Two way molecular communications

Jong Woo Kwack, H. Birkan Yilmaz, Nariman Farsad, Chan-Byoung Chae, Andrea GoldsmithIEEE Trans. Communications 2018

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-way molecular communication system that uses a single type of molecule for simultaneous communication between nano-devices. The authors develop a channel model for this system, propose self-interference cancellation techniques, and demonstrate significant improvements in bit error rate and throughput compared to existing one-way systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional radio frequency (RF) communication is unsuitable for nano-devices due to antenna size limitations and poor propagation in biological environments. Molecular communication via diffusion (MCvD) offers a promising alternative, where information is transmitted via molecules. However, existing MCvD systems are primarily one-way, limiting their efficiency. Two-way communication, common in RF systems, offers potential data rate gains and performance advantages. The challenge lies in implementing two-way MCvD using a single type of molecule, which introduces self-interference (SI) where a transmitter's molecules are absorbed by its own receiver. This paper tackles the problem of enabling efficient and reliable two-way molecular communication using a single molecule type, addressing the critical issue of self-interference.

Methods

The core of this work involves developing a new channel model for a two-way MCvD system with two absorbing spherical receivers. This model accounts for the complex interactions and dependencies between molecules absorbed by different receivers, a significant advancement over previous one-way models. To combat the self-interference inherent in two-way communication with a single molecule type, the authors propose two self-interference cancellation (SIC) techniques:

  • Analog Self-Interference Cancellation (A-SIC): This method involves ignoring the initial portion of the received molecular signal for a defined "discarding time" ($T_c$). This is based on the observation that early arriving molecules are more likely to be self-interference.
  • Digital Self-Interference Cancellation (D-SIC): This technique involves predicting the number of self-interfering molecules and subtracting this prediction from the total received signal.

The paper then derives bit error rate (BER) expressions for both half-duplex (time-division) and full-duplex (simultaneous) two-way MCvD systems. These analytical models are validated through particle-based simulations. The authors also investigate optimal parameters for the detection threshold and discarding time to minimize BER.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on particle-based simulations and theoretical analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feasibility of Two-Way MCvD with a Single Molecule Type: The paper demonstrates that efficient two-way molecular communication is achievable even when using a single type of molecule, overcoming the complexity and scalability issues of using multiple molecule types.
  • The Necessity of SIC for Full-Duplex MCvD: The research clearly shows that without self-interference cancellation, reliable communication in a full-duplex MCvD system is infeasible due to severe SI.
  • D-SIC Outperforms A-SIC: Digital SIC is shown to be more effective than analog SIC, as it accounts for a wider time interval of interference and provides a more sophisticated cancellation mechanism.
  • Synergistic Benefits of Combined SIC: Applying both A-SIC and D-SIC together yields a slight improvement in BER over D-SIC alone, suggesting complementary benefits.
  • Trade-offs Between Throughput and Symbol Duration: The study highlights that reducing the symbol duration ($t_s$) in full-duplex systems, even with SIC, can lead to higher throughput, but potentially at the cost of increased BER if not carefully managed.

Key Results

  • Channel Model for Multi-Receiver Systems: The paper successfully derives a channel model for a two-way MCvD system with two absorbing spherical receivers, a significant contribution to the field.
  • BER Performance:
    • The full-duplex system without SIC exhibits a BER close to 0.5, rendering it unusable.
  • With D-SIC, the full-duplex system's BER becomes comparable to that of the half-duplex system.
  • Applying both A-SIC and D-SIC further improves the BER of the full-duplex system.
  • Throughput Gains: The full-duplex system with optimized SIC can achieve nearly double the throughput of the half-duplex system, especially when symbol durations are reduced.
  • Modulation Impact: The paper notes that higher-order concentration-based modulation techniques significantly degrade BER, suggesting that simpler schemes like BCSK are more practical for two-way MCvD.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fabrication Issues: The authors acknowledge that the physical realization of the transceivers is an important issue that is left for future work.
  • General System Configurations: The paper focuses on a specific topology. Future work will involve studying channel models for more general system configurations.
  • More Effective Modulation Techniques: The study suggests that investigating more effective modulation techniques for two-way MCvD is a crucial area for future research, as higher-order schemes proved detrimental to BER.
  • Numerical Optimization: While optimal parameters for detection threshold and SIC were found numerically, deriving closed-form solutions for these parameters remains an open challenge.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kwack2018two,
  author = {Jong Woo Kwack and H. Birkan Yilmaz and Nariman Farsad and Chan-Byoung Chae and Andrea Goldsmith},
  title = {{Two way molecular communications}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure