Ultrasound probe tilt impedes the needle-beam alignment during the ultrasound-guided procedures

Qingxiang Mao, Hai‐Tao He, Yuangang Lu, Yi Hu, Zhen Wang, Maoxiang Gan, Hong Yan, Liyong ChenScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the factors complicating needle visualization during ultrasound-guided in-plane procedures. Forty-nine residents performed needle insertions into a simulated vessel under four conditions: Neutral, 45°-rotation, 45°-tilt, and a combination of both. Results indicate that tilting the probe significantly increases needle redirections and insertion time, while rotation alone has a negligible effect. These findings suggest that vertical tilting disrupts the operator's spatial alignment more severely than horizontal rotation.

Introduction

In ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia, the "in-plane" technique is the gold standard for safety, allowing real-time visualization of the entire needle path. Success depends on maintaining the needle within the extremely thin ultrasonic beam. In clinical practice, clinicians frequently rotate or tilt the probe to optimize target visualization. However, these adjustments alter the ergonomic relationship between the operator, the needle, and the imaging plane. This study aims to quantify how these common maneuvers impact procedural efficiency and needle visibility.

Methodology

The researchers recruited 49 anesthesia residents with varying experience levels for a randomized phantom study. Participants were tasked with puncturing a simulated blood vessel in a gel phantom.

Experimental setup and the four ultrasound views: (a) Neutral, (b) 45°-Rotation, (c) 45°-Tilt, and (d) Combined rotation and tilt.

The performance was evaluated across four distinct probe orientations:

  1. Neutral: Probe aligned with the visual axis; beam vertical.
  2. 45°-Rotation: Probe rotated 45° relative to the operator's visual axis.
  3. 45°-Tilt: Beam tilted 45° away from the vertical line.
  4. Combined: Both 45° rotation and 45° tilt.

Metrics included total insertion time, number of needle redirections, and "needle visibility" (the fraction of time the needle tip remained visible on the ultrasound screen).

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed a stark contrast between the effects of rotation and tilt. While rotation alone did not significantly degrade performance compared to the Neutral view, tilting the probe proved to be the primary obstacle to successful needle-beam alignment.

The Impact of Probe Tilt

In the 45°-tilt view, the median insertion time rose to 39 seconds (compared to 16 seconds in the Neutral view), and the number of redirections increased from 0 to 2.

A detailed view of the 45°-tilt orientation (view 'c'), which significantly hindered operator performance by creating a spatial mismatch.

The Combined Effect

The combination of rotation and tilt was the most challenging, with insertion times skyrocketing to 113 seconds and needle visibility dropping to a mere 6% of the procedure time. Over 75% of participants identified this as the most difficult scenario. Interestingly, even experienced clinicians (those with over 40 prior procedures) struggled with tilted views, suggesting that experience does not automatically confer the spatial reasoning required to overcome these ergonomic challenges.

Discussion

The difficulty associated with tilting likely stems from a "line of sight" conflict. Operators typically maintain a vertical needle path; when the beam is tilted, this path no longer aligns with the imaging plane unless the operator also adjusts their body position or head tilt. When the geometry becomes complex, as in the combined view, the needle easily "disappears" from the thin ultrasonic plane.

Conclusion

To improve procedural safety and efficiency, clinicians should prioritize maintaining a neutral probe orientation whenever possible. When a tilt is necessary to visualize a target, operators must consciously adjust their physical position to realign their visual axis with the tilted ultrasonic plane. Future training should emphasize these ergonomic adjustments to mitigate the risks associated with poor needle-beam alignment.

Summary updated

Abstract

The objective of this study was to identify the factors that complicate the needle visualization in ultrasound-guided in-plane needling procedures. Forty-nine residents were recruited and randomized to insert the simulated blood vessel with four different views including Neutral (the long axis of the probe along the visual axis and the ultrasonic beam vertical to the surface of gel phantom), 45°-rotation (45° angle between the long axis of probe and the operator's visual axis), 45°-tilt (45° angle between the ultrasonic beam and the surface of gel phantom) and 45°-rotation plus 45°-tilt of probe. Number of needle redirections, insertion time, and needle visibility were documented and compared for each procedure. When the residents faced with 45°-tilt view, the needle redirections (2 vs 0) and insertion time increased significantly (39 vs 16) compared with that of the Neutral view. When faced with 45°-rotation plus 45°-tilt view, the residents' performance decreased further as compared with that of the 45°-tilt view and the Neutral view. However, there was no performance difference between the Neutral view and 45°-rotation view. In conclusion, during ultrasound-guided in-plane procedures, tilting the ultrasound probe may increase the difficulty of needle-beam alignment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2021ultrasound,
  author = {Qingxiang Mao and Hai‐Tao He and Yuangang Lu and Yi Hu and Zhen Wang and Maoxiang Gan and Hong Yan and Liyong Chen},
  title = {{Ultrasound probe tilt impedes the needle-beam alignment during the ultrasound-guided procedures}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-81354-w},
}
Figure