Treatment effect estimation with confounder balanced instrumental variable regression

Anpeng Wu, Kun Kuang, Fei WuOpenReview 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Confounder Balanced IV Regression (CB-IV), a novel algorithm that tackles the challenge of estimating treatment effects from observational data when unmeasured confounders are present. CB-IV uniquely combines instrumental variable (IV) regression with confounder balancing techniques to simultaneously address biases from both unmeasured and observed confounders, offering improved accuracy and relaxing restrictive assumptions of prior methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating the causal effect of a treatment on an outcome using observational data is notoriously difficult due to confounding. Confounders are variables that influence both the treatment assignment and the outcome, creating spurious correlations that can lead to biased estimates. While instrumental variables (IVs) offer a way to address unmeasured confounders by providing an exogenous source of variation for the treatment, traditional IV methods (like 2SLS) often rely on strong assumptions, such as linearity and additive noise, which limit their applicability. More recent nonlinear IV methods can handle complex relationships but often suffer from bias introduced by observed confounders in their second stage. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that effectively handles both unmeasured and observed confounders in a unified framework.

Methods

The proposed Confounder Balanced IV Regression (CB-IV) algorithm operates in three main stages:

  1. Treatment Regression: This stage uses instrumental variables (Z) and observed confounders (X) to model the conditional probability distribution of the treatment (T). This is similar to existing nonlinear IV methods and aims to remove the influence of unmeasured confounders.
  2. Confounder Balancing: This is the core innovation. CB-IV learns a "balanced" representation of the observed confounders (C = f(X)) that is independent of the predicted treatment. This step specifically targets and removes the bias introduced by observed confounders, which often plagues previous nonlinear IV approaches. The paper utilizes Wasserstein distance for this balancing task.
  3. Outcome Regression: Finally, the algorithm regresses the outcome (Y) on the predicted treatment (from stage 1) and the balanced confounder representation (from stage 2). This joint modeling allows for a more accurate estimation of the treatment effect.

A key theoretical contribution is demonstrating that CB-IV can handle multiplicative assumptions for noise, relaxing the strict additive separability required by many prior methods.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their method on:

  • Synthetic Datasets: Generated datasets (Syn-mz-mx-mu) with varying numbers of instruments, observed, and unobserved confounders. These datasets are designed to mimic real-world scenarios and test the algorithm's robustness under different confounding structures.
  • Real-World Datasets:
    • IHDP (Infant Health and Development Program): Used to evaluate the effect of a specialist home visit on cognitive test scores.
  • Twins: Used to estimate the effect of birth weight in twins on infant mortality.

The paper also mentions experiments on a "Demand" dataset, which is a standard benchmark for continuous treatment evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dual Threat of Confounders: The paper highlights that both unmeasured and observed confounders pose significant challenges for treatment effect estimation, and existing methods often struggle to address both simultaneously.
  • Confounder Balancing as a Regularizer: By learning a representation of observed confounders that is independent of the treatment, CB-IV acts as a powerful regularizer in the outcome regression stage, preventing overfitting and reducing bias.
  • Relaxing Strict Assumptions: The ability of CB-IV to handle multiplicative noise assumptions is a significant theoretical advancement, making it applicable to a broader range of real-world causal models.
  • Synergy of IV and Balancing: The combination of IVs (for unmeasured confounders) and confounder balancing (for observed confounders) is shown to be more effective than either approach in isolation.

Key Results

  • Superior Performance: CB-IV consistently outperformed state-of-the-art IV regression and confounder balancing methods across various synthetic and real-world datasets in terms of bias in Average Treatment Effect (ATE) estimation.
  • Robustness to High-Dimensional Confounders: While some methods struggled with high-dimensional observed confounders, CB-IV maintained strong performance.
  • Effectiveness with Unmeasured Confounders: CB-IV showed significant improvements over traditional IV methods when unmeasured confounders were present.
  • Data Requirements: The paper notes that CB-IV, as a data-driven representation learning method, benefits from larger datasets to reduce variance in its estimates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Size Sensitivity: The authors acknowledge that CB-IV can exhibit high variance with small datasets, suggesting the need for more data for reliable estimation. They propose averaging over multiple runs as a practical solution.
  • Statistical Inference: The paper focuses on point estimation of treatment effects and does not delve into statistical inference (e.g., confidence intervals). The authors suggest this as a challenging but important direction for future research.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: The performance of CB-IV is influenced by hyperparameters like the trade-off parameter 'a' for the balancing loss, which requires careful tuning.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers the challenge of estimating treatment effects from observational data in the presence of unmeasured confounders. A popular way to address this challenge is to utilize an instrumental variable (IV) for two-stage regression, i.e., 2SLS and variants, but they need to assume the additive separability of noise and are limited to the linear setting. Recently, many nonlinear IV regression variants were proposed by regressing the treatment with IVs and confounders in the first stage, leading to confounding bias between the predicted treatment and outcome in the second stage. In this paper, we propose a Confounder Balanced IV Regression (CB-IV) algorithm to jointly remove the bias from the unmeasured confounders with IV regression and reduce the bias from the observed confounders by balancing for treatment effect estimation. Specifically, CB-IV algorithm consists of three main modules: (1) treatment regression: regressing the treatment with IVs and confounders like previous nonlinear IV methods for removing the confounding from unmeasured confounders; (2) confounder balancing: learning a balanced representation of confounders to eliminate the bias induced by the observed confounders (3) outcome regression: regressing the outcome with the predicted treatment and the balanced confounders representation for treatment effect estimation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to combine confounder balancing in IV regression for treatment effect estimation. Moreover, we theoretically prove that CB-IV algorithm is also effective even without the additive separability assumption on noise. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the CB-IV algorithm outperforms the state-of-the-art methods, including IV regression and confounder balancing methods, for treatment effect estimation.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2021treatment,
  author = {Anpeng Wu and Kun Kuang and Fei Wu},
  title = {{Treatment effect estimation with confounder balanced instrumental variable regression}},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=zxm7rzEPaj},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}
Figure