Abstract
The most common response of a host to pathogens is arguably the asymptomatic response. However, the genetic and molecular mechanisms responsible for asymptomatic responses to pathogens are poorly understood. Here we report on the genetic cloning of two genes controlling the asymptomatic response to tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) in cultivated tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum). These two genes are homologous to tobamovirus multiplication 2A (TOM2A) from Arabidopsis, which was shown to be critical for the accumulation of TMV. Expression analysis indicates that the TOM2A genes might play fundamental roles in plant development or in responses to stresses. Consistent with this hypothesis, a null allele of the TOM2A ortholog in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) led to the development of bent branches and a high tolerance to both TMV and tomato mosaic virus (ToMV). However, the TOM2A ortholog in Nicotiana glauca did not account for the asymptomatic response to TMV in N. glauca. We showed that TOM2A family is plant-specific and originated from Chlorophyte, and the biological functions of TOM2A orthologs to promote TMV accumulation are highly conserved in the plant kingdom—in both TMV host and nonhost species. In addition, we showed that the interaction between tobacco TOM1 and TOM2A orthologs in plant species is conserved, suggesting a conserved nature of TOM1-TOM2A module in promoting TMV multiplication in plants. The tradeoff between host development, the resistance of hosts to pathogens, and their influence on gene evolution are discussed. Our results shed light on mechanisms that contribute to asymptomatic responses to viruses in plants and provide approaches for developing TMV/ToMV-resistant crops.
Introduction
When a virus infects a plant, the outcome is usually binary: the plant either fights it off through resistance mechanisms (such as the hypersensitive response triggered by the 'N gene') or suffers visible damage like stunted growth and "mosaic" leaf patterns. However, a third, more mysterious state exists: the asymptomatic response, where the plant carries the virus but shows no symptoms. While the genetic basis of resistance is well-documented, the mechanisms allowing some tobacco varieties to remain asymptomatic have remained a "black box." Understanding this phenomenon is crucial for crop breeding, as it offers a strategy to maintain agricultural yield even in the presence of viral pathogens.
Methods
The research team employed a forward genetics approach to identify the responsible genes:
- Bulk Segregant Analysis (BSA) & NGS: An asymptomatic tobacco genotype (TI203) was crossed with a susceptible one (SR1). Next-Generation Sequencing on pooled offspring pinpointed genomic regions linked to the asymptomatic trait.
- Map-Based Cloning: The search was narrowed to two recessive loci, identified as homologs of the Arabidopsis gene TOM2A (TOBAMOVIRUS MULTIPLICATION 2A).
- CRISPR/Cas9 Gene Editing: To validate these findings, the team knocked out TOM2A homologs in both susceptible tobacco and tomato plants.
- Protein Interaction Assays: A split-ubiquitin yeast two-hybrid system confirmed that TOM2A proteins physically interact with TOM1 to form a replication complex hijacked by the virus.
- Phylogenetic Analysis: The evolution of TOM2A was traced across 54 plant species to determine its origins and conservation.
Results
The researchers successfully cloned the two genes responsible for the asymptomatic phenotype in tobacco, naming them NttTOM2A and NtsTOM2A. These genes are part of an ancient, plant-specific machinery required for viral replication.
In the asymptomatic variety TI203, TMV levels were barely detectable via immunoblotting compared to the high levels found in susceptible SR1 plants. Furthermore, CRISPR-edited tomato plants (sltom2a mutants) demonstrated high tolerance not just to TMV, but also to the closely related Tomato Mosaic Virus (ToMV). The study also showed that TOM2A orthologs from diverse species—including mosses and gymnosperms—can interact with tobacco TOM1, highlighting the extreme conservation of this viral-support module.
Discussion
The study confirms that the TOM1–TOM2A module acts as a host "scaffold" that TMV requires for replication. In asymptomatic plants, mutations in TOM2A disrupt this scaffold, reducing viral accumulation to levels that do not trigger symptoms.
However, this resistance comes with an evolutionary trade-off. TOM2A originated in green algae (Chlorophytes) and has been conserved for hundreds of millions of years, suggesting it performs a fundamental, non-viral role in plant biology. In tomatoes, the loss of TOM2A resulted in "bent branches," suggesting the gene is involved in structural integrity or stress signaling.
Interestingly, while TOM2A explains the asymptomatic response in cultivated tobacco, it does not account for it in the wild species Nicotiana glauca. This implies that plants have evolved multiple, independent pathways to achieve an asymptomatic state. Future research will focus on fine-tuning these mutations to block viral replication without affecting plant development and investigating the alternative mechanisms found in wild species.
Summary updated