Tuning in to Toddlers: Research Protocol and Recruitment for Evaluation of an Emotion Socialization Program for Parents of Toddlers

Sophie S. Havighurst, Christiane E. Kehoe, Ann E. Harley, Ameika M. Johnson, Nicholas B. Allen, Rae ThomasFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Toddlerhood is a period of significant emotional development, often characterized by dysregulation for both parents and children. The Tuning in to Toddlers (TOTS) program is a novel parenting intervention designed to improve emotion socialization—specifically parental emotional responsiveness, coaching, and regulation. This paper details the protocol for a cluster-randomized controlled trial (RCT) evaluating TOTS, focusing on its methodology and the challenges of recruiting parents of toddlers.

Introduction: Addressing the "Terrible Twos"

While toddlerhood is famously a time of emotional upheaval, most parenting interventions focus on behavioral management (discipline) rather than the underlying emotional processes. There is a critical gap in programs targeting emotion socialization—how parents respond to and coach their children's emotions—during the 18–36 month window. TOTS aims to fill this gap by promoting "emotion competence" in children, potentially preventing future social and behavioral difficulties.

Methods and Study Design

The study utilizes a cluster-randomized controlled design to evaluate the efficacy of the TOTS program. Childcare (CC) and maternal child health (MCH) centers in Melbourne, Australia, were randomized to either the intervention or a 15-month wait-list control condition. This design prevents "contamination" between parents at the same center.

CONSORT Flow Diagram of recruitment and participant allocation.

The TOTS Intervention

The TOTS program is an adaptation of the established "Tuning in to Kids" (TIK) curriculum, consisting of six weekly, two-hour group sessions. The curriculum focuses on teaching parents to notice low-intensity emotions, view distress as an opportunity for intimacy, and help children label and regulate their feelings.

Overview of the six-session TOTS program content.

Evaluation Metrics

The trial employs a comprehensive multi-method assessment strategy:

  • Self-Report Questionnaires: Measuring parent emotion regulation (DERS) and emotional style (PESQ).
  • Observational Assessments: Video-recorded parent-child interactions, including free play and frustration tasks.
  • Biological Markers: Analysis of hair cortisol to measure systemic, chronic stress in both parents and toddlers over several months.

Recruitment and Baseline Results

Recruitment proved challenging, with an uptake rate of approximately 4.5% from the centers approached. Parents of toddlers often operate in "survival mode," making the commitment to a six-week program difficult.

The final baseline cohort consisted of 306 parents (88.9% mothers, mean age 37.1 years). Baseline data collection was robust, including 234 parent-child observations and nearly 200 child hair cortisol samples. Notably, once enrolled, retention was high: 92% of the intervention group completed the program.

Discussion and Insights

The recruitment phase highlighted several key issues:

  1. Socioeconomic Skew: Participants tended to be of higher SES and education levels, suggesting that in-person, group-based programs may be less accessible to high-risk or low-resource families.
  2. Biological Feasibility: While hair cortisol is a powerful metric for chronic stress, some parents were hesitant due to aesthetic concerns or the child's potential distress during sampling.
  3. Recruitment Hubs: Childcare centers were more effective for recruitment than Maternal Child Health centers, likely due to more frequent parent contact.

Conclusion

This protocol paper establishes the feasibility of the TOTS RCT. While recruitment of busy toddler parents is difficult, the high retention rate suggests the program is engaging and valuable to those who attend. Future work will report on the program's efficacy in improving parent emotion socialization and toddler developmental outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Parenting a toddler is a challenging experience for many parents with times of emotional dysregulation in both parent and child. Parenting interventions may be useful for parents to improve in their emotion regulation as well as developing skills in responding to children’s emotions that assist the child to understand and regulate emotions (emotion competence). Tuning in to Toddlers (TOTS) is a new parenting program that aims to improve parents’ emotional responsiveness, coaching and emotion regulation (aspects of emotion socialization) to promote optimal emotional development in toddlers, and prevent social and behavioral difficulties. This paper outlines the rationale, methodology, intervention and recruitment process used in a trial to establish program efficacy. Method/Design: Parents of toddlers aged 18-36 months old were recruited through child care centers (CC) and maternal child health (MCH) centers in Melbourne, Australia and were allocated to either intervention or a 15-month wait-list control condition in a cluster-randomized controlled design. Inclusion criteria were a child in the age range at baseline attending one of the CC or MCH centers. Exclusion criteria were if the parent/carer had insufficient English to attend the intervention and complete measures. Parents in the intervention condition participated in the 6-session group TOTS program delivered by 2 facilitators using a structured manual and measures of program fidelity and acceptability. Participants in the wait-list control condition received the intervention after a 15-month waiting period. Participants completed measures at baseline, post- intervention (intervention participants only) and 15-month follow-up. Primary outcome measures included parent emotion socialization (self-report and observed). Secondary outcomes included parent-reported parent functioning and toddler social, emotional and behavioral functioning, and parent and toddler systemic cortisol stress (using hair samples). The study was designed to comply with the CONSORT statement and intervention reporting outlined using TIDieR. Results: Three hundred and six parents were recruited and completed baseline parent questionnaires, with a further 234 completing parent-child observation assessments, 235 parent cortisol, and 198 child cortisol. Discussion: This paper is a methodological description of the TOTS randomized controlled trial evaluation protocol. It outlines some of the challenges in recruiting parents of toddlers to parenting programs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{havighurst2019tuning,
  author = {Sophie S. Havighurst and Christiane E. Kehoe and Ann E. Harley and Ameika M. Johnson and Nicholas B. Allen and Rae Thomas},
  title = {{Tuning in to Toddlers: Research Protocol and Recruitment for Evaluation of an Emotion Socialization Program for Parents of Toddlers}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01054},
}
Figure