Two chronically misdiagnosed patients infected with Nocardia cyriacigeorgica accurately diagnosed by whole genome resequencing

Anqing Liu, Xiaojin Liu, Yunwei Lu, Zhan Gao, Ruixiang Tang, Yang Huang, Liheng Zheng, Zhenxin Fan, Miao HeFrontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper highlights a critical diagnostic challenge in identifying Nocardia species, which often exhibit varied colony morphologies that confound traditional methods. By employing whole-genome resequencing (WGRS), the researchers accurately identified Nocardia cyriacigeorgica in two patients who had been misdiagnosed for years due to these morphological differences, underscoring the necessity of advanced molecular techniques for precise diagnosis and treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nocardia infections, known as nocardiosis, are serious and potentially life-threatening, particularly in immunocompromised individuals. A major hurdle in diagnosing and treating nocardiosis is the difficulty in accurately identifying Nocardia species. These bacteria are notoriously challenging to differentiate based on standard microbiological techniques like Gram staining and colony morphology. Nocardia species can exhibit a wide range of appearances – from smooth to rough, various colors, and irregular shapes – making it hard to distinguish between them, even for experienced microbiologists. This ambiguity can lead to misdiagnosis, delayed treatment, and suboptimal patient outcomes. This study addresses this problem by demonstrating how whole-genome resequencing can overcome these limitations and provide definitive identification, even when phenotypic characteristics are misleading.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the bacterial isolates. Standard microbiological techniques were used initially, including:

  • Gram staining: To assess the cell wall structure.
  • Acid-fast staining: To identify bacteria with waxy cell walls.
  • Mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS): A common method for rapid bacterial identification based on protein profiles.

The core of the study, however, was the application of Whole Genome Resequencing (WGRS). This involved:

  • DNA Extraction: Genomic DNA was extracted from pure cultures of the isolates.
  • Library Construction: DNA libraries were prepared for sequencing using both PacBio Sequel and Illumina NovaSeq platforms.
  • Sequencing: High-throughput sequencing was performed to obtain the complete genomes of the isolates.
  • Genome Assembly and Annotation: The sequenced reads were assembled into contiguous genomic sequences, and genes were identified and annotated to understand their functions.
  • Phylogenomic Analysis: Evolutionary trees were constructed using protein sequences from the genus Nocardia to determine the precise phylogenetic placement of the isolates.
  • Comparative Genomics: The genomes of the isolates were compared with known Nocardia species to identify genetic differences and similarities, including genes related to pathogenicity, drug resistance, and virulence factors.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Genomic DNA of isolates L5.53 and L5.54: These are the primary datasets generated in this study from the two patient samples.
  • Publicly available Nocardia genomes: The researchers compared their isolates against a database of 117 protein sequences from the genus Nocardia, including reference strains like N. cyriacigeorgica GUH-2 and N. farcinica.
  • Databases for functional annotation: GO (Gene Ontology), KEGG (Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes), COG (Clusters of Orthologous Groups), NCBI-nr (National Center for Biotechnology Information Non-redundant protein database), Pfam, TCDB (Transporter Classification Database), SwissProt, the Pathogen-Host Interaction (PHI) database, the Antibiotic Resistance Genes Database (ARDB), and the Comprehensive Antibiotic Research Database (CARD) were used to annotate genes related to pathogenicity, drug resistance, and virulence.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Morphological variability is a major diagnostic pitfall: The study powerfully demonstrates that seemingly different colony morphologies can arise from the same species (Nocardia cyriacigeorgica), rendering traditional phenotypic identification unreliable for these cases.
  • WGRS is the gold standard for definitive identification: When phenotypic methods fail, WGRS provides the resolution needed to accurately classify bacterial species, even those with subtle genetic differences.
  • Genetic basis for morphological differences: The researchers identified a potential genetic basis for the observed morphological differences, specifically a variation in a "septum formation family protein," suggesting that subtle genetic changes can lead to significant phenotypic divergence.
  • Comprehensive understanding of pathogenicity and resistance: WGRS not only identified the species but also provided insights into potential virulence factors and antibiotic resistance mechanisms encoded within the genomes, which are crucial for guiding treatment.

Key Results

  • Accurate species identification: Whole-genome resequencing definitively identified both isolates, L5.53 and L5.54, as Nocardia cyriacigeorgica, despite their distinct colony morphologies (white, hoarfrost-like for L5.53 vs. yellow, rough for L5.54).
  • Phylogenetic confirmation: A gene family cluster analysis evolutionary tree confirmed that L5.53 and L5.54 formed a robust clade within N. cyriacigeorgica.
  • Identification of potential virulence and resistance genes: The analysis revealed genes associated with human diseases (e.g., Rv2626c, Rv1093), antibiotic resistance (40 genes identified across four categories, including efflux pumps and enzyme-producing genes), and virulence factors (e.g., Capsule, WhiB3, Pyrimidine biosynthesis, Mce).
  • Clinical relevance: The study highlights two cases of chronic misdiagnosis, emphasizing the clinical impact of accurate identification for effective patient management. One patient was cured, while the other was still undergoing treatment, underscoring the ongoing challenges.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Genome completeness: Due to experimental manipulation and sequencing data quality, the genome sequences of isolates L5.53 and L5.54 might be incomplete.
  • Subtle genetic differences: The genetic differences between the two strains were small, making it difficult to definitively exclude other factors contributing to the morphological variations.
  • In silico predictions: The identification of pathogenic genes, drug resistance genes, and virulence factors was based on bioinformatics tools and requires experimental validation to confirm their functions.

Future work should focus on:

  • Experimental validation: Confirming the functions of the predicted genes through laboratory experiments.
  • Further investigation of morphological determinants: Delving deeper into the genetic mechanisms responsible for the observed morphological differences.
  • Broader application of WGRS: Encouraging the wider adoption of WGRS for accurate Nocardia species identification in clinical settings, especially in cases with atypical presentations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nocardiosis is a rare but life-threatening infection particularly affecting immuno-compromised hosts, causing localized or systemic suppurative disease usually in human beings. <i>Nocardia</i> species, as the pathogen of nocardiosis, are difficult to differentiate because of their complex colony morphological features. In this study, we describe two patients who had been misdiagnosed for a long time infected with <i>Nocardia cyriacigeorgica</i> with completely different morphology were accurately diagnosed. Single colonies were analyzed by Gram staining, acid-fast stain, mass spectrometry and whole genome resequencing (WGRS). These two bacterial, strains L5.53 and L5.54, were found to be Gram-negative and acid-fast-weak positive. Blood sample culturing of strain L5.53 yielded white colonies, which were like a layer of hoarfrost, while colonies of L5.54 were yellow, rough, slightly convex. The two strains were identified as <i>Nocardia</i> sp. by mass spectrometry, and WGRS accurately determined them as <i>N. cyriacigeorgica.</i> After medical treatment, one patient was cured and the other was still receiving treatment in the hospital. It can be seen that <i>Nocardia</i> sp. cannot be accurately classified and identified only by phenotypic tests such as bacterial morphological differences, so it is necessary to identify <i>Nocardia</i> spp. with phenotypic tests in combination with other molecular biology technologies, such as WGRS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022two,
  author = {Anqing Liu and Xiaojin Liu and Yunwei Lu and Zhan Gao and Ruixiang Tang and Yang Huang and Liheng Zheng and Zhenxin Fan and Miao He},
  title = {{Two chronically misdiagnosed patients infected with Nocardia cyriacigeorgica accurately diagnosed by whole genome resequencing}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fcimb.2022.1032669},
}
Figure