Ultrasonography of salivary glands -- a highly specific imaging procedure for diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome.

Dirk Wernicke, Heidemarie Hess, Erika Gromnica‐Ihle, Andreas Krause, Wolfgang SchmidtPubMed 2008

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that ultrasonography of the major salivary glands, specifically looking for parenchymal inhomogenicity and reduced submandibular gland volume, is a highly specific and valuable non-invasive tool for diagnosing Sjögren's syndrome (SS). The findings suggest ultrasonography can serve as a practical first-line imaging modality for SS detection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sjögren's syndrome (SS) is a chronic autoimmune disease primarily affecting exocrine glands, leading to dryness of the eyes (keratoconjunctivitis sicca) and mouth. While ocular manifestations are relatively easy to diagnose, assessing salivary gland involvement is more challenging. Current accepted methods include minor salivary gland biopsy, parotid sialography, salivary gland scintigraphy, and unstimulated salivary flow examination. However, sialography is invasive, and scintigraphy, while sensitive, can lack specificity. This leaves a need for accurate, non-invasive, and readily available diagnostic tools for salivary gland involvement in SS. The paper aims to validate ultrasonography as such a tool.

Methods

The researchers conducted a study on 316 consecutive patients with rheumatic diseases, categorizing them into primary SS, secondary SS, sicca symptoms (without meeting SS criteria), and asymptomatic controls. They employed real-time ultrasonography with a 5-10 MHz linear transducer to examine the major salivary glands (parotid and submandibular). Key parameters assessed were:

  • Volume: Calculated using a standard formula (length x width x depth x 0.5).
  • Parenchymal Echogenicity: Compared to the thyroid gland and surrounding soft tissue. A normal gland is isoechoic to the thyroid.
  • Parenchymal Inhomogenicity: Graded from 0 (normal) to II (evident, diffuse hypoechoic areas > 2 mm).

The study also involved statistical analysis, including Mann-Whitney U-tests for group comparisons and Receiver-Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves to evaluate diagnostic accuracy. Interobserver agreement was assessed to ensure reliability.

Datasets

The study utilized a cohort of 316 patients with rheumatic diseases, categorized as:

  • Primary SS (n=57)
  • Secondary SS (n=33)
  • Sicca symptoms (n=78)
  • Asymptomatic Controls (n=148)

This dataset was collected from a tertiary care institution and included patients who provided informed consent. The study did not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather evaluated existing diagnostic criteria using a substantial patient cohort.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parenchymal Inhomogenicity as a Key Indicator: The study strongly reinforces that evident parenchymal inhomogenicity (Grade II) in at least two major salivary glands is a highly specific ultrasonographic finding for SS. This aligns with previous research but is validated here in a larger cohort.
  • Submandibular Volume Reduction is Significant: Unlike parotid gland volume, submandibular gland volume was found to be significantly reduced in patients with primary and secondary SS. This suggests that changes in submandibular gland size are a more reliable ultrasonographic marker than parotid gland size.
  • Ultrasonography's High Specificity: The paper highlights the remarkable specificity of ultrasonography for diagnosing SS, particularly for parenchymal inhomogenicity (96.1% for sicca symptoms, 100% for asymptomatic controls). This makes it a strong candidate for ruling out SS when findings are normal.
  • Association with Autoantibodies: In primary SS, parenchymal inhomogenicity showed a strong correlation with the presence of ANA and anti-Ro/anti-La antibodies, suggesting a link between these immunological markers and structural salivary gland changes.
  • Potential for First-Line Screening: Given its non-invasiveness, availability, and cost-effectiveness compared to MR imaging, ultrasonography is proposed as a valuable first-line imaging modality for patients presenting with symptoms suggestive of SS.

Key Results

  • Sensitivity and Specificity of Parenchymal Inhomogenicity: Ultrasonographic detection of evident parenchymal inhomogenicity in 2 or more major salivary glands showed a sensitivity of 63.1% for primary SS and 63.6% for secondary SS, with a high specificity of 96.1% for sicca symptoms and 100% for asymptomatic controls.
  • Submandibular Volume Reduction: Patients with primary and secondary SS showed a mean submandibular gland volume reduction of approximately 30% compared to controls.
  • ROC Curve Analysis for Volume: A cutoff point of 3.0 ml for reduced submandibular gland volume yielded 93% specificity and 48% sensitivity for diagnosing SS.
  • Association with Disease Duration: Patients with grade II parenchymal inhomogenicity had a longer average disease duration in primary SS (7.8 years) compared to those without ultrasonographic changes (4.2 years).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Male Patient Data: The study acknowledges that due to the small number of male patients, possible sex-related differences in salivary gland volumes could not be definitively determined and warrant further investigation in consecutive studies.
  • Need for Second Imaging Modality: While ultrasonography is promising, the authors suggest that further investigation of salivary gland size by a second imaging technique (like MR imaging or CT) might be beneficial to confirm ultrasonographic findings.
  • Further Classification Criteria Integration: The paper proposes that subsequent studies should aim to integrate ultrasonographic findings into the classification criteria for SS, particularly by testing the properties of parenchymal inhomogenicity.
  • Sex-Specific Differences: The authors suggest future research should focus on analyzing sex-specific differences in salivary gland volumes, as this was limited by the cohort composition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ultrasonographic detection of parenchymal inhomogenicity of the major salivary glands and observation of reduced volume of the submandibular glands resulted in high specificities for diagnosis of primary and secondary SS. The data indicate that ultrasonography of major salivary glands is a noninvasive imaging procedure with high diagnostic value for the diagnosis of primary and secondary SS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wernicke2008ultrasonography,
  author = {Dirk Wernicke and Heidemarie Hess and Erika Gromnica‐Ihle and Andreas Krause and Wolfgang Schmidt},
  title = {{Ultrasonography of salivary glands -- a highly specific imaging procedure for diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2008},
}
Figure