Unambiguous determination of the neutrino mass hierarchy using reactor neutrinos

Yufeng Li, Jun Cao, Y. F. Wang, Liang ZhanPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Determination of the neutrino mass hierarchy in a reactor neutrino experiment at the medium baseline is discussed. Observation of the interference effects between the $\Delta m_{31}^2$ and $\Delta m_{32}^2$ oscillations enables a relative measurement independent of the knowledge of the absolute mass-squared difference. With a 20 kton liquid scintillator detector of the $3\%/\sqrt{E (\text{MeV})}$ energy resolution, the Daya Bay II experiment at a baseline of $\sim 50$ km from reactors of total thermal power 36 GW can determine the mass hierarchy at a confidence level of $\Delta \chi^2_{\text{MH}} \sim 10-12$ ($3-3.5\sigma$) in six years. This sensitivity is robust against energy nonlinearity and can be further enhanced to $\sim 4\sigma$ by incorporating precise measurements from long-baseline accelerator experiments.

Introduction

The neutrino mass hierarchy (MH) remains one of the most fundamental unknowns in particle physics. While we have established that neutrinos possess mass and oscillate between three states ($m_1, m_2, m_3$), the specific ordering of these masses is yet to be determined. The "Normal Hierarchy" (NH) posits that $m_3$ is the heaviest state, whereas the "Inverted Hierarchy" (IH) suggests it is the lightest. Resolving this ambiguity is essential for understanding the origin of neutrino mass and the role of neutrinos in the early universe.

Traditionally, MH determination has relied on matter effects—the interaction of neutrinos with electrons as they travel through the Earth. However, such measurements are often entangled with the unknown CP-violating phase. This paper proposes a "cleaner" alternative: utilizing the interference between oscillation modes in reactor antineutrinos at a "medium" baseline of approximately 50 km.

Methodology

The proposed experiment, Daya Bay II (now JUNO), utilizes a 20-kiloton liquid scintillator detector. The methodology focuses on the "beat" pattern produced by the interference of two fast oscillation frequencies, $\Delta m^2_{31}$ and $\Delta m^2_{32}$.

Experimental Configuration

The simulation assumes a detector with a challenging but necessary energy resolution of $3\%/\sqrt{E(\text{MeV})}$. The detector is positioned roughly 50 km from the Yangjiang and Taishan reactor complexes in China, which provide a total thermal power of 36 GW. The analysis accounts for standard reactor flux models, the actual geospatial distribution of multiple reactor cores to account for "baseline smearing," and a self-calibration technique using the multiple peaks of the oscillation spectrum to mitigate detector response imperfections.

Sensitivity and Results

The success of the MH determination depends critically on the experimental baseline and the detector's energy resolution.

Sensitivity of the mass hierarchy determination as a function of baseline (left) and energy resolution (right).

As illustrated in Figure 2, the optimal sensitivity ($\Delta \chi^2$) peaks at a baseline of approximately 52 km. The right panel demonstrates that the sensitivity is highly sensitive to energy resolution; a degradation from 3% to 4% significantly reduces the ability to distinguish between hierarchies.

Real-World Constraints

In practice, the spatial distribution of reactor cores introduces "smearing" that can wash out the interference signal.

Impact of baseline distribution (left) and the $\chi^2$ analysis for true and false mass hierarchies (right).

Figure 4 (left) shows that the real spatial distribution of cores reduces the sensitivity by approximately $\Delta \chi^2 \sim 5$ compared to an ideal point-source distribution. However, the right panel of Figure 4 shows that even with these effects, the true and false hierarchy hypotheses remain statistically separable.

Synergy with Accelerator Experiments

A key insight of this work is the potential for synergy between reactor and accelerator experiments. By incorporating precise measurements of the effective mass-squared difference $\Delta m^2_{\mu\mu}$ from long-baseline muon neutrino disappearance experiments (like T2K or NOvA), the confidence level of the MH determination can be significantly boosted. With a 1% precision on $\Delta m^2_{\mu\mu}$, the combined sensitivity can reach $\Delta \chi^2 \sim 15-20$, or approximately $4\sigma$, within six years of data collection.

Conclusion

The medium-baseline reactor neutrino approach offers a robust and independent method for determining the neutrino mass hierarchy. While it demands high energy resolution and careful baseline optimization, the ability to self-calibrate against energy nonlinearity and the significant boost from combining data with accelerator experiments make it a highly promising path toward resolving this fundamental puzzle in particle physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Determination of the neutrino mass hierarchy in a reactor neutrino experiment at the medium baseline is discussed. Observation of the interference effects between the $\ensuremath{\Delta}{m}_{31}^{2}$ and $\ensuremath{\Delta}{m}_{32}^{2}$ oscillations enables a relative measurement independent of the knowledge of the absolute mass-squared difference. With a 20 kton liquid scintillator detector of the $3%/\sqrt{E\text{ }\text{ }(\mathrm{MeV})}$ energy resolution, the Daya Bay II experiment at a baseline of $\ensuremath{\sim}50\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{km}$ from reactors of total thermal power 36 GW can determine the mass hierarchy at a confidence level of $\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\mathrm{MH}}^{2}\ensuremath{\sim}(10\textdiv{}12)$ ($3\textdiv{}3.5\ensuremath{\sigma}$) in six years after taking into account the real spatial distribution of reactor cores. We show that the unknown residual energy nonlinearity of the liquid scintillator detector has limited impact on the sensitivity due to the self-calibration of small oscillation peaks. Furthermore, an extra increase of $\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\mathrm{MH}}^{2}\ensuremath{\simeq}4(9)$ can be obtained, by including the precise measurement of the effective mass-squared difference $\ensuremath{\Delta}{m}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\mu}}^{2}$ of expected relative error 1.5% (1%) from ongoing long-baseline muon neutrino disappearance experiments. The sensitivities from the interference and from absolute measurements can be cross-checked. When combining these two, the mass hierarchy can be determined at a confidence level of $\ensuremath{\Delta}{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\mathrm{MH}}^{2}\ensuremath{\sim}(15\textdiv{}20)$ ($4\ensuremath{\sigma}$) in six years.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2013unambiguous,
  author = {Yufeng Li and Jun Cao and Y. F. Wang and Liang Zhan},
  title = {{Unambiguous determination of the neutrino mass hierarchy using reactor neutrinos}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.88.013008},
}
Figure