Uncertainty-aware Risk Assessment of Robotic Systems via Importance Sampling

Woo-Jeong Baek, Tom Philip Huck, Joschka Haas, Jonas Lewandrowski, Tamim Asfour, Torsten KrögerarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the evolving landscape of Human-Robot Collaboration (HRC), ensuring safety is no longer just about physical barriers. As robots move into shared workspaces, safety engineers must account for the inherent unpredictability of complex systems. Traditional safety assessment tools, such as Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) and Reliability Block Diagrams (RBD), have long served as the industry standard. However, these methods typically treat failures as discrete, binary events—either a sensor is functional or it has failed.

This paper argues that such a binary view is insufficient for modern robotics. Real-world risks often emerge from subtle measurement uncertainties—spatial noise in a laser scanner or temporal jitter in a communication network. While these do not constitute a "failure" in the traditional sense, their accumulation can lead to catastrophic collisions. This research introduces a probabilistic framework that models these uncertainties as continuous distributions and utilizes an advanced sampling technique to assess risk efficiently.

The Challenge of Rare Events

Assessing safety risks in robotics is fundamentally a "rare event" problem. In a well-designed system, accidents are infrequent. If one were to use standard Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to estimate the probability of a collision, thousands or even millions of simulations might be required to observe a single accident. This computational burden makes it nearly impossible to gain statistically significant insights into the specific combinations of uncertainties that trigger dangerous encounters.

Methodology: A Four-Step Pipeline

To address the sparsity of accident data, the authors propose a pipeline that shifts the focus from uniform sampling to "Importance Sampling" (IS). This method acts as a statistical magnifying glass, focusing computational resources on the most dangerous regions of the parameter space.

Overview of the uncertainty-aware risk assessment pipeline.
  1. Uncertainty Modeling: Following the "Guide to the Evaluation of Uncertainty in Measurement" (GUM), the researchers define spatial uncertainties ($u_s$) and temporal uncertainties ($u_t$) as continuous probability distributions.
  2. Simulation Environment: Scenarios are implemented in CoppeliaSim, a high-fidelity robotics simulator. The modeled uncertainties are injected directly into the robot's perception and control loops.
  3. Grid-based Importance Sampling (IS): This is the core innovation. The process occurs in two phases:
  4. Learning Phase: A preliminary batch of standard MC samples is used to identify "critical" regions—areas in the uncertainty grid where accidents are most likely to occur.
  5. Importance Phase: The algorithm partitions the uncertainty space into a grid and "over-samples" the high-risk cells identified in the first phase.
  6. Statistical Weighting: To maintain accuracy, the results are re-weighted based on their original probability density. This allows the calculation of the "Variance in Approximation Error" (VAE), providing a measure of confidence in the risk estimate.

Experimental Scenarios

The framework was validated across three distinct simulation scenarios designed to mimic common industrial HRC tasks:

  • Scenario A (Evasive Maneuvers): A robot arm must detect an approaching human and move to a safe configuration.
  • Scenario B (Collaborative Conveyor): A human and a robot work side-by-side, reaching for objects on a moving belt. This scenario highlights the risks of spatial overlap in shared workspaces.
  • Scenario C (Mobile Navigation): A warehouse robot navigates through a corridor while avoiding a human pedestrian.
Simulation of a human-robot collaborative task on a conveyor belt (Scenario B).

Key Results and Engineering Insights

The study yielded several critical findings for the design of safe robotic systems:

Efficiency Gains

In Scenarios A and C, the grid-based IS significantly outperformed standard MC sampling. For the mobile robot scenario, the VAE was reduced from $1.6 \times 10^{-3}$ to $7.4 \times 10^{-4}$. This means the proposed method provides a much more reliable risk profile with fewer simulation runs.

Identifying Safety Thresholds

The method allows engineers to identify exact "tipping points" for safety. For instance, the researchers found that in their HRC setup, if temporal uncertainty (latency) exceeds 4 seconds, the probability of a dangerous event reaches 100%, regardless of spatial precision.

Informed Component Selection

By mapping specific uncertainty levels to risk probabilities, this framework enables a "safety-by-design" approach. If a project must meet a specific safety integrity level (e.g., risk probability $< \lambda$), engineers can use this data to determine the maximum allowable noise for their sensors. This prevents over-engineering (buying unnecessarily expensive sensors) or under-engineering (using sensors that cannot guarantee safety).

Conclusion and Future Work

While the grid-based IS approach offers a powerful tool for risk assessment, it is currently sensitive to manual tuning parameters like grid resolution. Future research will focus on automating these parameters to make the tool more accessible to safety practitioners. Additionally, the authors plan to test the framework in more complex, multi-robot environments to ensure its generalizability to large-scale industrial deployments. By treating uncertainty as a continuous variable rather than a binary failure, this work paves the way for more robust and statistically sound safety standards in robotics.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce a probabilistic approach to risk assessment of robot systems by focusing on the impact of uncertainties. While various approaches to identifying systematic hazards (e.g., bugs, design flaws, etc.) can be found in current literature, little attention has been devoted to evaluating risks in robot systems in a probabilistic manner. Existing methods rely on discrete notions for dangerous events and assume that the consequences of these can be described by simple logical operations. In this work, we consider measurement uncertainties as one main contributor to the evolvement of risks. Specifically, we study the impact of temporal and spatial uncertainties on the occurrence probability of dangerous failures, thereby deriving an approach for an uncertainty-aware risk assessment. Secondly, we introduce a method to improve the statistical significance of our results: While the rare occurrence of hazardous events makes it challenging to draw conclusions with reliable accuracy, we show that importance sampling -- a technique that successively generates samples in regions with sparse probability densities -- allows for overcoming this issue. We demonstrate the validity of our novel uncertainty-aware risk assessment method in three simulation scenarios from the domain of human-robot collaboration. Finally, we show how the results can be used to evaluate arbitrary safety limits of robot systems.
BibTeX
@misc{baek2023uncertainty,
  author = {Woo-Jeong Baek and Tom Philip Huck and Joschka Haas and Jonas Lewandrowski and Tamim Asfour and Torsten Kröger},
  title = {{Uncertainty-aware Risk Assessment of Robotic Systems via Importance Sampling}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.14068},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14068},
}
Figure