Two-dimensional Health State Map to define metabolic health using separated static and dynamic homeostasis features: a proof-of-concept study

Yanpu Wu, Xinyan Zhang, Liang Sun, Qingqing Wu, Xiaoping Liu, Yueyi Deng, Zhenzhen Lu, Zhongxia Li, C. Q. Deng, Ruikun He, Luyun Zhang, Rong Zeng, Xuguang Zhang, Luonan Chen, Lin XuNational 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Health State Map" (HSM) that uses a two-dimensional approach to define metabolic health. By separating static (fasting) and dynamic (post-meal) physiological responses, the HSM provides a more comprehensive and sensitive assessment than traditional methods, potentially enabling earlier detection of metabolic dysfunction and personalized nutritional interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Defining "metabolic health" is crucial for preventing metabolic diseases like type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Current definitions often rely heavily on fasting blood biomarkers, which may not fully capture an individual's ability to adapt to the stresses of daily life, particularly after meals. Most of our day is spent in a postprandial state, and how our bodies handle nutrients during this time is increasingly recognized as a critical indicator of health. Existing methods, like the oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT), focus primarily on glucose and don't fully reflect the complex metabolic responses to a mixed meal. This gap leaves a need for a more holistic and dynamic assessment of metabolic health that accounts for individual variability in response to nutrient intake.

Methods

The core innovation is the development of a two-dimensional Health State Map (HSM). This map comprises two distinct scores:

  • Health Phenotype Score (HPS): This score is derived from static, fasting-based features, including anthropometric measurements and fasting blood biomarkers. It essentially captures an individual's baseline metabolic state.
  • Homeostatic Resilience Score (HRS): This score is novel and focuses on dynamic changes in metabolomic and clinical biomarkers over five time points (30, 60, 90, 180, and 240 minutes) following a standardized mixed macronutrient tolerance test (MMTT). The HRS quantifies an individual's ability to adapt and maintain metabolic equilibrium under the stress of a meal.

The HRS was constructed using a new "area between response curves" (ABRC) method, which compares an individual's post-MMTT response curves to those of an "optimal health" reference group. This approach aims to capture the dynamic resilience of various metabolic pathways. The study also explored three specific "metabolic axes" within the HRS: glucose (axis-glu), lipids (axis-lip), and amino acids (axis-aa).

Datasets

The study utilized data from 111 Chinese adults. This dataset included:

  • Fasting blood metabolomic and clinical biomarkers.
  • Post-MMTT measurements of metabolomic and clinical biomarkers at five time points.
  • Anthropometric parameters.
  • Lifestyle data (smoking, drinking, sleep, physical activity).
  • Genetic data (23 single-nucleotide polymorphisms or SNPs).
  • Gut microbiome data (16s rDNA sequencing).

The study also defined two reference groups: an "optimal health" group and a "suboptimal health" group, to aid in the construction of the HPS and HRS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Resilience is Key: The HRS, focusing on post-meal responses, proved to be a more independent and sensitive indicator of metabolic health than static fasting measures (HPS) or a combined 1D score. This highlights the importance of how the body responds to food, not just its baseline state.
  • Beyond Disease Diagnosis: The HSM can identify metabolic characteristics that are not captured by traditional disease-based diagnoses, suggesting it can reveal earlier signs of metabolic dysfunction.
  • Interpersonal Variability: Even among individuals with similar overall metabolic scores, there are significant differences in how their bodies handle specific nutrients (glucose, lipids, amino acids), underscoring the need for personalized nutrition.
  • Lifestyle and Microbiome Influence: Physical activity and gut microbiome composition are linked to homeostatic resilience, suggesting potential avenues for intervention.

Key Results

  • The HRS was significantly associated with metabolic syndrome (MetS) prevalence, independently of the HPS and a combined "mixed-score" (OR [95% CI]: 0.41 [0.18, 0.92] for HPS-adjusted and 0.34 [0.15, 0.69] for mixed-score-adjusted).
  • Participants with higher HRSs generally exhibited better metabolic traits, including lower body fat percentage and improved liver function markers.
  • Large variations in postprandial homeostatic resilience were observed, with individuals showing different responses to glucose, lipids, and amino acids even when their overall HRS was similar.
  • Physical activity was positively associated with the HRS-aa and marginally with HRS-overall.
  • Night-time sleep duration was positively correlated with HRS-lip.
  • Specific gut microbiome structures, particularly within enterotype 2, were associated with higher HRS-overall and HRS-lip.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Generalizability: The study was a proof-of-concept with 111 Chinese adults. The findings need to be confirmed in larger, more diverse populations and across different ethnic groups.
  • MMTT as a Proxy: The MMTT is an acute test. Future work should explore how these findings translate to real-world dietary patterns and longer-term interventions.
  • Reference Group Definition: The HRS relied on an "optimal health" reference group, whereas the HPS also incorporated a "suboptimal health" reference. Future studies could refine these reference definitions.
  • Multi-omics Integration: The authors acknowledge that multi-omics analysis (e.g., integrating genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics) would be beneficial for a more comprehensive definition of metabolic health.
  • Genetic Associations: While some SNPs were tested, significant associations with HRS were not consistently found after FDR correction, suggesting the need for larger sample sizes and broader genetic analyses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Defining metabolic health is critical for the earlier reversing of metabolic dysfunction and disease, and fasting-based diagnosis may not adequately assess an individual's metabolic adaptivity under stress. We constructed a novel Health State Map (HSM) comprising a Health Phenotype Score (HPS) with fasting features alone and a Homeostatic Resilience Score (HRS) with five time-point features only (<i>t</i> = 30, 60, 90, 180, 240 min) following a standardized mixed macronutrient tolerance test (MMTT). Among 111 Chinese adults, when the same set of fasting and post-MMTT data as for the HSM was used, the mixed-score was highly correlated with the HPS. The HRS was significantly associated with metabolic syndrome prevalence, independently of the HPS (OR [95% CI]: 0.41 [0.18, 0.92]) and the mixed-score (0.34 [0.15, 0.69]). Moreover, the HRS could discriminate metabolic characteristics unseparated by the HPS and the mixed-score. Participants with higher HRSs had better metabolic traits than those with lower HRSs. Large interpersonal variations were also evidenced by evaluating postprandial homeostatic resiliencies for glucose, lipids and amino acids when participants had similar overall HRSs. Additionally, the HRS was positively associated with physical activity level and specific gut microbiome structure. Collectively, our HSM model might offer a novel approach to precisely define an individual's metabolic health and nutritional capacity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2024two,
  author = {Yanpu Wu and Xinyan Zhang and Liang Sun and Qingqing Wu and Xiaoping Liu and Yueyi Deng and Zhenzhen Lu and Zhongxia Li and C. Q. Deng and Ruikun He and Luyun Zhang and Rong Zeng and Xuguang Zhang and Luonan Chen and Lin Xu},
  title = {{Two-dimensional Health State Map to define metabolic health using separated static and dynamic homeostasis features: a proof-of-concept study}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwae425},
}
Figure