Trends of human brucellosis in Italy, 1998–2010

Francesca Romana Mancini, Antonino Bella, Caterina Graziani, Cinzia Marianelli, Lapo Mughini‐Gras, Paolo Pasquali, Maria Grazia Pompa, Caterina Rizzo, E Rizzuto, Luca BusaniEpidemiology 2013 · DOI

Abstract

This study describes the epidemiological trends and spatial distribution of human brucellosis in Italy over a 13-year period (1998–2010). During this time, 8,483 cases were notified, representing a significant 89% decrease in annual reports. The majority of cases were concentrated in southern Italy, specifically in the regions of Campania, Apulia, Calabria, and Sicily. A distinct seasonal pattern was observed, with cases peaking in late spring. Statistical modeling suggests a high rate of underreporting, with an average factor of 12.5, indicating that the true disease burden is substantially higher than official surveillance suggests.

Introduction

Brucellosis is a major zoonotic disease caused by Brucella bacteria, primarily transmitted from animals to humans through the consumption of contaminated food or direct contact with infected livestock. While rarely fatal, it causes chronic, debilitating illness and remains a significant public health concern in the Mediterranean basin.

A critical challenge in managing brucellosis is the discrepancy between official surveillance data and the actual number of infections. Underreporting can lead to an underestimation of the resources required for effective eradication programs. This research aims to characterize the epidemiology of brucellosis in Italy and estimate the true incidence by modeling underreporting rates.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-faceted analytical approach:

  1. Descriptive Epidemiology: Analysis of 13 years of mandatory notification data to identify demographic, temporal, and spatial trends.
  2. Underreporting Estimation: To estimate the "true" number of cases, the authors compared data from the National Surveillance System (SIMI) with Hospital Discharge Records (SDO). They employed a PERT distribution to calculate an underreporting factor ($\delta$).
  3. Spatial Analysis: Multilevel mixed-effects Poisson regression was used to determine Incidence Rate Ratios (IRRs) at the provincial level, identifying specific high-risk hotspots.

Data sources included SIMI (8,483 notified cases), SDO (6,946 hospitalizations), and population data from the Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT).

Results and Key Insights

Spatial Distribution and the "Southern Stronghold"

The study confirms that brucellosis in Italy is highly regional. Four southern regions—Campania, Apulia, Calabria, and Sicily—accounted for 89% of all notified cases. In contrast, cases in northern Italy were sporadic and typically associated with travel or the consumption of imported contaminated food.

Spatial distribution of human brucellosis incidence rates in Italy across different provinces.

Seasonality and Occupational Risk

A clear seasonal trend was identified, with incidence peaking in May. This peak corresponds to the lactation period of sheep and goats, which leads to increased production and consumption of fresh, unpasteurized cheese—a primary transmission vehicle.

The seasonal distribution of brucellosis cases in Italy, showing a clear peak in May.

Demographically, men represented 60% of the cases. This gender disparity is likely due to occupational exposure, as men are more frequently employed as shepherds, veterinarians, or slaughterhouse workers in endemic areas.

The Hidden Burden of Disease

The most significant finding is the extent of underreporting. While 8,483 cases were officially recorded, the model estimates the actual number of infections between 1998 and 2010 was approximately 98,572. This suggests that for every reported case, roughly 11 to 12 others were missed by the surveillance system.

Despite the high estimated burden, the reported incidence showed a dramatic 89% decline over the study period, falling from over 1,000 cases in 1998 to 138 in 2010. The disease remains low-fatality (0.2%), though 72% of notified cases required hospitalization.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights that while official numbers are decreasing, the "true" burden of brucellosis in southern Italy remains high enough to warrant continued aggressive intervention.

Limitations include the anonymity of the datasets, which prevented a direct "capture-recapture" link between individual patients in the SIMI and SDO systems. Additionally, the lack of socio-economic and professional data limited the ability to pinpoint specific individual risk factors beyond geography.

The authors advocate for a "One Health" approach, emphasizing that better integration between veterinary and human health surveillance is essential for the final elimination of brucellosis in Italy.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe the epidemiological trends and spatial distribution of human brucellosis in Italy over 13 years (1998-2010). In the study period 8483 cases were notified in Italy, with a relevant decrease (-89%) from 1998 to 2010. Most cases were notified in southern Italy (Campania, Apulia, Calabria, Sicily). In these regions we observed relevant differences in the risk of brucellosis at province level. Cases were distributed with a seasonal pattern, male patients represented 60% of the cases and no significant differences were observed between age groups. We modelled the underreporting rate that ranged between 2 and 21 (average 12·5). According to our estimates the true number of cases would have ranged from 41 821 to 155 324 providing a far more severe picture of human brucellosis in Italy than the one provided by the surveillance system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mancini2013trends,
  author = {Francesca Romana Mancini and Antonino Bella and Caterina Graziani and Cinzia Marianelli and Lapo Mughini‐Gras and Paolo Pasquali and Maria Grazia Pompa and Caterina Rizzo and E Rizzuto and Luca Busani},
  title = {{Trends of human brucellosis in Italy, 1998–2010}},
  booktitle = {Epidemiology},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1017/s0950268813002227},
}
Figure