Trial-to-trial variability of phase precession in the hippocampus

Robert C. Schmidt, Kamran Diba, Christian Leibold, Dietmar Schmitz, György Buzsáki, Richard KempterBMC 2009 · DOI

Introduction

In the study of spatial navigation, the rat hippocampus serves as a primary model for understanding how the brain encodes location and sequences. Within this region, "place cells" fire when an animal occupies a specific location, known as a place field. A critical temporal component of this activity is phase precession: as the rat moves through a place field, the timing of a cell's firing shifts to progressively earlier phases of the background 8Hz theta oscillation. This mechanism is widely believed to be fundamental for encoding spatial information.

Traditionally, neuroscientists have analyzed phase precession by "pooling" data from dozens of traversals through a place field to overcome neural noise. However, this approach assumes that the aggregate plot accurately reflects underlying neural dynamics. This study investigates whether the "average" model of phase precession masks significant, unexplained variability present in individual trials.

Methodology

Researchers analyzed electrophysiological recordings from pyramidal cells in the rat hippocampus across multiple subjects. The core of the study involved a comparative analysis between two distinct data perspectives:

  1. Pooled-trial analysis: The standard method of aggregating all traversals of a place field into a single dataset.
  2. Single-trial analysis: Examining the properties of phase precession within individual, isolated traversals.

The comparison focused on three primary metrics: phase-position correlation (how well phase predicts location), phase-time correlation (how well phase predicts elapsed time), and phase range (the total degrees of phase shift). To ensure that single-trial patterns were not merely noisy subsets of the aggregate, the researchers compared real data against "surrogate trials"—randomly sampled points from the pooled set.

Key Results

The analysis revealed that single-trial dynamics are fundamentally different from the pooled averages typically reported in literature.

Comparison of pooled (top row) versus single-trial (bottom rows) phase precession across different rats and cells.

The 180° vs. 360° Discrepancy

The most striking finding was the difference in phase range. While pooled data often shows phase precession spanning a full 360° (a complete theta cycle), single trials most frequently span only about 180°. This suggests that during any given run, a neuron utilizes only half of the available "coding space."

Distortion through Pooling

The study demonstrated that pooling is not a neutral act of noise reduction. Instead, it alters the basic statistical measures of phase precession. Single trials were found to be distinct, non-random structures that do not simply mirror the aggregate pool. The act of averaging multiple runs creates a composite picture that may never actually occur in the brain during a single journey.

Unexplained "Jitter"

There is massive trial-to-trial variability in how phase precession manifests. While factors such as running speed and firing rate account for a small portion of this variance, the majority remains unexplained. This "jitter" suggests the presence of internal brain states or external variables—such as cognitive load or attention—that current spatial navigation models do not yet incorporate.

Discussion and Future Directions

By highlighting that the "average" neuron is a statistical construct that may not exist in real-time processing, this research pushes the field toward a more nuanced understanding of hippocampal function. The primary challenge moving forward is identifying the source of the unexplained variance.

Future research should investigate whether this variability is mere biological noise or if it carries functional information, such as representing alternative paths or memory retrieval. Understanding the influence of other brain regions, like the entorhinal cortex, on hippocampal timing will also be crucial for developing models that reflect the true, dynamic nature of neural computation during navigation.

This summary is based on the poster presentation "Trial-to-trial variability of phase precession in the hippocampus," published in BMC Neuroscience (2009).

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmidt2009trial,
  author = {Robert C. Schmidt and Kamran Diba and Christian Leibold and Dietmar Schmitz and György Buzsáki and Richard Kempter},
  title = {{Trial-to-trial variability of phase precession in the hippocampus}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-2202-10-s1-p339},
}
Figure