Two-step etch method to improve the filtering performance of nuclear track membrane

Yan Wang, Qu Hua, Dan Mo2016 · DOI

Abstract: A method for the fabrication of double-cone shape pores in polyethylene terephthalate (PET)-based nuclear track membranes (NTMs) is presented here. PET films of 25 μm thickness were irradiated with Bi ions (kinetic energy 9.5 MeV/u, fluence 5×10^7 ions/cm²) at room temperature under vacuum at the Heavy Ion Research Facility (HIRFL) in Lanzhou. Then using a two-step etch method to fabricate the NTMs with double-cone pores. Comparing the filtering flux by using Yellow-river water between the double-cone shape and regular, cylindrical shape in the experiment. Filtering flux through simulation by ANSYS Fluent and the water test results are also compared. The experimental results show that the flux of double-cone shape is significantly 5 times higher than that of cylindrical shape. And NTMs with inner pore size of 450 nm can effectively separate bacteria by an average of 99.90% (particle counter) in raw water.

Introduction

Nuclear track membranes (NTMs) are thin polymer films characterized by precise microscopic pores, created by bombarding the film with heavy ions followed by chemical etching. While highly effective for fine filtration, standard NTMs typically feature cylindrical pores that are prone to membrane fouling. In water treatment applications, particles and bacteria quickly block the narrow entrances of these cylinders, causing the filtration flux to plummet. To make NTMs viable for large-scale water purification—particularly in regions with high sediment like the Yellow River—researchers have sought to optimize pore geometry to increase throughput without sacrificing contaminant removal.

Methods

The researchers utilized 25 μm thick PET films and a multi-stage fabrication process. After irradiation with Bismuth (Bi) ions to create latent tracks, a novel two-step etching process was applied:

  1. Initial Etch: The film was treated with a high-concentration alkaline solution (9 M NaOH) mixed with methanol at 20°C. This creates initial cone shapes from both sides of the film.
  2. Secondary Etch: A second etch using a lower concentration (1 M NaOH) at 80°C connects the cones and tunes the "inner-pore" diameter to a precise 450 nm.
Comparison of cylindrical (A) and double-cone (B) pore models used for simulation and design.

The performance of these "double-cone" membranes was compared against standard cylindrical membranes using both physical experiments with Yellow River water and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations via ANSYS Fluent 14.5.

Key Insights and Results

The geometric shift from cylindrical to double-cone pores fundamentally changes the membrane's fluid dynamics. The double-cone shape acts as a funnel, increasing surface porosity and allowing liquid to gather into the holes faster under the same pressure. Furthermore, the wider openings prevent the formation of a compact "cake layer" of debris that typically seals cylindrical pores.

SEM micrographs showing cylindrical pores (top) and double-cone pores (bottom) in both surface (A) and cross-section (B) views.

Key experimental findings include:

  • 5x Flux Increase: Double-cone membranes demonstrated a filtration flux approximately five times higher than cylindrical membranes.
  • Superior Anti-Blocking: Cylindrical pores became almost entirely blocked after filtering 250 mL of water, whereas double-cone pores remained functional until 850 mL.
  • High Purity: Despite the increased flow, the 450 nm inner pores removed 99.90% of bacteria, bringing Yellow River water within safe drinking standards for turbidity and colony count.
  • Simulation Alignment: CFD data confirmed the experimental results, showing a mass flow rate of $4.88 \times 10^{-9}$ kg/s for double-cone pores versus $1.02 \times 10^{-9}$ kg/s for cylindrical pores.

Conclusion

The two-step etch method successfully transforms NTMs into high-performance filters by optimizing pore geometry. While the process requires strict control over etching parameters to maintain the 450 nm inner diameter, the resulting double-cone membranes offer a significant leap in filtration efficiency and fouling resistance, making them a promising candidate for advanced water purification technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

A method for the fabrication of double-cone shape pores in polyethylene terephthalate (PET)-based nuclear track membranes (NTMs) is presented here. PET films of 25 m thickness were irradiated with Bi ions (kinetic energy 9.5 MeV/u, fluence 5107 ions/cm2) at room temperature under vacuum at the Heavy Ion Research Facility (HIRFL) in Lanzhou.Then using two-step etch method to fabricate the NTMs with double-cone pores. Comparing the filtering flux by using Yellow-river water between the double-cone shape and regular, cylindrical shape in the experiment. Filtering flux through simulation by ANSYS Fluent and the water test results are also compared. The experimental results show that the flux of double-cone shape is significantly 5 times higher than that of cylindrical shape. And NTMs with inner pore size of 450 nm can effectively separate bacteria by an average of 99.90% (particle counter) in raw water.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2016two,
  author = {Yan Wang and Qu Hua and Dan Mo},
  title = {{Two-step etch method to improve the filtering performance of nuclear track membrane}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2991/icmcm-16.2016.39},
}

Loading related content...

Figure