Turbulent flow simulation of a single-blade Magnus rotor

Xiao Bai, Chunning Ji, P. Grant, Nathan Phillips, Utsav Oza, Eldad Avital, John WilliamsAdvances 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the Magnus effect for kinetic turbines using high-fidelity numerical simulations. By modeling a single self-spinning cylindrical blade within a rotating framework, researchers employed an iterative direct-forcing immersed boundary method (IBM) and Large Eddy Simulation (LES) to capture complex turbulent wake structures. The findings highlight a significant "3D penalty" as the blade's aspect ratio increases, alongside a substantial boost in torque production, providing critical data for the design of next-generation Magnus-effect turbines.

Introduction

The Magnus effect—the generation of lift on a spinning body moving through a fluid—presents a promising alternative to traditional airfoil-based turbine blades. Magnus rotors can achieve higher lift coefficients and avoid the stall characteristics that limit conventional designs. However, real-world turbine blades are inherently three-dimensional and operate in turbulent environments. This paper addresses the scarcity of high-fidelity data on how blade geometry, specifically the aspect ratio (AR), influences aerodynamic performance under these conditions.

Numerical Methodology

To resolve the intricate physics of a spinning and rotating blade, the researchers utilized an in-house Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) code, CgLES-IBM. The framework combines:

  • Large Eddy Simulation (LES): Captures large-scale turbulent structures at a high Reynolds number ($Re = 1.0 \times 10^5$) using a Mixed-Time-Scale (MTS) sub-grid model.
  • Iterative Direct-Forcing Immersed Boundary Method (IBM): Efficiently handles the dual motion of the rotor—self-spinning and global rotation—without the need for complex, body-conformal remeshing.
Schematic view of the single-bladed Magnus rotor showing the coordinate system and dual rotation axes.

The "3D Penalty" and Aspect Ratio Effects

A core finding of the study is the impact of the blade's aspect ratio on lift and drag. When the AR of a spinning cylinder was increased from 3 to 10, the researchers observed a 30% drop in the lift coefficient and a 22% increase in drag.

This performance degradation is attributed to the enhancement of three-dimensional instabilities in the near-wake. As shown in the velocity contours, the longer blade (AR=10) experiences more complex, unsteady wake structures compared to the more compact AR=3 case. These 3D effects act as "lift killers," emphasizing that 2D theoretical models significantly overestimate the performance of long Magnus blades.

Contours of dimensionless instantaneous stream-wise velocity comparing (a) AR = 10 and (b) AR = 3, illustrating the increased wake complexity in the higher aspect ratio case.

Rotor Performance and Torque Production

Despite the lift penalty, increasing the aspect ratio proved beneficial for power extraction metrics. For the full Magnus rotor simulation:

  • Case 3 (AR=10): Achieved a torque coefficient ($C_{ts}$) of 2.1.
  • Case 4 (AR=3): Achieved a torque coefficient ($C_{ts}$) of 0.68.

While the AR=3 blade showed a slightly higher overall power coefficient ($C_{power}$), the AR=10 blade's superior torque production per unit length makes it a more attractive design for high-torque applications. The study also noted that stable torque is primarily generated near the blade's root, while the tip region is dominated by unsteady tip vortices and fluctuating force patterns.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that while high aspect ratio blades suffer from 3D wake instabilities that reduce lift, they are significantly more effective at generating torque. Future work will focus on mitigating the high drag associated with these rotors—potentially through the use of endplates or micro-vortex generators—and exploring multi-blade interactions to optimize the efficiency of Magnus-effect kinetic turbines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract This paper presents numerical studies of the Magnus effect for a kinetic turbine on a horizontal axis. To focus on the Magnus blade, a single self-spinning cylindrical blade is assumed. An iterative direct-forcing immersed boundary method is employed within the Eulerian-Lagrangian framework due to its capability to treat complex and moving geometries. The Eulerian fluid domain is discretized using the finite volume method while the Magnus rotor is represented by a set of discrete points/markers. The aim of the numerical studies is to provide insights for the design process and predict aerodynamic performances under various operating conditions. Results for stationary and self-spinning cylinders in turbulent flows are found to be in good agreement with published data. By increasing the aspect ratio of the cylinder (simulated segment length over its diameter) from 3 to 10, a 30% drop in lift coefficient and a 22% increase in drag coefficient were observed, which is believed to be attributed to an enhancement of the three-dimensionality of the near-wake. For the Magnus rotor, key parameters such as dynamic forcing and frequency, distribution of pressure coefficient and torque have been produced for two cases with different structural designs and working conditions. With increase of the aspect ratio from 3 to 10, stable forces are observed from the root side of the blade and the torque coefficient increases from 0.68 to 2.1, which indicates a superior performance in terms of power extraction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2021turbulent,
  author = {Xiao Bai and Chunning Ji and P. Grant and Nathan Phillips and Utsav Oza and Eldad Avital and John Williams},
  title = {{Turbulent flow simulation of a single-blade Magnus rotor}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s42774-021-00068-9},
}
Figure