Two roaming pathways in the photolysis of CH3CHO between 328 and 308 nm

Kin Long Kelvin Lee, Mitchell S. Quinn, Alan T. Maccarone, Klaas Nauta, Paul L. Houston, Scott A. Reid, Meredith J. T. Jordan, Scott H. KableChemical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals two distinct "roaming" pathways in the photodissociation of acetaldehyde (CH<sub>3</sub>CHO), a crucial process in atmospheric chemistry. By analyzing the fragments produced at different wavelengths, the researchers demonstrate that these roaming mechanisms, where atoms or groups "roam" around the molecule before bond breaking, are significant and can even dominate over traditional transition-state pathways.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The photodissociation of acetaldehyde (CH<sub>3</sub>CHO) is a fundamental process with implications for atmospheric chemistry. For decades, it was understood to proceed through a few well-defined photochemical pathways, primarily involving transition states (TS) where a molecule passes through a specific, high-energy configuration before breaking apart. However, more recent studies have suggested the importance of "roaming" mechanisms, where fragments move around the molecule in a less constrained way before dissociation. This paper aims to clarify the relative contributions of these different pathways, specifically addressing the discrepancy in previous findings regarding the dominance of roaming versus TS mechanisms and identifying the specific types of roaming involved.

Methods

The researchers employed velocity map imaging (VMI) spectroscopy to study the photodissociation of CH<sub>3</sub>CHO. This technique involves:

  • Photolysis: Irradiating CH<sub>3</sub>CHO molecules with UV light at specific wavelengths (308-328 nm).
  • Fragment Detection: Detecting the resulting CO fragments using (2+1) resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization (REMPI) spectroscopy.
  • Velocity Map Imaging: A sophisticated VMI setup was used, combining Doppler-free spectral resolution with 3D REMPI-ion imaging. This allows for the simultaneous measurement of both the speed and rotational state distributions of the CO fragments.
  • Data Analysis: The collected ion images were analyzed to extract speed distributions for different CO rotational states. These distributions were then fitted with Boltzmann functions to determine temperature and fractional contributions of different components. The energy dependence of these distributions was crucial for assigning specific mechanisms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the photodissociation of acetaldehyde under controlled laboratory conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Distinct Roaming Pathways: The study definitively identifies two separate roaming mechanisms contributing to CH<sub>4</sub> + CO formation: H-roaming and CH<sub>3</sub>-roaming. This is a significant advancement in understanding the complexity of this reaction.
  • Energy Threshold for Roaming: The disappearance of the "cold" CO component in the speed distribution at wavelengths longer than 325 nm strongly suggests an energy threshold. This threshold aligns with the energy required for C-H bond cleavage, directly linking the cold component to H-roaming.
  • Roaming Dominance: The findings suggest that roaming pathways, particularly CH<sub>3</sub>-roaming, are the dominant mechanisms for CH<sub>4</sub> + CO formation at 308 nm, contradicting earlier assumptions that transition states were the primary route.
  • Reconciliation of Previous Work: By identifying these two distinct roaming pathways, the paper successfully reconciles seemingly contradictory results from previous experimental and theoretical studies.
  • Implications for Atmospheric Chemistry: The paper highlights that roaming often produces more stable products (molecules) at the expense of more reactive ones (radicals). This has significant implications for atmospheric chemistry, where such processes can influence reaction rates and product distributions.

Key Results

  • Bimodal CO Distributions: At 308 nm, the CO fragment speed distributions are clearly bimodal, indicating at least two distinct dissociation pathways.
  • Cold Component Disappears: The "cold" component of the CO speed distribution vanishes for photolysis wavelengths between 325 and 328 nm, indicating an energy threshold around 325.6 nm, consistent with C-H bond cleavage.
  • H-Roaming Assignment: The cold component is attributed to H-roaming, where a hydrogen atom roams from the CH<sub>3</sub>CO core to form CH<sub>4</sub>.
  • CH<sub>3</sub>-Roaming Assignment: The "hot" component is predominantly attributed to CH<sub>3</sub>-roaming, where the CH<sub>3</sub> group roams around the HCO core.
  • Branching Ratios at 308 nm: The study estimates the branching fractions for CH<sub>4</sub> + CO formation at 308 nm as:
  • CH<sub>3</sub>-roaming: 71 ± 12%
    • H-roaming: 13 ± 3%
    • Transition State (TS): 16 ± 10%
  • Consistency with Previous Studies: These results are in good agreement with previous experimental (HK, RL) and theoretical (Heazlewood et al.) work, providing a unified picture.

Limitations and Future Work

  • TS Mechanism Obscured: The contribution of the traditional transition state (TS) mechanism is difficult to discern experimentally and is likely masked by the dominant roaming pathways, particularly at higher J values. While theoretical calculations suggest a small TS contribution, its direct experimental observation remains challenging.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the identification of two distinct roaming channels from the same electronic state has broad implications for understanding roaming in other photochemical and thermal unimolecular reactions. Further theoretical work is needed to fully characterize these roaming transition states and to develop more robust kinetic theories for roaming reactions. The paper also points to the need to resolve discrepancies in the importance of roaming versus TS pathways in other systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We attribute the two product-state distributions previously seen in CH<sub>3</sub>CHO photodissociation to CH<sub>3</sub>-roaming and H-roaming, unifying all previous experimental results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2014two,
  author = {Kin Long Kelvin Lee and Mitchell S. Quinn and Alan T. Maccarone and Klaas Nauta and Paul L. Houston and Scott A. Reid and Meredith J. T. Jordan and Scott H. Kable},
  title = {{Two roaming pathways in the photolysis of CH<sub>3</sub>CHO between 328 and 308 nm}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1039/c4sc02266a},
}

Loading related content...

Figure