Tubeless versus common minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy for renal stones under local anesthesia: analysis of clinical outcomes

Genyi Qu, Yong Xu, Tang Cheng, JinGe Liu, Hai-bo Nie, XiuFang Jiang, Wenlin Huang, Guang YangResearch 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Background: To compare the clinical outcomes of tubeless minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy (mPCNL) and common minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy under local anesthesia, and to explore the feasibility, safety and clinical efficacy of tubeless mPCNL under local anesthesia. Methods: Patients with PCNL who underwent local anesthesia from January 1, 2018 to November 30, 2018. The patients were divided into Group 1 (tubeless mPCNL: indwelling double J tube, no indwelling nephrostomy tube) and group 2 (common mPCNL: indwelling double J tube and nephrostomy tube). Results: In group 1, the VAS scores of 6 hours after surgery was 4.07±1.79 significantly lower than that for group 2 (6.24±1.33, P<0.05). The hospital stay for group 1 was significantly shorter than group 2 (3.15±1.42 vs 6.48±1.88 days, P<0.01). There were no significant differences in the operation time, stone removal rate, or complications. Conclusion: Tubeless mPCNL is a simple, safe and effective technique under local anesthesia that significantly reduces postoperative pain and shortens hospital stays.

Introduction

Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) is the gold-standard treatment for renal stones larger than 20mm. Traditionally, surgeons leave a nephrostomy tube in the kidney post-procedure for drainage and hemostasis. However, this tube often causes significant postoperative pain by irritating the renal pelvis and intercostal nerves. Furthermore, the standard use of general or epidural anesthesia carries risks for certain patient populations. This study evaluates a "tubeless" approach—omitting the external drainage tube—performed under local anesthesia to improve patient recovery and comfort.

Methods and Patient Cohort

This retrospective study analyzed 135 patients treated at The Affiliated ZhuZhou Hospital, XiangYa Medical College, between January and November 2018. Patients were divided into two cohorts:

  • Group 1 (Tubeless, n=68): Received an internal 5F double-J stent but no external nephrostomy tube.
  • Group 2 (Common, n=67): Received both the internal stent and an 18F external nephrostomy tube.

All procedures utilized local infiltration anesthesia (1% lidocaine) and minimally invasive techniques (18F working sheath, holmium laser). The groups were well-balanced regarding age, BMI, and stone characteristics.

Table 1: Baseline demographic and stone characteristics of the study groups.

Results

The tubeless approach demonstrated significant advantages in postoperative recovery without sacrificing surgical efficacy.

Pain and Analgesia

The primary benefit of the tubeless technique was a reduction in pain. Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) scores 6 hours post-surgery were significantly lower in Group 1 (4.07 ± 1.79) compared to Group 2 (6.24 ± 1.33, P < 0.05). This trend continued into the first postoperative day. Consequently, fewer patients in the tubeless group required additional analgesics (6 vs. 15, P = 0.042).

Hospital Stay and Safety

The average hospital stay for the tubeless group was nearly half that of the common group (3.15 vs. 6.48 days, P < 0.01). Importantly, there were no significant differences in operation time, postoperative fever, or hemoglobin decline, indicating that the omission of the nephrostomy tube did not increase surgical risk.

Table 2: Comparison of intraoperative and postoperative clinical outcomes between tubeless and common mPCNL.

Surgical Efficacy

Both groups achieved high stone clearance rates, with approximately 97% of patients in both cohorts successfully cleared of stones. There was no statistical difference in operation time, which averaged approximately 70 minutes for both groups.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study confirms that the nephrostomy tube is a major driver of postoperative morbidity. By removing it, surgeons eliminate mechanical stimulation of the subcostal nerves and irritation of the renal pelvis. Performing the procedure under local anesthesia further facilitates "rapid rehabilitation," as patients can mobilize and eat almost immediately post-surgery without the fasting requirements of general anesthesia.

While this study is limited by its retrospective nature and the exclusion of complex cases (e.g., staghorn calculi), the results strongly support tubeless mPCNL under local anesthesia as a safe, effective, and patient-friendly alternative for non-complex renal stones.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: To compare the clinical outcomes of tubeless minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy(mPCNL)and common minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy under local anesthesia, and to explore the feasibility, safety and clinical efficacy of tubeless mPCNL under local anesthesia. Methods: Patients with PCNL who underwent local anesthesia from January 1, 2018 to November 30, 2018. The patients were divided into Group 1 (tubeless mPCNL: indwelling double J tube, no indwelling nephrostomy tube) and group 2 (common mPCNL: indwelling double J tube and nephrostomy tube). The intraoperative and postoperative parameters of the two groups were compared, including operation time, average postoperative hospital stay, puncture position, postoperative hemoglobin decline, postoperative visual analogue scale (VAS), analgesic use, postoperative fever and stone removal rate. Results: In group1,the VAS scores of 6 hours after surgery was 4.07±1.79 significantly lower than that for group 2 (4.07±1.79 vs 6.24±1.33, P&lt;0.05). and There was a statistically significant difference in the use of analgesics between the two groups(P&lt;0.05). The VAS scores of day 1 after surgery (2.50±1.76 vs 3.83±2.22 in group1 and group2) was significantly lower in the tubeless mPCNL (P&lt;0.05). The hospital stay for group 1 was significantly shorter than group 2(3.15±1.42 vs 6.48±1.88 days, P&lt;0.01)). There were no significant differences in the operation time, puncture position, postoperative hemoglobin decline rate, VAS score on the day of discharge, postoperative fever, and stone removal rate between the two groups (P&gt;0.05). Conclusion: Tubeless mPCNL is a simple, safe and effective technique under local anesthesia. It is worthy of clinical application. Tubeless mPCNL treatment for renal stones can significantly reduce postoperative pain and shorten hospital stays compared with common m PCNL.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qu2020tubeless,
  author = {Genyi Qu and Yong Xu and Tang Cheng and JinGe Liu and Hai-bo Nie and XiuFang Jiang and Wenlin Huang and Guang Yang},
  title = {{Tubeless versus common minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy for renal stones under local anesthesia: analysis of clinical outcomes}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-22569/v1},
}
Figure