Type-II Topological Dirac Semimetals: Theory and Materials Prediction (VAl3 family)

Tay‐Rong Chang, Su‐Yang Xu, Daniel S. Sanchez, Shin-Ming Huang, Guoqing Chang, Chuang‐Han Hsu, Guang Bian, Ilya Belopolski, Zhi‐Ming Yu, Xicheng Xu, Xiang Cheng, Shengyuan A. Yang, Titus Neupert, Horng‐Tay Jeng, Hsin Lin, M. Zahid HasanarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces the concept of a "type-II Dirac fermion" in three-dimensional materials, a novel topological state that breaks Lorentz symmetry. The authors identify the VAl₃ family of compounds as promising candidates for realizing this state, predicting unique electronic properties and potential for new topological phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of topological materials has seen exciting progress with the discovery of Dirac and Weyl semimetals, which host quasiparticles that mimic elementary particles like Dirac and Weyl fermions. These materials have opened doors to exploring fundamental physics and potential applications in low-power electronics and quantum computing. However, most discovered topological semimetals fall into the "type-I" category, which adhere to Lorentz symmetry. Recently, "type-II" Weyl semimetals, which do break Lorentz symmetry, have been predicted and observed, exhibiting distinct properties. The authors noticed that while type-II Weyl fermions have been explored, the analogous three-dimensional "type-II Dirac fermion" remained elusive. This paper addresses this gap by proposing the concept of type-II Dirac fermions and identifying a material family, VAl₃, where this exotic state can be realized.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of theoretical approaches:

  • First-principles calculations (DFT): These were used to compute the electronic band structure of the VAl₃ family of materials. This is a standard method for predicting material properties.
  • Symmetry analysis: The authors meticulously analyzed the crystal symmetries of VAl₃ (including time-reversal, spatial inversion, and rotational symmetries) to understand how they dictate the electronic band structure and the formation of topological nodes.
  • k·p model: A simplified model that describes the electronic band structure near specific points in the Brillouin zone was developed and analyzed. This allows for a more focused study of the emergent Dirac and Weyl fermions and their properties.
  • Topological invariant calculations: The researchers calculated topological invariants like the 2D Z₂ invariant and mirror Chern number to rigorously confirm the topological nature of the predicted states.

The novelty lies in the theoretical framework developed to define and identify the type-II Dirac fermion and its specific realization in the VAl₃ family, going beyond existing type-I Dirac and type-II Weyl semimetals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations and material property predictions rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The birth of the type-II Dirac fermion: The paper formally introduces and defines the concept of a three-dimensional type-II Dirac fermion, which is a Lorentz-violating topological state. This expands the zoo of exotic quasiparticles found in condensed matter.
  • VAl₃ as a prime candidate: The VAl₃ family (specifically VAl₃) is identified as a material that hosts these type-II Dirac fermions. This is a significant material prediction, offering a concrete system to experimentally investigate these phenomena.
  • Lorentz violation in Dirac systems: Unlike type-I Dirac fermions, type-II Dirac fermions exhibit a tilted cone in their energy-momentum dispersion, a hallmark of Lorentz symmetry breaking. This opens up new avenues for exploring phenomena not seen in conventional Dirac materials.
  • Tunable topological phases: The VAl₃ system is shown to be a platform for rich topological phase transitions. By tuning parameters like crystalline distortions or applying external fields, one can transition from the type-II Dirac semimetal to topological crystalline insulators or even to various types of Weyl semimetals (quadratic and single Weyl). This tunability is crucial for potential device applications.
  • Distinct Landau level spectrum: The predicted Landau level spectrum for type-II Dirac fermions in VAl₃ is shown to be distinct from that of known Dirac semimetals, offering a potential experimental signature for identifying this new state.

Key Results

  • Prediction of type-II Dirac nodes in VAl₃: Theoretical calculations confirm the existence of type-II Dirac nodes in the VAl₃ family of materials.
  • Symmetry-protected degeneracy: The triply-degenerate point in the absence of spin-orbit coupling evolves into the type-II Dirac node upon inclusion of spin-orbit coupling, protected by crystal symmetries.
  • Topological characterization: The VAl₃ Dirac semimetal state is confirmed to be topologically distinct from other known Dirac semimetals (like Cd₃As₂ or Na₃Bi) based on calculated topological invariants (mirror Chern number).
  • Surface Fermi arcs: The calculations predict the existence of Fermi arc surface states connecting the projected Dirac nodes, a characteristic feature of topological semimetals.
  • Phase transition pathways: The paper outlines how VAl₃ can be driven into topological crystalline insulator and various Weyl semimetal phases through symmetry breaking.
  • Unique Landau level signatures: The predicted Landau level spectrum shows unique features, including a critical angle of the magnetic field where Landau levels collapse, suggesting a large density of states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental verification: While the theoretical predictions are strong, experimental confirmation of the type-II Dirac fermion state in VAl₃ and its unique properties is the crucial next step.
  • Material synthesis and characterization: The authors suggest that the VAl₃ family offers a rich platform for exploring these phenomena. Future work will likely involve synthesizing these materials and performing detailed experimental characterization, including transport, spectroscopic, and device-based measurements.
  • Exploring other MA₃ compounds: The paper focuses on VAl₃, but the MA₃ family is large (M=V, Nb, Ta; A=Al, Ga, In). Further investigation into the topological properties of other members of this family could reveal additional interesting states.
  • Understanding magneto-transport phenomena: The unique Landau level spectrum and the tunability of topological phases suggest novel magneto-transport phenomena that warrant further theoretical and experimental investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The discoveries of Dirac and Weyl semimetal states in spin-orbit compounds led to the realizations of elementary particle analogs in table-top experiments. In this paper, we propose the concept of a three-dimensional type-II Dirac fermion and identify a new topological semimetal state in the large family of transition-metal icosagenides, MA3 (M=V, Nb, Ta; A=Al, Ga, In). We show that the VAl3 family features a pair of strongly Lorentz-violating type-II Dirac nodes and that each Dirac node consists of four type-II Weyl nodes with chiral charge +/-1 via symmetry breaking. Furthermore, we predict the Landau level spectrum arising from the type-II Dirac fermions in VAl3 that is distinct from that of known Dirac semimetals. We also show a topological phase transition from a type-II Dirac semimetal to a quadratic Weyl semimetal or a topological crystalline insulator via crystalline distortions. The new type-II Dirac fermions, their novel magneto-transport response, the topological tunability and the large number of compounds make VAl3 an exciting platform to explore the wide-ranging topological phenomena associated with Lorentz-violating Dirac fermions in electrical and optical transport, spectroscopic and device-based experiments.
BibTeX
@misc{chang2016type,
  author = {Tay‐Rong Chang and Su‐Yang Xu and Daniel S. Sanchez and Shin-Ming Huang and Guoqing Chang and Chuang‐Han Hsu and Guang Bian and Ilya Belopolski and Zhi‐Ming Yu and Xicheng Xu and Xiang Cheng and Shengyuan A. Yang and Titus Neupert and Horng‐Tay Jeng and Hsin Lin and M. Zahid Hasan},
  title = {{Type-II Topological Dirac Semimetals: Theory and Materials Prediction (VAl3 family)}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1606.07555},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.07555},
}
Figure