Trustworthy Wireless Sensor Networks for Monitoring Humidity and Moisture Environments

Radomir Prodanovic, Sohail Sarang, Dejan D. Rancic, Ivan Vulic, Goran M. Stojanovic, Stevan Stankovski, Gordana Ostojic, Igor Baranovski, Dusan Maksovic2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel trust model for wireless sensor networks (WSNs) specifically designed for monitoring humidity and moisture in agricultural and industrial settings. By integrating digital signatures, public key infrastructure (PKI), and timestamping, the model ensures the authenticity and temporal integrity of sensor data, addressing a critical gap in existing WSN trust mechanisms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are increasingly deployed in critical applications like agriculture and industry for environmental monitoring. However, a significant challenge lies in ensuring the trustworthiness of the data collected. Without robust trust mechanisms, decisions based on sensor readings could be flawed, leading to suboptimal outcomes or even system failures. Existing WSN trust models often focus on data authenticity but overlook the crucial aspect of temporal integrity – ensuring that data is not only from a legitimate source but also recorded at the correct time and hasn't been tampered with post-collection. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a comprehensive trust model that incorporates the time dimension.

Methods

The proposed trust model leverages a combination of established and novel techniques:

  • Digital Signatures and Public Key Infrastructure (PKI): This forms the backbone of authentication. Each sensor and monitoring entity is issued a digital certificate, binding their public key to their identity. Digital signatures, generated using private keys, are used to verify the origin and integrity of messages. PKI manages these certificates and ensures a trust chain.
  • Timestamping Authority (TSA): To address the temporal integrity of data, the model integrates timestamping. When a sensor collects data, it requests a timestamp from a TSA. This timestamp, cryptographically signed by the TSA, attests to the time the data was recorded. This prevents data from being backdated or altered after its original creation time.
  • Authentication and Time Tokens: The model defines specific tokens for establishing trust. An "authentication token" is generated when entities communicate, verifying their identity. A "time token" is generated by the TSA and associated with the sensor data, providing temporal proof.
  • Castalia Network Simulator: The proposed model's performance was evaluated using the Castalia simulator. This allowed for the assessment of energy consumption at sender and receiver nodes, as well as packet delay under various network conditions.
  • Ascertia TSA Crusher: This tool was used to evaluate the efficiency and response times of various free timestamping authorities (TSAs) when handling requests from multiple sensors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated scenarios within the Castalia network simulator.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Time Dimension is Crucial for Trust: The paper strongly emphasizes that true trustworthiness in sensor data requires not just knowing who sent it, but also when it was sent and that this timestamp is immutable. This temporal aspect is often overlooked in WSN security.
  • PKI and Digital Signatures are Foundational: The model builds upon well-established cryptographic principles to ensure data authenticity and integrity, providing a solid base for trust.
  • Free TSAs Offer a Viable, Though Limited, Solution: The evaluation of free TSAs shows that they can be effective for smaller deployments, but their performance degrades significantly under heavy load or with a large number of simultaneous requests. This highlights the trade-offs between cost and reliability.
  • Energy and Delay Trade-offs Exist: Implementing robust security measures like digital signatures and timestamping inevitably incurs overhead. The paper quantifies these increases in energy consumption and packet delay, providing valuable data for system designers.

Key Results

  • Energy Consumption: The proposed model, using RSA-3072, increased receiver node energy consumption by up to 126.3% and sender node energy consumption by up to 9.3% compared to a non-signature scenario.
  • Packet Delay: The implementation of the trust model increased packet delay by up to 15.6% compared to a system without security measures.
  • TSA Performance:
    • For a single monitoring application, TSA5 offered the best average total time consumed (TTC) at 1.186s, with 84.36% of requests processed in the first second.
  • In a scenario with two monitoring applications, TSA5 still performed well with an average TTC of 2.213s.
  • In a scenario with three monitoring applications, TSA5 and TSA7 showed the best results, with average TTCs of 3.226s and 3.242s respectively.
  • The study found that free TSAs are generally reliable for up to 30 simultaneous sensor requests. Beyond this, performance degrades, and some TSAs may fail to respond.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Energy and Delay Overhead: The paper acknowledges that the implemented trust mechanisms introduce increased energy consumption and packet delay. While quantified, further optimization to minimize this overhead would be beneficial.
  • Free TSA Limitations: The reliance on free TSAs presents scalability and reliability challenges for large-scale deployments. The authors suggest establishing internal TSAs as a more robust, albeit expensive, alternative.
  • Sensor Hardware Constraints: The paper notes that sensors have limited resources, making it challenging to generate private keys locally. While the model relies on certification authorities for key generation, future work could explore more efficient on-device key management solutions.
  • Environmental Disturbances: The paper briefly mentions that environmental factors can affect WSNs. While the model can detect changes in transmitted data, further research into how environmental disturbances impact the trust mechanism itself could be valuable.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into optimizing the model for energy efficiency and exploring more robust TSA solutions for large-scale deployments. They also highlight the need to consider the impact of environmental disturbances on WSN communication and trust.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{prodanovic2021trustworthy,
  author = {Radomir Prodanovic and Sohail Sarang and Dejan D. Rancic and Ivan Vulic and Goran M. Stojanovic and Stevan Stankovski and Gordana Ostojic and Igor Baranovski and Dusan Maksovic},
  title = {{Trustworthy Wireless Sensor Networks for Monitoring Humidity and Moisture Environments}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21113636},
}
Figure