Ultra-precise all-optical manipulation of neural circuits with multifunctional Cre-dependent transgenic mice

Hayley A. Bounds, Masato Sadahiro, William D. Hendricks, Marta Gajowa, Karthika Gopakumar, Daniel Quintana, Bosiljka Tasic, Tanya L. Daigle, Hongkui Zeng, Ian Antón Oldenburg, Hillel AdesnikbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new transgenic mouse line and a sophisticated all-optical pipeline that allows researchers to precisely control and simultaneously record neural activity in large populations of neurons. This breakthrough enables unprecedented investigation into how the complex patterns of neural firing, not just individual neuron activity, drive perception and behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the brain processes information and generates behavior hinges on deciphering the "neural code." This code isn't just about which neurons are active, but also how their firing rates are distributed across a population. While advanced techniques like two-photon (2p) calcium imaging and optogenetics allow us to observe and stimulate neurons with high precision, a major hurdle has been the inability to accurately translate calcium signals into precise firing rates and then use that information to write specific firing patterns back into the neural circuit. Existing methods struggle with the biological variability in how neurons respond to light and how their calcium signals reflect their activity, making it difficult to achieve fine-grained control over population-level activity.

Methods

The researchers tackled this challenge with two key innovations:

  1. A Novel Transgenic Mouse Line (Ai203): They engineered a new mouse line that, in a Cre-dependent manner, expresses a potent, fast-acting microbial opsin (ChroME) and a high-performance calcium indicator (GCaMP7s) as a single, soma-targeted fusion protein. This ensures reliable co-expression and targeted delivery of both the actuator and the sensor to the neuron's cell body, minimizing off-target effects.
  2. An All-Optical Read/Write Pipeline: They developed a multi-step calibration process that combines 2p holographic optogenetics with advanced imaging.
  3. Power Calibration: This step determines the precise laser power needed to reliably elicit a single spike in each individual neuron.
  4. Spike Calibration: This step maps the relationship between spike rate and the resulting calcium signal for each neuron, accounting for individual cell variability.
  5. Holographic Pattern Generation: Using the calibrated functions, they can then generate complex light patterns to precisely control the firing rate of multiple neurons simultaneously, effectively "writing" desired population activity vectors.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from the newly developed Ai203 transgenic mice, as well as comparisons with other established mouse lines (e.g., Vglut1-Cre, C57BL6 wildtype, Camk2a-tTA;tetO-GCaMP6s) and virally transduced models. No specific external datasets were used for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense; rather, the data generated from these experiments served as the basis for their analysis and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Tool for Precision Control: The Ai203 mouse line elegantly combines a powerful optogenetic actuator and a sensitive calcium reporter in a single, genetically encoded package, simplifying experimental design and improving reproducibility.
  • Bridging the Gap Between Calcium and Spikes: The developed calibration pipeline is crucial for overcoming the inherent variability in calcium imaging, allowing for accurate inference of firing rates and precise control of those rates.
  • Recreating Naturalistic Neural Activity: The ability to write specific population activity patterns, rather than just activating groups of neurons uniformly, opens the door to understanding how the geometry of neural representations influences computation and behavior.
  • In Vivo Precision: The system demonstrates high spatial and temporal precision for both reading and writing neural activity in awake, behaving animals, a critical step for studying complex brain functions.

Key Results

  • The Ai203 mice showed robust and specific expression of the ChroME-GCaMP7s fusion protein in targeted neurons.
  • 2p photostimulation in Ai203 mice reliably evoked spiking with high temporal precision (sub-millisecond jitter).
  • The all-optical pipeline successfully calibrated the spike-to-calcium signal transformation in individual neurons, with 80% of targeted cells being well-fit.
  • The system could accurately recreate visually evoked neural population activity patterns, achieving a mean cosine similarity of 0.61 ± 0.04 between recreated and natural patterns.
  • They demonstrated the ability to simultaneously activate nearly 50 neurons with a single hologram, with minimal activation of neighboring cells.
  • Ai203 mice performed comparably to wildtype mice on a visual detection task, indicating that transgene expression did not negatively impact basic visual function or learning.
  • Optogenetic stimulation in V1 of Ai203 mice could alter behavioral performance on the visual detection task.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sparsity of Expression: While the Ai203 line shows good expression in many cell types, it exhibits sparser expression in cortical excitatory neurons compared to some other transgenic lines. This might limit all-optical control and readout from a large fraction of neurons in certain experimental contexts.
  • Incomplete Transgene Coverage: The expression of the transgene is Cre-dependent and not uniformly distributed across all Cre+ cells, which could be a consideration for experiments requiring dense labeling.
  • Spike Timing Precision: While the system excels at controlling firing rates, recreating precise spike timing is currently limited by imaging frame rates and calcium sensor kinetics. The authors suggest incorporating faster imaging techniques, faster calcium sensors, or voltage sensors as future directions.
  • Potential Physiological Differences: In brain slices, opsin+ cells showed slightly more depolarized resting membrane potentials and altered miniature EPSC properties, which could be due to the transgene expression or represent a specific neuronal subtype. However, these differences did not appear to impact in vivo circuit function.
  • Future Directions: The authors envision this platform being particularly useful for probing the causal role of neural code geometry in computation and behavior, and for investigating how different dimensions of population activity influence perception and decision-making. They also suggest that the calibration approach could be combined with deconvolution algorithms to improve spike timing reconstruction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Determining which features of the neural code drive perception and behavior requires the ability to simultaneous read out and write in neural activity patterns with high precision across many neurons. All-optical systems that combine two photon (2p) calcium imaging and targeted 2p photostimulation enable the activation of specific, functionally defined groups of neurons in behaving animals. However, these techniques do not yet have the ability to reveal how the specific distribution of firing rates across a relevant neural population mediates neural computation and behavior. The key technical obstacle is the inability to transform single-cell calcium signals into accurate estimates of firing rate changes and then write in these cell-specific firing rate changes to each individual neuron in a targeted population. To overcome this challenge, we made two advances: first we introduce a new genetic line of mice for robust Cre-dependent co-expression of a high-performance calcium indicator and a potent soma-targeted microbial opsin. Second, using this line, we developed a pipeline that enables the read-out and write-in of precise population vectors of neural activity across a targeted group of neurons. The combination of the new multifunctional transgenic line and the photostimulation paradigm offer a powerful and convenient platform for investigating the neural codes of computation and behavior. It may prove particularly useful for probing causal features of the geometry of neural representations where the ability to directly control the topology of population activity is essential.
BibTeX
@misc{bounds2021ultra,
  author = {Hayley A. Bounds and Masato Sadahiro and William D. Hendricks and Marta Gajowa and Karthika Gopakumar and Daniel Quintana and Bosiljka Tasic and Tanya L. Daigle and Hongkui Zeng and Ian Antón Oldenburg and Hillel Adesnik},
  title = {{Ultra-precise all-optical manipulation of neural circuits with multifunctional Cre-dependent transgenic mice}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.05.463223},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure