Abstract
Factors that affect tree species suitability assessment especially for embankment shelter forest are very complex. And the information for assessment always has incompleteness, multiplicity and uncertainty. To solve the complexity and difficulty of shelter forest vegetation species selection effectively, a tree species suitability assessment model for shelter forest planning based on principle of maximum entropy (POME) using the tree species suitability multi-index system is proposed. And through the proposed model, the tree species can be classified into 4 grades: most suitable, suitable, general and unsuitable. The case study in Baidajie Dike shows that the proposed model is capable of recommending the most suitable tree species for shelter forest and could also provide useful references for the vegetation species selection in landscape planning and design.
Introduction
The establishment of shelter forests along river embankments is a vital component of flood control and ecological preservation. These forests serve as biological barriers that mitigate wave energy, prevent soil erosion, and stabilize dike structures. However, the process of selecting the most appropriate tree species is fraught with complexity. Environmental variables are often inconsistent, and the data available to planners is frequently incomplete or "fuzzy."
Historically, species selection has relied on two primary methods: qualitative expert assessments, which are prone to subjectivity, and long-term quantitative planting trials, which are often prohibitively expensive and slow. This paper presents a novel assessment model based on the Principle of Maximum Entropy (POME) to provide a rigorous, objective framework for species selection in shelter forest planning.
Methodology
The proposed model integrates a multi-index evaluation system with advanced weighting techniques to handle the inherent uncertainties of ecological data.
Multi-Index Evaluation System
The researchers identified 11 key indicators categorized into three subsystems:
- Wave Dissipation: Root length, trunk diameter, crown diameter, and branch flexibility.
- Growth Habit: Flood survival rate, growth speed, disease resistance, cold endurance, and soil fertility requirements.
- Value: Landscape aesthetics and economic value.
Weighting and Optimization
To ensure a balanced perspective, the model employs a combination weighting strategy. It utilizes the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to capture subjective expert priorities and the Entropy Method (EM) to extract objective weights from the data itself.
The core of the model is the Principle of Maximum Entropy (POME). In information theory, POME is used to find the most "unbiased" probability distribution that satisfies given constraints. In this context, the model seeks to determine the membership degree of each species by minimizing the distance to an "ideal" suitability standard while maximizing Shannon entropy. This approach ensures that the model does not assume more certainty than the data justifies.
Case Study: Baidajie Dike
The model's efficacy was tested at the Baidajie Dike in Tailai County, Heilongjiang Province. Nine common tree species were evaluated against the 11 indicators. The model distinguishes between "benefit-type" indicators (e.g., flood survival) and "cost-type" indicators (e.g., soil fertility needs), allowing for a nuanced mathematical treatment of diverse biological traits.
Results and Discussion
The POME model categorized the nine species into four suitability grades:
- Most Suitable: Willow (T1), Pterocarya stenoptera (T2), and Poplar (T3). Willow, in particular, demonstrated a high suitability index of 0.943, making it the premier choice for this specific environment.
- Suitable: Metasequoia and Taxodium distichum were among the species classified as suitable, indicating strong overall performance.
- General: Taxodium ascendens was ranked in this lower tier, primarily due to its lower scores in growth habit and wave dissipation for the Heilongjiang region.
- Unsuitable: Species failing to meet the minimum thresholds for the local environment.
The results demonstrate that the POME model effectively reduces the "forced" certainty often found in traditional fuzzy logic models, providing a more honest and data-driven recommendation for landscape planners.
Conclusion
The Principle of Maximum Entropy offers a robust mathematical foundation for tree species suitability assessment. By accounting for data uncertainty and balancing engineering requirements with economic and aesthetic values, the model provides a reliable tool for embankment shelter forest planning. Future research may focus on tuning the model's sensitivity parameters and incorporating dynamic factors such as long-term climate change projections to further refine species recommendations.
Summary updated