Ultra-Large Silicon Diode for Characterizing Low-Intensity Radiation Environments

Kacper Biłko, Rubén García Alía, Sylvain Girard, Mario Sacristán Barbero, Matteo Cecchetto, C. Bélanger-Champagne, Matteo Brucoli, Salvatore Danzeca, Alex Hands, Pedro Martín‐Holgado, Yolanda Morilla, Amor Romero-Maestre, Marc Sebban, M. WidorskiIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers at CERN and partner institutions have demonstrated that an "ultra-large" commercial silicon diode (50 cm²) can monitor low-intensity radiation environments with unprecedented sensitivity. By providing full energy deposition spectra rather than simple event counts, this detector outperforms traditional SRAM-based monitors by five orders of magnitude, enabling rapid characterization of "quiet" areas like shielded accelerator alcoves or ground-level atmospheric radiation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In high-energy physics environments like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), monitoring radiation is critical for "Radiation Hardness Assurance"—ensuring that electronic systems don't fail due to particle strikes. Currently, CERN uses the RadMON system, which relies on SRAM (Static Random Access Memory) chips. These chips work by counting "Single Event Upsets" (bit flips).

However, as shielding improves and we look at "low-intensity" areas (like accelerator alcoves or even ground-level buildings), the radiation flux becomes so low that an SRAM monitor might only record a few dozen events in an entire year. This makes it impossible to get timely data or understand the specific energy distribution of the particles. There is a clear need for a detector that is sensitive enough to provide statistically significant data in hours or days, rather than months, while also revealing the "spectral fingerprint" of the radiation field.

Methods

The authors utilized a massive commercial silicon diode (Mirion PIPS detector) with an active area of 50 cm² and a thickness of 500 µm.

Key technical aspects include:

  • Readout Chain: Instead of a standard charge-sensitive amplifier, they used a broadband current-sensitive preamplifier (CIVIDEC C2-HV) coupled with a high-speed digitizer (1 GS/s). This allows for precise pulse-shape analysis and integration of the total deposited energy ($E_{dep}$) for every single strike.
  • Calibration: The system was calibrated at the Centro Nacional de Aceleradores (CNA) using monoenergetic proton and alpha beams (2–8 MeV) to determine a "correction factor" ($k$) for charge collection. They also performed dose-rate calibration using a Cobalt-60 gamma source.
  • Simulation Benchmarking: The experimental results were compared against FLUKA and Geant4 (G4SEE) Monte Carlo simulations. This allowed the team to decompose the energy spectra into specific nuclear reaction channels (e.g., elastic vs. inelastic scattering).

Datasets

The study evaluated the detector across four distinct radiation environments:

  1. Atmospheric Field: 55 days of continuous monitoring in a ground-level building at CERN (Geneva).
  2. Am-Be Source: A standard Americium-Beryllium neutron source at CERN’s CALLAB.
  3. TRIUMF-BL1B: A spallation neutron facility in Canada that mimics the atmospheric neutron spectrum but at much higher intensities.
  4. LINAC3: A CERN accelerator environment where they simulated a "beam loss" event by impacting an oxygen ion beam onto an aluminum target.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sensitivity Leap: The diode's detection cross-section is roughly 5 orders of magnitude larger than that of a typical SRAM-based monitor. This transforms radiation monitoring from a "waiting game" into a real-time diagnostic tool.
  • Energy Spectroscopy vs. Binary Counting: Unlike SRAMs, which only tell you if a strike happened, the diode provides the energy deposition distribution. This allows researchers to distinguish between different types of interactions (like $n,\alpha$ or $n,p$ reactions) and validate complex physics models.
  • Volume Matters: While smaller diodes have better energy resolution, the massive volume of this "ultra-large" diode is what enables the detection of rare, high-energy events in low-flux environments.
  • Validation of Monte Carlo Codes: The high-fidelity data provided a rare opportunity to benchmark FLUKA and Geant4 in the low-intensity regime, showing excellent agreement (within 25% for atmospheric neutrons).

Key Results

  • Atmospheric Monitoring: Over 55 days at ground level, the diode recorded 1035 events with energy depositions above 10 MeV. The measured event rate matched FLUKA simulations within 25%.
  • Cross-Section Comparison: The diode showed a detection cross-section of ~0.2–0.3 cm², compared to ~10⁻⁶ cm² for commercial SRAMs.
  • TRIUMF Consistency: The energy spectrum measured at the TRIUMF spallation source matched the ground-level atmospheric spectrum within 3% at high energies, confirming the facility's accuracy as an atmospheric proxy.
  • Accelerator Utility: In the LINAC3 test, the diode successfully characterized the radiation field from a beam loss, while the standard RadMON (SRAM) recorded zero bit flips because the flux was below its sensitivity threshold.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost and Complexity: The authors acknowledge that these diodes are significantly more expensive and require more sophisticated readout electronics than SRAM-based solutions. Consequently, they are not intended to replace RadMONs for mass deployment but rather to complement them in specific low-radiation zones.
  • Energy Resolution: The choice of a current-sensitive preamplifier (optimized for timing and high-rate environments) results in lower energy resolution compared to charge-sensitive amplifiers.
  • Future Applications: The authors suggest this technology is ideal for avionics and stratospheric measurements, where understanding the low-intensity neutron environment is critical for flight safety and electronics reliability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present applications of a large commercial silicon diode (50 cm<inline-formula xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <tex-math notation="LaTeX">$^{2}\,\,\times 500\,\,{\mu }\text{m}$ </tex-math></inline-formula>) for monitoring low-intensity radiation fields, together with benchmarks via Monte Carlo simulations. After energy calibration with monoenergetic proton and alpha beams in the 2–8-MeV range, we show that the detector is capable of measuring atmospheric radiation at the ground level, not only in terms of a total number of events but also through their energy deposition distribution. Focusing on the atmospheric-like neutron spectrum, we prove that the diode detection cross Section is more than five orders of magnitude larger with respect to static random access memory (SRAM)-based solutions and highlight the potential use cases in the accelerator’s radiation environment.
BibTeX
@article{biko2023ultra,
  author = {Kacper Biłko and Rubén García Alía and Sylvain Girard and Mario Sacristán Barbero and Matteo Cecchetto and C. Bélanger-Champagne and Matteo Brucoli and Salvatore Danzeca and Alex Hands and Pedro Martín‐Holgado and Yolanda Morilla and Amor Romero-Maestre and Marc Sebban and M. Widorski},
  title = {{Ultra-Large Silicon Diode for Characterizing Low-Intensity Radiation Environments}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/tns.2023.3337839},
}
Figure