Twenty-Four Hour Glucose Profiles and Glycemic Variability during Intermittent Religious Dry Fasting and Time-Restricted Eating in Subjects without Diabetes: A Preliminary Study

Beeke Peters, Christina Laetitia Pappe, Daniela A. Koppold, Katharina Schipp, Bert Arnrich, Andreas Michalsen, Henrik Dommisch, Nico Steckhan, Olga Pivovarova‐RamichNutrients 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the impact of two intermittent fasting methods, religious Bahá'í fasting (BF) and time-restricted eating (TRE), on glucose control in individuals without diabetes. The findings suggest that neither BF nor TRE negatively affects glycemic control or variability, even with significant changes in eating patterns and caloric intake in the BF group.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intermittent fasting (IF) has gained popularity for its potential health benefits, but its effects on glucose metabolism, particularly in individuals without diabetes, are not fully understood. While IF is known to pose risks for individuals with diabetes (e.g., hypoglycemia), its impact on healthy individuals is less clear. Specifically, religious fasting practices, like Bahá'í fasting (BF), involve strict dietary and fluid restrictions, raising questions about potential adverse effects on glycemic control and variability. This study aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining the effects of BF and comparing it to time-restricted eating (TRE), another popular IF method, in a controlled setting using continuous glucose monitoring (CGM).

Methods

The researchers conducted a three-arm randomized controlled trial involving 16 participants without diabetes. Participants were assigned to one of three groups: religious Bahá'í fasting (BF), time-restricted eating (TRE), or a control group.

  • Intervention:
    • BF Group: Followed a religious dry fasting regimen for 19 days, consuming food and drink only between sunset and sunrise.
  • TRE Group: Adhered to a time-restricted eating window of 8 hours per day, with 16 hours of fasting.
  • Control Group: Maintained their usual eating habits without specific recommendations.
  • Data Collection:
    • Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM): Used FreeStyle Libre Pro IQ sensors to continuously measure interstitial blood glucose levels over 15-minute intervals for 14 consecutive days before and during the intervention.
  • Food Intake Documentation: Participants kept detailed dietary records.
  • Anthropometric Measurements: Body weight, BMI, waist, and hip circumference were measured.
  • Blood Pressure: Measured systolic and diastolic blood pressure.
  • HbA1c: Measured at baseline to assess long-term glycemic status.
  • Analysis: CGM data was analyzed using the EasyGV software to assess various glycemic parameters, including mean sensor glucose (MSG), glycemic variability indices (SD, CV, MAGE, CONGA, MAG change, MODD), time in range (TIR), time above range (TAR), and time below range (TBR). Statistical analysis involved parametric and non-parametric tests, including ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis tests, to compare changes within and between groups.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study collected data from its own participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Religious Fasting's Unique Impact: While both BF and TRE reduced eating windows, only BF led to a significant decrease in caloric intake, body weight, and BMI. This suggests that the strict nature of dry fasting, rather than just time restriction, drives these metabolic changes.
  • Max Glucose Peaks in BF: The most striking finding was the increase in maximum glucose values during BF, particularly after sunrise and sunset meals. This suggests that the timing of meals, rather than overall glycemic control, is significantly altered by this fasting method.
  • Metabolic Flexibility in Healthy Individuals: The study highlights the metabolic flexibility of individuals without diabetes. Despite significant dietary shifts and weight loss in the BF group, their overall 24-hour mean glucose and glycemic variability remained stable, indicating a robust ability to manage glucose levels.
  • TRE's Neutral Effect: TRE, without caloric restriction, did not significantly alter glycemic control or variability, reinforcing its generally mild impact on metabolism in healthy individuals.

Key Results

  • Caloric Intake & Weight Loss: The BF group significantly reduced caloric intake (-677.8 ± 357.6 kcal, p = 0.013), body weight (-1.92 ± 0.95 kg, p = 0.011), and BMI (-0.65 ± 0.28 kg, p = 0.006). The TRE and control groups showed no significant changes in these parameters.
  • Maximum Glucose Values: The BF group experienced higher maximum glucose values during the intervention compared to baseline (+1.41 ± 1.04 mmol/L, p = 0.039) and compared to the control group (p = 0.010) and TRE group (p = 0.022).
  • No Change in Overall Glycemic Control: Despite the observed peaks in maximum glucose during BF, there were no significant alterations in the 24-hour mean glucose, intra-day, or inter-day glycemic variability indices in any of the groups.
  • Stable Time in Range: The proportion of time spent within the target glucose range (70-180 mg/dL), as well as time above or below this range, remained unchanged across all groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study involved only 16 participants, making it a preliminary investigation. The authors emphasize that these findings need confirmation in larger, carefully controlled cohorts.
  • Healthy Subjects Only: The study focused exclusively on individuals without diabetes. Future research should include individuals with prediabetes and type 2 diabetes to understand the effects in at-risk populations.
  • Lack of Physical Activity Monitoring: The study did not monitor physical activity levels, which can influence glucose metabolism. Future studies should incorporate this to provide a more comprehensive picture.
  • Follow-up Needed: A follow-up examination after the intervention period could reveal longer-term effects, particularly on HbA1c.
  • Homogenous Cohorts: The authors suggest that future studies should aim for more homogenous cohorts with similar nutritional compositions to better isolate the effects of the fasting interventions.
  • Distinguishing Fasting Effects: Further research is needed to disentangle the effects of eating window duration from weight loss on glycemic control, especially in the context of TRE.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intermittent religious fasting increases the risk of hypo- and hyperglycemia in individuals with diabetes, but its impact on those without diabetes has been poorly investigated. The aim of this preliminary study was to examine the effects of religious Bahá'í fasting (BF) on glycemic control and variability and compare these effects with time-restricted eating (TRE). In a three-arm randomized controlled trial, 16 subjects without diabetes were assigned to a BF, TRE, or control group. Continuous glucose monitoring and food intake documentation were conducted before and during the 19 days of the intervention, and the 24 h mean glucose and glycemic variability indices were assessed. The BF and TRE groups, but not the control group, markedly reduced the daily eating window while maintaining macronutrient composition. Only the BF group decreased caloric intake (-677.8 ± 357.6 kcal, <i>p</i> = 0.013), body weight (-1.92 ± 0.95 kg, <i>p</i> = 0.011), and BMI (-0.65 ± 0.28 kg, <i>p</i> = 0.006). Higher maximum glucose values were observed during BF in the within-group (+1.41 ± 1.04, <i>p</i> = 0.039) and between-group comparisons (BF vs. control: <i>p</i> = 0.010; TRE vs. BF: <i>p</i> = 0.022). However, there were no alterations of the 24 h mean glucose, intra- and inter-day glycemic variability indices in any group. The proportions of time above and below the range (70-180 mg/dL) remained unchanged. BF and TRE do not exhibit negative effects on glycemic control and variability in subjects without diabetes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peters2024twenty,
  author = {Beeke Peters and Christina Laetitia Pappe and Daniela A. Koppold and Katharina Schipp and Bert Arnrich and Andreas Michalsen and Henrik Dommisch and Nico Steckhan and Olga Pivovarova‐Ramich},
  title = {{Twenty-Four Hour Glucose Profiles and Glycemic Variability during Intermittent Religious Dry Fasting and Time-Restricted Eating in Subjects without Diabetes: A Preliminary Study}},
  booktitle = {Nutrients},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/nu16162663},
}
Figure