraints: To improve computational efficiency, the method identifies and utilizes "umbrella constraints." These are a minimal set of constraints that preserve the optimal solution, effectively eliminating redundant constraints and reducing the dimensionality of the problem.
  • Linearization for Commercial Solvers: The method transforms the problem into a linear form, allowing it to be solved using standard commercial optimization software like IBM ILOG CPLEX.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a "typical Transformer area MG" as an example, with parameters provided in Table 1 and operational data illustrated in Figure 3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility through Deviation: Allowing controlled deviations in power exchange between the MG and the ULG (via the IPDF) significantly expands the MG's operational flexibility. This is a crucial insight, as it treats these deviations as a valuable resource akin to controllable units.
  • OAC for Efficiency: The Outer Approximation Cutting method, combined with umbrella constraint identification, offers a more efficient way to analyze high-dimensional feasible regions compared to traditional inner approximation methods. It avoids the potential for missed boundary information and speeds up computation.
  • UFR as a Planning Tool: The UFR analysis provides a theoretical basis for understanding the renewable energy consumption capacity of an MG, directly informing day-ahead dispatch scheduling and improving grid integration strategies.
  • Volume as a Metric: Using the volume of the feasible region as an indicator of the MG's capacity to handle uncertainties is a practical and intuitive approach.

Key Results

  • Expanded UFR with IPDF: The study demonstrates that allowing interactive power deviations (higher IPDF values) significantly expands the volume of the Uncertainty Feasible Region. For instance, increasing the IPDF from 0.01 to 0.2 led to a substantial increase in the feasible region's volume (from 0.4779 to 3.2187, in arbitrary units).
  • Computational Speedup: The use of umbrella constraint identification reduced the computation time. For the example case, it showed a reduction from 11.0945 seconds to 8.0235 seconds when umbrella constraints were identified.
  • Validation: The proposed method was validated through simulations on a typical MG scenario, demonstrating its effectiveness in characterizing the UFR under interactive power deviation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linearity Assumption: The strong duality assumption used in the method relies on the linearity of the model.
  • Energy Storage Not Considered: The current model does not explicitly incorporate the complexities of energy storage systems.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should focus on incorporating energy storage into the model by moving away from discretization and adopting a continuous modeling approach. This would allow for a more comprehensive analysis of MG operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The coordination of microgrid (MG) and distribution is an emerging trend for future development. This paper proposes an uncertainty feasible region (UFR) analysis method based on outer approximation cutting (OAC) under the coordination of MG and distribution. Firstly, an optimal economic dispatch scheduling is obtained. It serves as the basis for the intraday analysis of UFR. Drawing on the concepts of robust optimization, a method for determining the intra-day UFR is proposed. Subsequently, the problem is transformed using duality theory by identifying umbrella constraints, ultimately linearizing the problem to enable its solution by commercial software. In the intra-day analysis of the feasible region, the interactive power deviation between the MG and the upper-level grid (ULG) is allowed, which is represented by an interactive power deviation factor (IPDF). Different factors represent varying sizes of controllable resources, and a larger factor positively affects the size of the feasible region, and the volume is used to represent the size of the feasible region. The UFR defined in this paper provides a theoretical basis for renewable energy consumption capacity corresponding to the day-ahead dispatch scheduling. The effectiveness of the proposed method is validated by simulation results in a typical MG scenario.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2025uncertainty,
  author = {Dong Hao and Peng Lu and Xiang Jiang and Xu Chen and Puyan Wang and Junpeng Zhu},
  title = {{Uncertainty Feasible Region Analysis for Microgrids in the Coordination with Distribution System Considering Interactive Power Deviation}},
  booktitle = {Algorithms},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/a18030142},
}
Figure