Abstract
This paper is concerned with the boundary-layer separation in subsonic and transonic flows caused by a two-dimensional isolated wall roughness. The process of the separation is analysed by means of two approaches: the direct numerical simulation (DNS) of the flow using the Navier–Stokes equations, and the numerical solution of the triple-deck equations. Since the triple-deck theory relies on the assumption that the Reynolds number ( $Re$ ) is large, we performed the Navier–Stokes calculations at $Re=4\times 10^{5}$ based on the distance of the roughness element from the leading edge of the flat plate. This $Re$ is also relevant for aeronautical applications. Two sets of calculation were conducted with the free-stream Mach number $Ma_{\infty }=0.5$ and $Ma_{\infty }=0.87$ . We used different roughness element heights, some of which were large enough to cause a well-developed separation region behind the roughness. We found that the two approaches generally compare well with one another in terms of wall shear stress, longitudinal pressure gradient and detachment/reattachment points of the separation bubbles (when present). The main differences were found in proximity to the centre of the roughness element, where the wall shear stress and longitudinal pressure gradient predicted by the triple-deck theory are noticeably different from those predicted by DNS. In addition, DNS predicts slightly longer separation regions.
Introduction: The Challenge of Surface Roughness
In aeronautics, even tiny surface imperfections—like a rivet head or a paint chip—can disrupt the "boundary layer" (the thin layer of air hugging a wing). If the bump is large enough or the flow is fast enough, the air can actually lift off the surface, creating a "separation bubble" that increases drag and alters flight characteristics.
Engineers have two main ways to study this:
- Triple-deck theory: A classical asymptotic method developed in the late 1960s. It breaks the flow into three layers (decks) to simplify the complex Navier-Stokes equations. It’s computationally "cheap" but relies on the assumption that the Reynolds number ($Re$) is extremely large.
- Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS): The "gold standard" of fluid dynamics. It solves the full, unsimplified Navier-Stokes equations. It is highly accurate but computationally "expensive" and difficult to implement for high-speed, separated flows.
The authors set out to determine if the computationally efficient Triple-deck theory is still a reliable tool for modern aeronautical applications ($Re = 4 \times 10^5$) compared to high-fidelity DNS.
Methods
The researchers modeled a two-dimensional flat plate with a single Gaussian-shaped hump. They tested two scenarios: Subsonic (Mach 0.5) and Transonic (Mach 0.87).
- Triple-deck Approach: They solved the lower-deck equations using a second-order finite-difference method on a non-uniform mesh. The interaction between the boundary layer and the outer flow was handled via a Hilbert integral (subsonic) or a Transonic Small Perturbation (TSP) integral.
- DNS Approach: They used a high-order spectral/$hp$ element method with a Discontinuous Galerkin (DG) spatial discretization. This allowed them to capture very fine details of the flow using a mesh of 500 × 66 elements, with a solution polynomial of order three (effectively 2000 points in the streamwise direction).
Key Results and Comparison
Both methods successfully predicted separation for the same test cases ($10\%$ and $15\%$ hump heights in subsonic; $15\%$ in transonic). However, significant differences emerged in the local flow details.
- Pressure Gradient Discrepancies: At the center of the hump, the maximum difference in the longitudinal pressure gradient ($dp/dx$) was roughly 27% for the subsonic case and over 54% for the transonic case.
- Separation Bubble Length: DNS consistently predicted slightly longer separation regions than Triple-deck theory. For example, in the $15\%$ height subsonic case, the reattachment point predicted by DNS was about 26% further downstream than the theory suggested.
- Wall Shear Stress: Differences in wall shear stress ($\tau_{xy}$) near the hump center ranged from 11% to 30%.
The "Zero-Gradient" Assumption in Triple-deck theory—which assumes the pressure gradient perpendicular to the wall is zero—was found to be inaccurate near the hump. This neglected vertical pressure gradient is a primary reason for the discrepancies.
Conclusion
While Triple-deck theory is a powerful tool for predicting the global structure of boundary-layer separation (detachment and reattachment points), it struggles with local accuracy at the center of roughness elements, especially as speeds approach the transonic regime. The gap between theory and simulation widens with increasing Mach number and roughness height. For quantitative engineering design in nonlinear, transonic regimes, Triple-deck theory should be used with caution, while remaining a valuable model for quick estimates and receptivity studies.
Summary updated