Uncertainties in direct dark matter detection in light of Gaia's escape velocity measurements

Youjia Wu, Katherine Freese, Chris Kelso, Patrick Stengel, Monica ValluriJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Direct detection experiments have set increasingly stringent limits on the cross section for spin-independent dark matter-nucleon interactions. In obtaining such limits, experiments primarily assume the standard halo model (SHM) as the distribution of dark matter in our Milky Way. Three astrophysical parameters are required to define the SHM: the local dark matter escape velocity, the local dark matter density and the circular velocity of the sun around the center of the galaxy. This paper studies the effect of the uncertainties in these three astrophysical parameters on the XENON1T exclusion limits using the publicly available DDCalc code. We compare limits obtained using the widely assumed escape velocity from the RAVE survey and the newly calculated escape velocity by Monari et al. using Gaia data. Our study finds that the astrophysical uncertainties are dominated by the uncertainty in the escape velocity (independent of the best fit value) at dark matter masses below 6 GeV and can lead to a variation of nearly 6 orders of magnitude in the exclusion limits at 4 GeV. Above a WIMP mass of 6 GeV, the uncertainty becomes dominated by the local dark matter density, leading to uncertainties of factors of ~10 (3) at 6 (15) GeV WIMP mass in the exclusion limits. Additionally, this work finds that the updated best fit value for the escape velocity based on Gaia data leads to only very minor changes to the effects of the astrophysical uncertainties on the XENON1T exclusion limits.

Introduction

The search for Dark Matter (DM) in the form of Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) relies on detecting the tiny energy deposited when a WIMP scatters off a nucleus in an underground detector. Experiments like XENON1T have pushed the boundaries of sensitivity, yet interpreting their null results requires a robust model of the dark matter distribution in the Milky Way.

The Standard Halo Model (SHM) is the benchmark used by most experimental collaborations. It is characterized by three key parameters: the local DM density ($\rho_\chi$), the circular velocity of the Sun ($v_0$), and the galactic escape velocity ($v_{esc}$). However, these are not fundamental constants; they are measured with inherent uncertainties. This study investigates how these astrophysical uncertainties propagate into the exclusion limits set by direct detection experiments, particularly in the low-WIMP-mass regime where sensitivity is most volatile.

Methodology

To quantify the impact of these uncertainties, the researchers employed DDCalc, a tool for performing likelihood analyses of direct detection data. They focused on the 2017 results from the XENON1T experiment. The core of the analysis involved a Monte Carlo simulation, drawing $10^5$ random samples of the astrophysical parameters to observe the resulting spread in exclusion limits.

A critical comparison was made between two sources for the galactic escape velocity: the older RAVE survey and the more recent measurements derived from Gaia-DR2 (specifically the analysis by Monari et al.). The study modeled these parameters using both uniform and Gaussian distributions to identify which factors dominate the error budget across different mass scales.

Results: The Low-Mass Sensitivity Cliff

The most striking finding is the extreme sensitivity of low-mass WIMP searches to the assumed escape velocity. For WIMPs with masses below 6 GeV, only the fastest particles in the halo possess enough kinetic energy to trigger a nuclear recoil above the detector's threshold. This "high-velocity tail" is directly truncated by the escape velocity ($v_{esc}$).

Exclusion limits for spin-independent cross-sections showing the massive uncertainty bands at low WIMP masses for both Monari (Gaia) and RAVE models.

As shown in the figure above, at a WIMP mass of 4 GeV, the uncertainty in $v_{esc}$ can cause the exclusion limit to vary by nearly six orders of magnitude. This means a reported limit of $10^{-40}$ cm² could realistically be as high as $10^{-34}$ cm² depending on the galactic model. This "cliff" effect makes low-mass dark matter searches uniquely vulnerable to our imperfect knowledge of the Milky Way's gravitational potential.

Statistical Distribution and Gaia's Impact

When examining the statistical distribution of these limits, the spread is significant. The histogram of frequency versus cross-section at low masses reveals a wide, non-Gaussian distribution that underscores the difficulty in assigning a single "correct" limit.

Frequency distribution of the spin-independent cross-section exclusion limits at a WIMP mass of 4 GeV, illustrating the statistical spread caused by astrophysical uncertainties.

Interestingly, while the Gaia mission provides a more precise and slightly higher best-fit value for the escape velocity compared to RAVE, the relative uncertainty remains comparable. Consequently, while the absolute position of the exclusion curve shifts slightly with Gaia data, the overall magnitude of the astrophysical uncertainty remains a dominant factor.

Above the 6 GeV threshold, the source of uncertainty shifts. In this higher-mass regime, the local dark matter density ($\rho_\chi$) becomes the primary driver of error. However, the impact is much smaller than in the low-mass regime, leading to uncertainties of a factor of ~10 at 6 GeV, which further reduces to a factor of ~3 at 15 GeV.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study highlights that for light dark matter, astrophysical uncertainties are not just minor corrections but can fundamentally alter the interpretation of experimental results. While the Gaia satellite has improved our measurements of stellar kinematics, the inherent limitations of the Standard Halo Model—such as the assumption of a smooth, isothermal halo—persist.

Future work must move beyond the SHM to incorporate galactic substructures like the "Gaia Sausage" or tidal debris, which could further complicate the velocity distribution. Additionally, treating astrophysical parameters as nuisance parameters within the experimental likelihoods could provide a more statistically rigorous way to account for these uncertainties in future dark matter searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Direct detection experiments have set increasingly stringent limits on the cross section for spin-independent dark matter-nucleon interactions. In obtaining such limits, experiments primarily assume the standard halo model (SHM) as the distribution of dark matter in our Milky Way. Three astrophysical parameters are required to define the SHM: the local dark matter escape velocity, the local dark matter density and the circular velocity of the sun around the center of the galaxy. This paper studies the effect of the uncertainties in these three astrophysical parameters on the XENON1T exclusion limits using the publicly available DDCalc code. We compare limits obtained using the widely assumed escape velocity from the RAVE survey and the newly calculated escape velocity by Monari $et$ $al.$ using Gaia data. Our study finds that the astrophysical uncertainties are dominated by the uncertainty in the escape velocity (independent of the best fit value) at dark matter masses below 6 GeV and can lead to a variation of nearly 6 orders of magnitude in the exclusion limits at 4 GeV. Above a WIMP mass of 6 GeV, the uncertainty becomes dominated by the local dark matter density, leading to uncertainties of factors of $\sim$10 (3) at 6 (15) GeV WIMP mass in the exclusion limits. Additionally, this work finds that the updated best fit value for the escape velocity based on Gaia data leads to only very minor changes to the effects of the astrophysical uncertainties on the XENON1T exclusion limits.
BibTeX
@article{wu2019uncertainties,
  author = {Youjia Wu and Katherine Freese and Chris Kelso and Patrick Stengel and Monica Valluri},
  title = {{Uncertainties in direct dark matter detection in light of Gaia's escape velocity measurements}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2019/10/034},
}
Figure