Ultra-high resolution sampling with UAVs for optimising fractional woody cover characterisations in dryland savannahs

Ilias Symeonakis, Κωνσταντίνος Καράντζαλος, Erik Berg, Klaus Kellner2017

Abstract

Dryland savannahs are critical components of the global carbon cycle and provide essential ecosystem services. However, mapping the woody component of these landscapes is challenging due to the coarse resolution of satellite imagery relative to the fine-scale heterogeneity of the vegetation. This research addresses the "spatial gap" between traditional point-based validation and satellite-scale observations by employing a UAV-based 2D and 3D sampling strategy. By integrating ultra-high-resolution drone data with Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 imagery, the study demonstrates a significant improvement in the accuracy of fractional woody cover (FWC) mapping in the dryland savannahs of South Africa.

Introduction: The Challenge of Savannah Mapping

Dryland savannahs are complex ecosystems characterized by a continuous grass layer interspersed with trees and shrubs. In Southern Africa, these regions are increasingly affected by "bush encroachment"—the proliferation of unpalatable woody species at the expense of palatable grasses. This process not only threatens local livelihoods by reducing grazing land but also complicates global carbon emission models.

While Earth observation (EO) technologies are the only viable means for monitoring these vast expanses, they face a fundamental scaling problem. Satellite pixels from platforms like Landsat (30m) or Sentinel-2 (10m) are typically "mixed," containing a combination of woody vegetation, grasses, and bare soil. Traditional validation methods, which rely on point samples from aerial photography or Google Earth, often fail to accurately represent the actual fraction of woody cover within these pixels, leading to significant uncertainties in biomass and carbon estimates.

Methodology: Bridging the Spatial Gap

To overcome the limitations of traditional point-sampling, this study proposes a multi-tiered sampling strategy that utilizes Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) as a bridge between ground reality and satellite sensors.

UAV Data Acquisition and 3D Modeling

The researchers deployed UAVs over a 400 $km^2$ study area in the Northwest Province of South Africa. These drones collected ultra-high-resolution RGB imagery, which was processed into 2D mosaics and 3D structural models. The inclusion of 3D data is a critical innovation; while 2D imagery can struggle to distinguish between green grass and green shrubs, 3D structural data allows researchers to identify woody vegetation based on height and volume.

Scaling and Machine Learning

The high-resolution UAV data served as a "gold standard" to calibrate the coarser satellite imagery. The study tested the approach across two different spatial scales:

  • Landsat-8: 30m resolution
  • Sentinel-2: 10m resolution

Two machine learning classification algorithms—Random Forests (RF) and Support Vector Machines (SVM)—were evaluated to determine their effectiveness in translating satellite signals into accurate fractional woody cover maps.

Key Insights

Overcoming the Mixed Pixel Problem

The core finding of the research is that the "spatial gap" is the primary bottleneck in savannah mapping. By using UAV data to provide a more representative sample of what exists within a 10m or 30m pixel, the researchers were able to "train" the satellite models much more effectively than with traditional point samples.

The Value of 3D Structure

The integration of 3D mosaics proved to be a game-changer. In savannah environments, spectral signatures alone are often insufficient to separate vegetation types. The vertical dimension provided by UAV-derived 3D models offers the necessary depth to isolate woody cover from the surrounding herbaceous layer.

Fractional vs. Discrete Classification

Rather than simply classifying a pixel as "woodland" or "grassland," this methodology allows for the calculation of fractional woody cover. This provides a continuous percentage of woodiness per pixel (e.g., 35% cover), which is far more useful for precise carbon accounting and land degradation monitoring.

Results and Implications

The 2D/3D UAV-based sampling approach yielded consistently higher accuracy in FWC classification compared to traditional methods. The approach proved robust across both Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 platforms, suggesting that it can be integrated into various existing satellite monitoring workflows.

For land managers and policy makers in Southern Africa, this methodology offers a much-needed tool for monitoring bush encroachment and land degradation. By providing more accurate maps of woody vegetation, this research supports better-informed decisions regarding livestock management and carbon sequestration strategies.

Future Directions

While the UAV-integrated approach is highly effective, future work must address the challenges of scalability and cost. UAVs cover relatively small areas compared to the vastness of the African continent. Strategic deployment of UAV sampling sites will be necessary to extrapolate these high-accuracy results across larger regional or continental scales. Additionally, multi-temporal studies will be essential to track the progression of bush encroachment over years and decades.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dryland savannahs are crucial for understanding carbon cycling and storage and for their provision of ecosystem services. Globally, the accurate mapping of the woody savannah component and its characteristics is especially important as it provides input to carbon emissions models. Moreover, in the southern African region, the encroachment of unpalatable woody species over large expanses of palatable grasses has received a lot of attention as it directly affects the livelihoods of local populations. Over these scales, Earth observation technologies are seen as the only viable means for mapping and monitoring the characteristics of woody vegetation. However, the commonly applied sampling and validation approach incorporating point woody samples identified over aerial photography or very-high resolution data (e.g. via Google Earth) is problematic as the satellite data used for the mapping, with a pixel size of 10 – 30 m, rarely consists of pure woody vegetation. To bridge this spatial gap between what is identified in the point-based samples and what is included in the 10-30m pixel, we employ a UAV-based 2D and 3D sampling strategy. We incorporate point samples collected from Google Earth in a 400km2 area of the Northwest Province of South Africa together with UAV-collected RGB and 3D mosaics, in order to optimise the mapping of fractional woody cover. We test the approach using both Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 data in order to assess the applicability at both 10 and 30m scales. We also test the accuracy of two different machine learning classification approaches: random forests and support vector machines. Our 2D/3D UAV-based sampling approach provides higher fractional woody cover classification results than simply incorporating the ‘traditional’ point samples from aerial photography or Google Earth. Our suggested methodology can provide much needed assistance to fractional woody vegetation monitoring efforts in Southern African savannahs where the process is partly related with bush encroachment and land degradation.
BibTeX
@misc{symeonakis2017ultra,
  author = {Ilias Symeonakis and Κωνσταντίνος Καράντζαλος and Erik Berg and Klaus Kellner},
  title = {{Ultra-high resolution sampling with UAVs for optimising fractional woody cover characterisations in dryland savannahs}},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure