Ubiquitin Interacting Motifs: Duality Between Structured and Disordered Motifs

Matteo Lambrughi, Emiliano Maiani, Burcu Aykaç Fas, Gary S. Shaw, Birthe B. Kragelund, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Kaare Teilum, Gaetano Invernizzi, Elena PapaleoFrontiers in Molecular Biosciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Ubiquitin Interacting Motifs (UIMs), traditionally thought to be helical, can also exist in disordered states. This study reveals that UIMs exhibit a structural duality, with disordered UIMs offering increased versatility in protein interactions and potentially new cellular functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The prevailing view in protein science has long been that a protein's function is intrinsically tied to its well-defined three-dimensional structure. However, over the past two decades, the concept of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) has gained significant traction. These regions lack stable tertiary contacts, are highly dynamic, and often do not exhibit stable secondary structures. They are crucial for mediating interactions with multiple partners and orchestrating complex cellular pathways. Short linear motifs (SLiMs), often embedded within these disordered regions, play vital roles in modulating protein function.

One such motif, the Ubiquitin Interacting Motif (UIM), has been traditionally characterized by a conserved sequence signature and a propensity for forming stable helical structures, particularly when bound to ubiquitin. This paper investigates the structural propensities of UIMs, specifically questioning whether they always adopt helical conformations, even in their unbound state, or if they can also exist in disordered states, similar to other SLiMs. Understanding this structural plasticity is crucial for comprehending the full functional repertoire of UIMs and their role in the ubiquitination system and beyond.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining computational simulations and experimental data analysis:

  • Bioinformatic Analysis: Several sequence-based predictors (DynaMine, MFDp2, SPOT-Disorder2) were used to predict the disorder propensity and secondary structure of UIMs.
  • Replica-Exchange Molecular Dynamics (REMD) Simulations: This technique was used to explore the conformational landscape of the AT-3 C-terminus (residues 306-361). REMD allows for the simultaneous simulation of multiple replicas of the system at different temperatures, enabling the system to overcome energy barriers and sample a wider range of conformations. They tested four different combinations of protein force fields and water models to assess the robustness of their findings.
  • Well-Tempered Metadynamics (WT-metaD) Simulations: This method was used to further enhance sampling, particularly for exploring free energy landscapes. It involves adding a history-dependent potential to collective variables (CVs) that bias the system towards exploring less sampled regions. They used CVs related to the radius of gyration and the similarity of dihedral angles to an ideal alpha-helix.
  • NMR Chemical Shift Analysis: Existing NMR chemical shift data from various UIM-containing proteins were analyzed using the 82D predictor to estimate secondary structure propensity. They also recorded new NMR data for a construct of AT-3.
  • Helical Wheel Projections: This visualization technique was used to assess the amphipathic nature of UIM sequences when they adopt helical conformations.

Datasets

  • NMR Chemical Shift Data: The study utilized publicly available NMR chemical shift data from the Biological Magnetic Resonance Bank (BMRB) for several UIM-containing proteins, including AT-3 (UIM1, UIM2, UIM3), STAM1, STAM2, USP25 (UIM1 and UIM2), USP28, and RAP80 (UIM1 and UIM2). They also recorded new NMR data for AT-3182-291 (UIM1 and UIM2).
  • Experimental Structures of Ubiquitin-Bound UIMs: For comparison, they used experimentally determined structures of UIMs in complex with ubiquitin from other proteins (e.g., VPS27 UIM, S5a UIM1, S5a UIM2, RAP80 UIM1).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UIMs are not exclusively helical: Contrary to the traditional view, UIMs can exist in both stable helical and intrinsically disordered conformations in their unbound state. This "duality" is a key finding.
  • Disordered UIMs offer enhanced versatility: The disordered nature of some UIMs allows them to interact with a broader range of partners beyond just ubiquitin, potentially acting as recruitment points for other proteins.
  • Structural plasticity is functionally relevant: The ability of UIMs to adopt different conformations (helical vs. disordered) is not just an academic curiosity but has functional implications for protein-protein interactions and cellular roles.
  • Force field choice matters for disordered systems: The study highlights how different molecular dynamics force fields can lead to varying descriptions of disordered protein ensembles, emphasizing the importance of careful force field selection and validation against experimental data.
  • Disordered UIMs are not a barrier to binding: The research demonstrates that UIMs with low helical propensity in their free state can still effectively bind to ubiquitin, suggesting that disorder does not preclude interaction.

Key Results

  • Ataxin-3 UIM3 is predominantly disordered: Molecular dynamics simulations of the C-terminal region of ataxin-3 (AT-3306-361) revealed that the UIM3 motif within this region is largely disordered, with only a small fraction of the ensemble exhibiting helical propensity, primarily in the N-terminal region.
  • CHARMM22*2 force field best describes AT-3 UIM3 disorder: Among the tested force fields, CHARMM22*2, when combined with TIPS3P water, provided the most accurate representation of the disordered ensemble of AT-3306-361, as validated by comparison with experimental NMR chemical shifts.
  • UIMs exhibit a spectrum of disorder: Analysis of NMR data from various UIMs showed a range of helical propensities, with some UIMs (e.g., AT-3 UIM1, UIM2) being highly helical, while others (e.g., AT-3 UIM3, USP25 UIM2) displayed low helical content.
  • Disordered UIMs can sample bound-like conformations: The study found that disordered UIM3 could sample conformations that partially resemble ubiquitin-bound UIM structures, suggesting a role for conformational selection in their binding mechanism.
  • Sequence features correlate with disorder: Certain sequence characteristics, such as the presence of suboptimal residues for helix formation (e.g., threonine, valine), appear to be associated with the low propensity of some UIMs to adopt stable helical conformations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited sampling in REMD: The authors note that REMD simulations might have provided limited sampling and could still be biased by the initial helical conformation, leading them to rely more heavily on WT-metaD results.
  • Kinetics not accounted for: The current study focuses on equilibrium conformational ensembles. Future investigations should incorporate kinetic aspects to fully understand the mechanisms of interaction and conformational selection.
  • Further experimental validation: While NMR data was used for validation, further experimental studies, particularly those probing binding kinetics and affinities of disordered UIMs, would be beneficial.
  • Broader exploration of disordered UIMs: The paper identifies a new class of disordered UIMs and suggests that this structural duality might be a more general phenomenon. Future work could focus on characterizing more such UIMs and understanding their specific roles in various cellular processes.
  • Impact of post-translational modifications: The authors mention that post-translational modifications can modulate UIM helical propensity and binding preferences, suggesting this as an important area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ubiquitin is a small protein at the heart of many cellular processes, and several different protein domains are known to recognize and bind ubiquitin. A common motif for interaction with ubiquitin is the Ubiquitin Interacting Motif (UIM), characterized by a conserved sequence signature and often found in multi-domain proteins. Multi-domain proteins with intrinsically disordered regions mediate interactions with multiple partners, orchestrating diverse pathways. Short linear motifs for binding are often embedded in these disordered regions and play crucial roles in modulating protein function. In this work, we investigated the structural propensities of UIMs using molecular dynamics simulations and NMR chemical shifts. Despite the structural portrait depicted by X-crystallography of stable helical structures, we show that UIMs feature both helical and intrinsically disordered conformations. Our results shed light on a new class of disordered UIMs. This group is here exemplified by the C-terminal domain of one isoform of ataxin-3 and a group of ubiquitin-specific proteases. Intriguingly, UIMs not only bind ubiquitin. They can be a recruitment point for other interactors, such as parkin and the heat shock protein Hsc70-4. Disordered UIMs can provide versatility and new functions to the client proteins, opening new directions for research on their interactome.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lambrughi2021ubiquitin,
  author = {Matteo Lambrughi and Emiliano Maiani and Burcu Aykaç Fas and Gary S. Shaw and Birthe B. Kragelund and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Kaare Teilum and Gaetano Invernizzi and Elena Papaleo},
  title = {{Ubiquitin Interacting Motifs: Duality Between Structured and Disordered Motifs}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Molecular Biosciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmolb.2021.676235},
}
Figure