U.S. Children and Youth’s Physical Activities Inside and Outside of School PE: 1985 vs. 2012

Xiaochen Zhao, Weimo Zhu, Zezhao Chen, Sicong Ren, Xiong QinInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares physical activity (PA) trends in U.S. children and youth from 1985 to 2012, using two national surveys. It reveals shifts in popular activities, particularly a decline in swimming and a rise in running outside of school, while basketball remains dominant in school PE. The findings highlight the need for school curricula to emphasize lifelong, individual activities to better align with current youth preferences and combat rising obesity rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Childhood obesity is a growing public health concern, with physical activity (PA) levels showing a downward trend, especially during adolescence. Understanding what types of physical activities children and youth engage in, both within and outside of school physical education (PE), is crucial for developing effective interventions. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of how PA preferences and participation have changed over time and whether these changes differ across demographic groups (grade, sex, weight status). It aims to identify potential disconnects between school-based PA promotion and actual youth engagement, informing future curriculum development and public health strategies.

Methods

The researchers utilized a comparative approach, analyzing data from two large-scale national surveys: the 1985 National Children and Youth Fitness Study (NCYFS) and the 2012 NHANES National Youth Fitness Survey (NNYFS). They merged data from these surveys, focusing on participants aged 10-15 years. PA data was collected through questionnaires asking about participation in various activities both inside and outside of school PE. To ensure comparability, some adjustments were made to the PA lists, and Body Mass Index (BMI) was calculated using standardized methods to categorize participants into weight status groups (underweight, normal weight, overweight, obese). Statistical analysis involved descriptive statistics, ranking of PA preferences, and Spearman rank correlation coefficients to assess the relationship between in-school and out-of-school PA rankings.

Datasets

The study used two publicly available datasets:

  • 1985 National Children and Youth Fitness Study (NCYFS): This survey collected data on the fitness and physical activity of U.S. youth.
  • 2012 NHANES National Youth Fitness Survey (NNYFS): This survey, part of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, also collected data on physical activity patterns in children and youth.

The researchers matched and merged data from these two surveys, resulting in a combined sample of 6178 participants (3107 boys and 3071 girls).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting Trends in Popular Activities: While basketball consistently dominated in-school PE across both surveys, swimming's popularity outside of school plummeted from being the most popular in 1985 to being replaced by running in 2012. This suggests a significant change in how youth engage with PA outside of structured school environments.
  • Disconnect Between School and Out-of-School PA: The study found a moderate correlation between in-school and out-of-school PA preferences, but also noted "disconnections." This implies that what is taught or promoted in school PE may not fully align with what students choose to do in their free time, potentially impacting the development of lifelong PA habits.
  • Lifelong Individual PAs Gaining Traction: The research highlights a growing preference for lifelong, individual PAs among youth, with team sports becoming less dominant in out-of-school settings. This trend suggests a need for school curricula to adapt and incorporate more activities that can be sustained into adulthood.
  • Weight Status Matters: The study confirmed that weight status significantly influences PA preferences. Obese children and youth, for instance, showed different activity choices compared to their normal-weight peers, underscoring the importance of targeted PA recommendations for weight management.
  • Gendered Preferences Persist: While differences were not always stark, the study observed some gender-specific preferences, with boys leaning towards team sports and girls showing a tendency towards individual activities. This reinforces the need for "sex-friendly" PA programs.

Key Results

  • In-School PE: Basketball remained the most popular activity in school PE in both 1985 (83.6%) and 2012 (18.0%). Other popular activities in 1985 included jogging, baseball/softball, and volleyball. In 2012, soccer and baseball also featured prominently in school sports/PA clubs.
  • Out-of-School PA: Swimming was the most popular out-of-school activity in 1985 (85.7%), followed by bicycling. By 2012, running emerged as the most popular (26.9%), followed closely by basketball (26.4%) and walking (22.6%).
  • Demographic Differences: The study found that grade level, sex, and weight status all impacted PA preferences and participation. For example, obese students showed different preferences than normal-weight students, and boys and girls exhibited some distinct choices.
  • Correlation: The overall correlation between in-school and out-of-school PA rankings was moderately high in 1985 (0.702) but lower in 2012 (0.556), potentially due to differences in survey questionnaires.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Questionnaire Differences: The PA questionnaires used in 1985 and 2012 were not identical, which may have influenced comparability and the interpretation of "PA inside and outside of school PE."
  • PA Grouping: Some PA items were grouped (e.g., "play games," "backyard games"), potentially obscuring finer-grained preferences.
  • Seasonal/Regional Factors: Certain PAs might be affected by seasonal availability or regional differences, which could influence their ranking.
  • Self-Reported Data: The reliance on self-reported PA data is a known limitation, as recall bias can affect accuracy.
  • Time Lag: The surveys were conducted several years ago, and current PA trends might have evolved further.

Future work should focus on designing and integrating more lifelong and individual PAs into school PE curricula and community programs. There is a need to consider the specific needs and preferences of different demographic groups, particularly obese children and youth, to promote sustained physical activity for long-term health management. Further research could explore the impact of school environments and community resources on PA participation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was, by taking advantage of the rich data from two U.S. national fitness surveys, to examine the physical activity (PA) students engaged in, both inside and outside school physical education (PE), determine if there are differences by grade, sex, and weight status, and if there was a change between 1985 and 2012. The data from the 1985 National Children and Youth Fitness Study (NCYFS) and the 2012 NHANES National Youth Fitness Survey (NNYFS) were matched, merged (<i>N</i> = 6178, 3107 boys and 3071 girls), and analyzed. It was found that basketball remained the most popular PA inside school PE across both surveys. Swimming was the most popular PA outside of school PE in 1985, but was replaced by running in 2012. Although PA taught and promoted inside of school PE and that such PA practiced outside were moderately correlated across the surveys, some disconnections were noticed. The impact of grade, sex, and weight status on PA preference and participation was also confirmed. What is needed is to the design and integration of more lifelong and individual PAs in future school PE curricula and school and community children and youth sport and PA programs.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2021u,
  author = {Xiaochen Zhao and Weimo Zhu and Zezhao Chen and Sicong Ren and Xiong Qin},
  title = {{U.S. Children and Youth’s Physical Activities Inside and Outside of School PE: 1985 vs. 2012}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18020398},
}
Figure