Tunable CHA/AEI Zeolite Intergrowths with A Priori Biselective Organic Structure‐Directing Agents: Controlling Enrichment and Implications for Selective Catalytic Reduction of NOx

Estefanía Bello‐Jurado, Daniel Schwalbe‐Koda, Mathias Nero, Cecilia Paris, Toni Uusimäki, Yuriy Román‐Leshkov, Avelino Corma, Tom Willhammar, Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli, Manuel MolinerAngewandte 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel computational approach to design "biselective" organic structure-directing agents (OSDAs) that precisely control the synthesis of CHA/AEI zeolite intergrowths. These new materials exhibit superior performance in the selective catalytic reduction of NOx, even outperforming established catalysts, paving the way for more efficient and stable catalytic converters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The selective catalytic reduction (SCR) of NOx is crucial for reducing harmful emissions from vehicles. Copper-exchanged zeolites, particularly those with CHA and AEI frameworks, are the workhorses for this application. While Cu-AEI offers better hydrothermal stability and Cu-CHA is easier to synthesize, combining their advantages through intergrowth materials has been challenging. Traditional methods rely on mixtures of expensive OSDAs and offer limited control over the precise phase composition of the intergrowth, leading to complex synthesis and unpredictable catalytic performance. This paper addresses the need for a more controlled and efficient method to synthesize CHA/AEI intergrowths with tunable compositions.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a novel "a priori" computational methodology. This approach utilizes high-throughput simulations to predict and design specific organic structure-directing agents (OSDAs). The key criteria for OSDA selection are:

  1. Biselectivity: The OSDA must exhibit similarly strong binding energies towards both CHA and AEI frameworks, while having weak binding towards undesired competing phases.
  2. Favorable Molecular Shape: The OSDA's shape must facilitate the crystallization of both frameworks within the same crystal.
  3. Synthetic Simplicity: The OSDA should be easy and inexpensive to synthesize.

To characterize the synthesized intergrowths, the researchers employed advanced electron microscopy techniques:

  • Integrated Differential Phase Contrast Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (iDPC STEM): This technique provides high-resolution, nanoscale imaging that reveals the local crystallographic ordering within the intergrown materials.
  • Scanning Electron Diffraction (SED) / 4DSTEM: This method allows for the acquisition of diffraction patterns from very small regions, enabling detailed analysis of local crystallographic variations and twinning.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The paper relies on:

  • Computational simulations: A high-throughput simulation framework was used to screen potential OSDAs based on binding energies and molecular shape descriptors.
  • Existing zeolite synthesis knowledge: The study builds upon established knowledge of CHA and AEI framework synthesis and the role of specific OSDAs (e.g., TMAda for CHA, DEDMP for AEI).
  • Experimental characterization data: PXRD, FESEM, iDPC STEM, SED, N2 adsorption, and MAS NMR were used to characterize the synthesized materials.
  • Catalytic performance data: NOx conversion and N2O selectivity measurements under various conditions were collected for the synthesized catalysts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Computational Design of Biselective OSDAs: The most significant insight is the successful development of a computational framework to design OSDAs that can simultaneously direct the formation of two distinct zeolite frameworks (CHA and AEI) within a single crystal. This moves beyond trial-and-error synthesis.
  • Controlling Phase Enrichment: By carefully selecting OSDA candidates based on their predicted binding energies and molecular shapes, the researchers demonstrated the ability to tune the relative proportions of CHA and AEI within the intergrowth. OSDA3 led to a more balanced CHA/AEI intergrowth, while OSDA4 favored AEI-enriched domains.
  • Nanoscale Structural Insights: Advanced electron microscopy (iDPC STEM and SED) provided unprecedented nanoscale details of the intergrowth structures, revealing disordered domains and evidence of twinning, which are crucial for understanding their properties.
  • Superior Catalytic Performance: The designed CHA/AEI intergrowths, when loaded with copper, exhibited outstanding performance in NOx SCR, particularly in terms of hydrothermal stability. This suggests that the intergrowth structure offers synergistic benefits over single-phase zeolites.

Key Results

  • OSDA Design: Two novel biselective OSDAs, OSDA3 and OSDA4, were identified through computational screening.
  • Synthesis of CHA/AEI Intergrowths: Successful synthesis of CHA/AEI intergrowths was achieved using OSDA3 and OSDA4, with distinct phase enrichments observed.
  • Structural Characterization: iDPC STEM and SED confirmed the intergrowth nature of the materials and revealed nanoscale structural features, including disordered domains and twinning.
  • Catalytic Performance: Cu-exchanged CHA/AEI intergrowths showed excellent NO conversion and low N2O selectivity. Crucially, they demonstrated remarkable hydrothermal stability, even surpassing commercial CHA-type catalysts, and approached the performance of AEI-type catalysts. For example, after severe steam treatment at 850°C for 13 hours, the intergrowth materials maintained significantly higher NO conversion compared to pure CHA catalysts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While the computational approach is powerful, the paper acknowledges that the precise control over phase enrichment is still an area for further refinement. The "a priori" methodology provides strong candidates, but experimental fine-tuning is still necessary. The study focused on specific OSDAs, and further exploration of the OSDA design space could yield even better results.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this methodology can be extended to synthesize other complex zeolite intergrowths with unique catalytic properties. This opens a broad avenue for designing advanced materials for various industrial and environmental applications. Further investigation into the structure-activity relationships of these intergrowths under different operating conditions is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

A novel ab initio methodology based on high-throughput simulations has permitted designing unique biselective organic structure-directing agents (OSDAs) that allow the efficient synthesis of CHA/AEI zeolite intergrowth materials with controlled phase compositions. Distinctive local crystallographic ordering of the CHA/AEI intergrowths was revealed at the nanoscale level using integrated differential phase contrast scanning transmission electron microscopy (iDPC STEM). These novel CHA/AEI materials have been tested for the selective catalytic reduction (SCR) of NOx, presenting an outstanding catalytic performance and hydrothermal stability, even surpassing the performance of the well-established commercial CHA-type catalyst. This methodology opens the possibility for synthetizing new zeolite intergrowths with more complex structures and unique catalytic properties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bellojurado2022tunable,
  author = {Estefanía Bello‐Jurado and Daniel Schwalbe‐Koda and Mathias Nero and Cecilia Paris and Toni Uusimäki and Yuriy Román‐Leshkov and Avelino Corma and Tom Willhammar and Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli and Manuel Moliner},
  title = {{Tunable CHA/AEI Zeolite Intergrowths with A Priori Biselective Organic Structure‐Directing Agents: Controlling Enrichment and Implications for Selective Catalytic Reduction of NOx}},
  booktitle = {Angewandte},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1002/anie.202201837},
}
Figure