Typicality-Based Stability and Privacy

Raef Bassily, Yoav FreundarXiv 2016 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces "typical stability," a new algorithmic stability notion that relaxes the strict requirements of differential privacy. It allows for more flexible data analysis by not demanding bounded query sensitivity or independent data samples, while still providing guarantees on generalization error and privacy for certain data distributions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional methods for ensuring data privacy and controlling generalization error in data analysis, particularly differential privacy, often rely on two strong assumptions: queries must have bounded sensitivity (meaning a small change in input data only causes a small change in output), and data samples must be independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.). These assumptions can be restrictive, limiting the types of queries that can be analyzed and the scenarios where these guarantees apply. This paper aims to address this limitation by proposing a more flexible notion of algorithmic stability that can handle scenarios with non-independent data and queries that don't necessarily have bounded sensitivity.

Methods

The core contribution is the introduction of typical stability. Unlike differential privacy, which focuses on the output's indistinguishability across any two datasets differing by one record, typical stability focuses on the output's concentration around its expected value for datasets drawn from a specific distribution. This is formalized by requiring that the output of a query on a dataset is "well-concentrated" around its true mean with respect to that distribution.

The authors define typical stability with parameters $(\eta, \tau, \nu)$, where $\eta$ and $\tau$ control the "closeness" of distributions and $\nu$ bounds the probability of a dataset being "atypical." They also introduce the concept of $\gamma_n$-concentrated queries, which are statistics whose output is close to their expected value with a certain probability.

Key technical contributions include:

  • Near-Independence Lemma: Shows that typical stability implies a form of near-independence between the input dataset and the algorithm's output.
  • Generalization Guarantees: Demonstrates how typical stability can control generalization error, even for non-i.i.d. data and non-bounded sensitivity queries, provided the query outputs are $\gamma_n$-concentrated.
  • Composition Theorems: Develops theorems for both non-adaptive and adaptive composition of typically stable algorithms, characterizing how the stability parameters degrade with multiple sequential operations.
  • Noise-Addition Mechanisms: Proposes simple algorithms (Laplace for pure typical stability, Gaussian for approximate) that achieve typical stability by adding noise calibrated to the query's concentration properties, rather than global sensitivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical concepts and algorithmic properties rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting Focus from "Worst Case" to "Typical Case": The core idea is to move away from the strict worst-case guarantees of differential privacy (which consider any single-record difference) to a more distribution-aware notion. Typical stability focuses on the behavior of algorithms on "typical" datasets drawn from a specific distribution.
  • Bridging Privacy and Generalization: The paper elegantly connects algorithmic stability to generalization error, showing that typical stability provides a framework for ensuring that algorithms learn from data without overfitting, even in challenging settings.
  • Flexibility for Real-World Scenarios: By relaxing the i.i.d. and bounded sensitivity assumptions, typical stability opens the door to analyzing and providing guarantees for a wider range of practical data analysis tasks, such as those involving correlated data or complex statistical queries.
  • Calibrating Noise Differently: The noise added in the proposed mechanisms is not based on the query's global sensitivity (as in DP) but on the confidence interval of the query's output over the dataset. This "data-dependent" calibration is key to achieving typical stability.

Key Results

  • Typical stability is closed under post-processing and non-adaptive composition.
  • Adaptive composition of typically stable algorithms is characterized, showing how parameters degrade with $k$ sequential steps.
  • Typical stability implies generalization guarantees for $\gamma_n$-concentrated queries, even with non-i.i.d. data.
  • Simple noise-addition mechanisms (Laplace and Gaussian) are proposed that achieve pure and approximate typical stability, respectively, for $\gamma_n$-concentrated queries.
  • The paper provides theoretical bounds on the worst-case error in adaptive data analysis scenarios using these mechanisms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Privacy Guarantees are Distribution-Dependent: While typical stability offers privacy-like properties, these guarantees are only for a given family of distributions over the dataset, unlike differential privacy which is distribution-agnostic. This means the privacy guarantee is tied to assumptions about the underlying data-generating process.
  • Focus on Real-Valued Queries: The paper primarily focuses on releasing real-valued queries (statistics). Extending these concepts to other types of outputs (e.g., classifiers) might be a future direction.
  • Empirical Validation: The paper is largely theoretical. Future work could involve empirical studies to demonstrate the practical benefits and trade-offs of typical stability on real-world datasets and compare it with existing methods.
  • Exploring Broader Query Classes: While subgaussian and subexponential queries are mentioned, exploring the applicability of typical stability to even more complex query types could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce a notion of algorithmic stability called typical stability. When our goal is to release real-valued queries (statistics) computed over a dataset, this notion does not require the queries to be of bounded sensitivity -- a condition that is generally assumed under differential privacy [DMNS06, Dwork06] when used as a notion of algorithmic stability [DFHPRR15a, DFHPRR15b, BNSSSU16] -- nor does it require the samples in the dataset to be independent -- a condition that is usually assumed when generalization-error guarantees are sought. Instead, typical stability requires the output of the query, when computed on a dataset drawn from the underlying distribution, to be concentrated around its expected value with respect to that distribution. We discuss the implications of typical stability on the generalization error (i.e., the difference between the value of the query computed on the dataset and the expected value of the query with respect to the true data distribution). We show that typical stability can control generalization error in adaptive data analysis even when the samples in the dataset are not necessarily independent and when queries to be computed are not necessarily of bounded-sensitivity as long as the results of the queries over the dataset (i.e., the computed statistics) follow a distribution with a "light" tail. Examples of such queries include, but not limited to, subgaussian and subexponential queries. We also discuss the composition guarantees of typical stability and prove composition theorems that characterize the degradation of the parameters of typical stability under $k$-fold adaptive composition. We also give simple noise-addition algorithms that achieve this notion. These algorithms are similar to their differentially private counterparts, however, the added noise is calibrated differently.
BibTeX
@misc{bassily2016typicality,
  author = {Raef Bassily and Yoav Freund},
  title = {{Typicality-Based Stability and Privacy}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1604.03336},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1604.03336},
}
Figure