Twenty Years of Resilient City Research: Reviews and Perspectives

Zongrun Wang, Yongtao Tan, Xin LüSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive review of two decades of resilient city research, analyzing nearly 27,000 papers to map out key themes, regional differences, and evolutionary trends. It reveals that resilient city research has matured from a niche area into a multidisciplinary field, with a growing focus on urban ecology, economic development, and mobility, offering valuable insights for urban planning and policy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cities worldwide are increasingly vulnerable to a confluence of risks, including extreme weather events driven by climate change, economic downturns, and social challenges. The concept of a "resilient city" – one that can absorb, adapt to, and recover from such shocks – has gained significant traction. However, despite a surge in research, there's a lack of clarity regarding the core themes, global distribution of research efforts, and the evolutionary trajectory of this field. This paper aims to address this gap by systematically analyzing the existing literature to provide a clear overview, identify research frontiers, and offer empirical support for policy and practice.

Methods

The authors employed a combination of scientometric and bibliometric analysis to dissect the vast body of resilient city research. This involved:

  • Data Collection: Searching the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC) for approximately 27,094 relevant papers published between 2000 and 2022, using a broad set of keywords related to resilience.
  • Statistical Analysis: Examining publication trends, author collaboration networks, and country cooperation networks.
  • Category and Theme Analysis: Identifying disciplinary categories and clustering keywords to uncover the main research themes and their evolution over time.
  • Knowledge Flow and Citation Trajectory Analysis: Using dual-map overlays to visualize the interdisciplinary connections and evolution of research fields.
  • Burst Detection Analysis: Identifying periods of intense research activity (bursts) in both disciplines and keywords to pinpoint emerging hot spots and trends.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study was the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC), specifically including the Science Citation Index Expanded (SC-EXPANDED), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts and Humanities Citation Index (AHCI), Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI), Current Chemical Reactions (CCR-EXPANDED), and Index Chemicus (IC). The search was conducted for publications from January 1, 2000, to December 31, 2022. No new datasets were introduced; the study focuses on analyzing existing published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Maturation of a Field: Resilient city research has evolved from a single discipline into a complex, multidisciplinary field, demonstrating its growing importance and integration into various academic domains.
  • Regional Nuances: Research on resilient cities exhibits distinct regional characteristics. For instance, Europe is identified as a central hub for cooperation, while Asia shows a strong focus on technology and methods, and Africa emphasizes economic development and resource management.
  • Lagging Impact of Events: Major disaster events, like the 9/11 attacks or Hurricane Katrina, often show a significant time lag before keywords related to them become prominent in research, suggesting a delayed academic response to real-world crises.
  • Interdisciplinary Synergy: Resilient city research is more interdisciplinary than smart city or urban emergency research, drawing from a wider range of fields, including ecology, Earth sciences, psychology, and governance.
  • Technological Integration: There's a clear trend towards incorporating advanced technologies like machine learning, AI, and big data into resilient city strategies, reflecting a shift towards data-driven solutions.

Key Results

  • Publication Growth: The average yearly growth rate of resilient city research is approximately 16%, significantly higher than the average scientific growth rate. Research has seen explosive growth since 2015, likely influenced by initiatives like the "Global 100 Resilient Cities" project.
  • Dominant Themes: The top seven research themes identified include urban climate change, social and demographic health, urban public health, urban economic resilience, urban resources, environmental pollution, and technology and methods. "Urban climate resilience" has been a consistently dominant theme.
  • Leading Countries: The U.S. and China lead in the number of publications, while European countries like France, the UK, and Switzerland show higher betweenness centrality, indicating strong cooperative roles.
  • Shifting Focus: Research has transitioned from an initial focus on "public health" and "urban emergencies" to a broader scope encompassing "computer engineering," "ecological environment," and "sustainable development." Key emerging trends include urban ecology, urban economic development, urban sprawl, and urban mobility.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their reliance solely on the Web of Science Core Collection might overlook valuable research published in non-English journals or regional databases, potentially limiting the comprehensiveness of the review.

For future work, they recommend:

  • Expanding Data Sources: Incorporating other databases to achieve a more holistic understanding of resilient city research.
  • Deeper Analysis: Continuing to analyze research trends, cooperation networks, and disciplinary evolution to guide future research and policy.
  • Promoting Collaboration: Fostering international cooperation and knowledge sharing to enhance urban resilience globally.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: Providing a solid foundation for achieving sustainable urban development by informing policy and practice with data-driven insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

The resilient city plays an increasingly important role in coping with the challenges raised by economic, social, and environmental risks. In this review, we examine approximately 27,094 papers published in the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC) and perform extensive bibliometric and scientometric analyses to identify the research themes, evolutionary history, and potential research trends in the state of the art in resilient city studies. Seven main resilient city research themes are identified, with significant differences persisting across regions. Specifically, the research on resilient cities in Europe, Asia, Africa, and North America reveals clear regional characteristics in macro development planning and strategies, technological methods, urban economic growth, urban water resource protection, and so on. The analysis also reveals the collaborative networks among different countries and regions in the study of resilient cities. The evolutionary history of resilient city research shows that it has gradually evolved from a single research field into a multidisciplinary field and further formed a unique discipline. Moreover, the urban ecological environment, urban economic development, urban sprawl, and urban mobility have become key research hot spots and trends in resilient city research. This study provides a systematic and data-driven analytical demonstration of resilient city research, which provides empirical support for policy formulation and practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024twenty,
  author = {Zongrun Wang and Yongtao Tan and Xin Lü},
  title = {{Twenty Years of Resilient City Research: Reviews and Perspectives}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su162411211},
}
Figure