Ultrastructural analysis of adult mouse neocortex comparing aldehyde perfusion with cryo fixation

Natalya Korogod, Carl C.h. Petersen, Graham KnotteLife 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

Standard chemical fixation for electron microscopy of brain tissue causes significant shrinkage and distortion, leading to a misrepresentation of the extracellular space and cellular arrangements. This study demonstrates that rapid cryo-fixation preserves a more physiologically accurate ultrastructure, revealing a larger extracellular space, more docked synaptic vesicles, and less intimate glial coverage of synapses and blood vessels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electron microscopy (EM) is crucial for understanding the intricate structure of the nervous system, particularly at the synaptic level. However, the conventional method for preparing brain tissue for EM, chemical fixation using aldehydes, is known to introduce artifacts. Specifically, it causes significant tissue shrinkage and distortion, most notably a reduction in the extracellular space (ECS). This distortion can lead to misinterpretations of cellular morphology, the relative volumes of different cellular compartments, and the spatial relationships between neurons and glial cells, potentially impacting our understanding of neuronal communication and brain function. The paper aims to quantify these differences by comparing the ultrastructure of adult mouse neocortex prepared with standard chemical fixation versus rapid cryo-fixation.

Methods

The study employed two primary fixation methods for adult mouse neocortex:

  • Chemical Fixation: This involved standard cardiac perfusion with buffered paraformaldehyde and glutaraldehyde, followed by osmium tetroxide and uranyl acetate staining, and embedding in Durcupan resin. This is the widely accepted method for EM of brain tissue.
  • Cryo-Fixation: This utilized rapid, high-pressure freezing (HPF) of small tissue pieces (approx. 200 µm thick) using liquid nitrogen and high pressures. This method aims to vitrify water, preventing ice crystal formation and thus minimizing structural distortion. The HPF samples were then freeze-substituted in acetone with osmium tetroxide and embedded in resin at low temperatures.

Quantitative analyses were performed using serial section electron microscopy (TEM) and focused ion beam scanning electron microscopy (FIBSEM). Measurements included cortical volume changes, extracellular space volume fraction, glial volume fraction, neurite volume fraction, synapse density, distance of synaptic vesicles from the presynaptic membrane, astrocytic coverage of blood vessels, and synaptic vesicle morphology.

Datasets

The study used adult mouse (C57 BL/6, 7–10 weeks old) neocortex tissue. No specific public datasets were used for training or evaluation. The data generated in this study is derived from the experimental preparation and imaging of these mouse brains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chemical Fixation is a Major Distorter: The most striking insight is the profound impact of chemical fixation on brain ultrastructure. It's not just a minor artifact; it fundamentally alters the perceived volume and spatial organization of neural tissue.
  • Extracellular Space is Dramatically Reduced: Chemical fixation shrinks the ECS by approximately six-fold, creating a false impression of tightly packed cells and membranes. This has significant implications for understanding diffusion of neurotransmitters and other molecules.
  • Glial Cells are Misrepresented: Astrocytic processes appear to swell and more intimately ensheath synapses and blood vessels in chemically fixed tissue, masking their true, less intimate relationship in vivo.
  • Synaptic Vesicle Dynamics are Altered: Cryo-fixation reveals a more physiological distribution of synaptic vesicles, with a distinct population docked at the presynaptic membrane, suggesting it better captures the readily releasable pool. Chemical fixation seems to distort this arrangement.
  • Synapse Classification Artifacts: The characteristic morphological distinctions between excitatory (Type 1) and inhibitory (Type 2) synapses, particularly the shape of vesicles, appear to be induced by chemical fixation rather than being inherent properties.

Key Results

  • Cortical Volume Reduction: Chemical fixation caused a significant total volume shrinkage of the somatosensory neocortex by approximately 30%. This was measured as a 16% reduction in cortical thickness and 18% shrinkage along the rostrocaudal axis.
  • Extracellular Space: Cryo-fixed neuropil had six times more extracellular space (15.4%) compared to chemically fixed neuropil (2.47%).
  • Glial Volume: Astrocytic volume fraction was significantly higher in chemically fixed tissue (14.4%) compared to cryo-fixed tissue (7.4%).
  • Synapse Density: Chemically fixed neuropil showed a 38% increase in synapse density compared to cryo-fixed neuropil, likely a consequence of tissue shrinkage.
  • Astrocytic Coverage: Chemically fixed capillaries showed significantly greater glial coverage (94.4%) by astrocytic endfeet compared to cryo-fixed capillaries (62.9%).
  • Synaptic Vesicle Distribution: Cryo-fixation revealed a higher density of synaptic vesicles within 0-30 nm of the presynaptic membrane compared to chemical fixation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cryo-Fixation Volume Limitations: A significant limitation of cryo-fixation is its inability to preserve large volumes of brain tissue due to ice crystal formation beyond a depth of 10-20 microns. This means that large-scale ultrastructural analysis will likely continue to rely on chemical fixation.
  • Freeze Substitution Artifacts: While HPF minimizes ice crystal damage, the subsequent freeze-substitution process, which involves replacing water with acetone, might introduce some artifacts, although the authors suggest it preserves ultrastructure better than traditional dehydration.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further computational simulations are needed to fully understand the implications of the enlarged perisynaptic space revealed by cryo-fixation on neurotransmitter diffusion and synaptic crosstalk. The findings also highlight the need to re-evaluate existing ultrastructural data obtained using chemical fixation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Analysis of brain ultrastructure using electron microscopy typically relies on chemical fixation. However, this is known to cause significant tissue distortion including a reduction in the extracellular space. Cryo fixation is thought to give a truer representation of biological structures, and here we use rapid, high-pressure freezing on adult mouse neocortex to quantify the extent to which these two fixation methods differ in terms of their preservation of the different cellular compartments, and the arrangement of membranes at the synapse and around blood vessels. As well as preserving a physiological extracellular space, cryo fixation reveals larger numbers of docked synaptic vesicles, a smaller glial volume, and a less intimate glial coverage of synapses and blood vessels compared to chemical fixation. The ultrastructure of mouse neocortex therefore differs significantly comparing cryo and chemical fixation conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{korogod2015ultrastructural,
  author = {Natalya Korogod and Carl C.H. Petersen and Graham Knott},
  title = {{Ultrastructural analysis of adult mouse neocortex comparing aldehyde perfusion with cryo fixation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.05793},
}
Figure