Trial-Oriented Visual Rearrangement

Yuyi Liu, Xinhang Song, Tianliang Qi, Shuqiang JiangICCV 2025

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Trial-Oriented Visual Rearrangement" (TOR) framework that tackles the complex challenge of restoring a disordered room to its intended state, even when objects are moved, change appearance, or are added/removed. TOR uses a dynamic "diff-cloud" representation and an iterative trial-and-assessment mechanism to efficiently handle these diverse changes, outperforming existing methods on challenging benchmarks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Visual room rearrangement is a crucial task for embodied AI agents, requiring them to not only navigate and interact with objects but also to detect and correct changes in a scene to match a desired goal configuration. The core challenge lies in the diverse nature of these changes: objects can be moved, their appearance can alter (e.g., a door opening/closing), or objects can be added or removed entirely. Existing methods often struggle to handle these different types of changes in a unified manner. Modular approaches, while effective for movement, falter with appearance and existence changes due to the heterogeneous nature of the inference spaces. End-to-end reinforcement learning methods, on the other hand, can become computationally intractable with the complexity of these diverse changes. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a unified framework that can effectively and efficiently manage all three types of object changes.

Methods

The proposed "Trial-Oriented Visual Rearrangement" (TOR) framework is modular, comprising three key components:

  • Scene Change Detection (Differential Point Cloud): TOR utilizes a dynamic "diff-cloud" (differential point cloud) to represent scene changes. Unlike static approaches, this diff-cloud is updated dynamically based on the agent's interactions and observations, allowing it to capture localized, fine-grained changes in object position, appearance, and even existence. This representation is robust to varying viewpoints and obstructions. Scene changes are then matched using a weighted bipartite graph matching based on geometric features.
  • Interaction Assessment Module: This module evaluates the effectiveness of each action taken by the agent. It quantifies how much an action reduces the discrepancy between the current and goal scene configurations by measuring the change in the diff-cloud. An action is deemed effective if it leads to a significant reduction in this discrepancy.
  • Trial Module: This is the core of the "trial-oriented" approach. It leverages both static scoring (based on scene matching and contextual information) and dynamic feedback from the assessment module. For each detected change, the trial module prioritizes potential operations (e.g., pick, put, push, open) and iteratively attempts them. If an operation is successful, the change is marked as resolved. If it fails, the agent learns from the assessment feedback and tries the next best option, progressively refining its strategy until the scene is restored or the cluster is deemed unsolvable. This iterative process effectively prunes the search space and turns a complex reasoning problem into a discrimination task.

Datasets

  • AI2THOR Rearrangement Challenge (RoomR dataset): Used for validation and testing, this dataset focuses on movement and appearance changes within single-room environments.
  • Versatile Indoor Rearrangement (VIR) dataset: Introduced by the authors, this dataset is built on ProcTHOR and is designed to be more practical and challenging. It includes multi-room environments and covers all three types of object changes: movement, appearance, and existence. The VIR dataset is further categorized into general, movement-specific, and existence-specific settings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Representation for Diverse Changes: The dynamic diff-cloud is a key innovation, providing a single representation that can capture movement, appearance, and existence changes, overcoming a major limitation of prior work.
  • Embodiment as a Constraint: The framework leverages the inherent physical constraints of embodied agents (i.e., actions must comply with physical laws) to prune the reasoning space, making the task more tractable.
  • Iterative Trial-and-Error with Feedback: The trial module's combination of static scoring and dynamic assessment feedback is crucial. It allows the agent to learn from its mistakes and progressively refine its actions, mimicking a more human-like problem-solving approach.
  • Complexity Reduction: By shifting from a multiplicative complexity (handling each change type independently) to an additive one (managing each change type sequentially), the TOR framework significantly reduces computational demands.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-Art Performance: TOR achieves state-of-the-art results on the AI2THOR Rearrangement Challenge, significantly improving success rates and reducing misplaced objects compared to existing methods like TIDEE, MaSS, and CAVR.
  • Superiority on Complex Scenarios: On the more challenging VIR dataset, TOR demonstrates substantial advantages, achieving more than a twofold improvement in room-level success rates, highlighting its effectiveness in complex, multi-room environments with diverse object changes.
  • Efficiency and Robustness: The framework shows robust accuracy in restoring objects without introducing new misplacements and demonstrates a better ability to restore scenes closer to the goal state, even if not fully completed.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Undetected Changes: The authors acknowledge that a primary failure reason for their method is undetected changes. This suggests that future work could focus on improving the coverage and fidelity of the diff-cloud building process.
  • Existence Changes: While the paper introduces existence changes, the authors note that the disappearance of originally existing objects is not considered in this work. Future research could explore this aspect.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: The paper presents parameter ablation studies, indicating that optimal performance is achieved with specific diff-cloud granularity and reduction thresholds. Further exploration into adaptive or learned hyperparameter settings could be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025trial,
  author = {Yuyi Liu and Xinhang Song and Tianliang Qi and Shuqiang Jiang},
  title = {{Trial-Oriented Visual Rearrangement}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF International Conference on Computer Vision},
  year = {2025},
}

Loading related content...

Figure