Abstract: Advances in predictive algorithms are revolutionizing how we understand and design effective decision support systems in many sectors. The expanding role of predictive algorithms is part of a broader movement toward using data-driven machine learning (ML) for modalities including images, natural language, speech. This article reviews whether and to what extent predictive algorithms can assist decision-making in forest conservation and management. Although state-of-the-art ML algorithms provide new opportunities, adoption has been slow in forest decision-making. This review shows how domain-specific characteristics, such as system complexity, impose limits on using predictive algorithms in forest conservation and management. We conclude with possible directions for developing new predictive tools and approaches to support meaningful forest decisions through easily interpretable and explainable recommendations.
Introduction
While machine learning (ML) is revolutionizing fields like healthcare and law, its impact on forest conservation remains limited. The core challenge is that forests are not just biological entities; they are complex social-ecological systems (SES). Current predictive models often fail because they treat forest management as a purely technical optimization problem. In reality, forest decisions involve non-linear dynamics, long time lags, and a messy web of human stakeholders—from government officials to indigenous communities. When algorithms ignore these "human-in-the-loop" variables, they produce recommendations that are either ignored by field staff or, worse, exacerbate existing social inequalities.
The Complexity of Forest Systems
Forest management takes place within a framework where biophysical resources are inextricably linked to governance structures and diverse actors. A central question, such as "Where to plant trees?", cannot be answered by looking at soil quality alone. It requires understanding the resource system (forest patches, plantations), the governance system (forest rules, land tenure), and the multi-stakeholder landscape (NGOs, local governments, and villagers).
As shown in the framework above, action situations are influenced by direct feedback loops between resource units and outcomes. Predictive algorithms that fail to account for these socio-economic and ecological benefits often fall into "abstraction traps," assuming a model trained in one context will be portable to another without considering local power dynamics.
Machine Learning Taxonomy in Forestry
To understand the barriers to adoption, it is necessary to categorize the types of ML currently being applied. This review synthesizes findings from 81 peer-reviewed studies, evaluating them through the lens of "Trustworthy AI."
Most current applications rely on supervised learning, which requires high-quality labeled data—a resource that is often scarce in remote forest regions. Furthermore, there is a significant "scale mismatch" where models capturing relationships at a 10km grid level fail to provide actionable insights at the local community level.
Barriers to Adoption: Trust and Interpretability
A primary hurdle is the "Black Box" trust deficit. If a forest official does not understand why a model suggests a specific site for a plantation, they are likely to ignore it. The authors argue that a model with slightly lower accuracy but higher interpretability is often more valuable in the field. This is particularly true for deep learning models, which struggle to provide reliable uncertainty projections critical for high-stakes conservation decisions.
Ethical Considerations and Power Dynamics
Algorithms are not neutral. Local elites can manipulate algorithmic deployments to serve their interests at the expense of the larger public or indigenous groups. Developers often fall into the "Formalism Trap," mathematically defining "fairness" in a way that ignores actual social context. Ensuring fairness and justice requires moving beyond technical metrics to include algorithmic audits and interdisciplinary collaboration between data scientists and social scientists.
Future Directions
The paper calls for "Interpretable-by-Design" models and the development of Theory-Guided ML that incorporates domain-specific knowledge, such as physics-based loss functions that ensure tree growth predictions don't violate biological laws. By bridging the gap between biophysical measurements and social variables, we can develop predictive tools that offer meaningful, explainable recommendations for forest conservation.
Summary updated