Treatment and Effective Removal of Metal Fine Particles from Waste Cutting Fluids by Flotation via Microbubbles and Skimming

Kimio Fukami, Namiko Ogata, Kenji Yamamoto, Kazuki Kawamura, I Mitani, Masaoki SakamotoWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a cost-effective and eco-friendly method for treating spent cutting fluids (CFs) by using microbubbles (MiBs) and skimming. The technique effectively removes metal fine particles (MFPs), doubles the lifespan of CFs, and significantly reduces treatment costs and waste.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metal-machining processes rely heavily on cutting fluids (CFs) for lubrication and cooling. However, these fluids become contaminated with toxic organic compounds and, crucially, metal fine particles (MFPs) generated during machining. These MFPs, particularly iron fine particles (IFPs) around 1 µm in size, degrade the quality and precision of machined products. Furthermore, spent CFs pose environmental risks if not properly treated. The industry faces a need for cost-effective and environmentally sound methods to remove these MFPs and manage waste CFs, as traditional disposal methods are expensive and can lead to pollution.

Methods

The study investigates the use of microbubbles (MiBs) for treating spent cutting fluids. MiBs, defined as bubbles with diameters of 1–100 µm, possess a large surface-to-volume ratio, enabling them to adsorb dissolved organic matter and fine particles. The core methodology involves:

  • Microbubble Generation: A gas-liquid shear system (Bubble Fresher BF152) was used to generate air microbubbles with an average diameter of 50 µm. These were continuously supplied to the cutting fluid.
  • Flotation and Skimming: The MiBs are introduced into the spent CFs. It's hypothesized that MFPs adsorb onto the surface of these MiBs, causing them to float to the surface. A skimming apparatus is then used to remove the accumulated particles and contaminants from the surface.
  • Particle Size Analysis: Preliminary experiments used GF/F filters (>0.7 µm) and GF/C filters (>1.2 µm) to demonstrate that a significant portion of the retained IFPs were smaller than 0.7 µm, confirming the presence of very fine particles.
  • Chemical Analysis: Concentrations of iron fine particles (IFPs) were measured using a spectrophotometric method (1,10-phenanthroline method). Organic carbon and nitrogen concentrations were determined using an NCH elemental analyzer.
  • Odor Monitoring: A gas detection apparatus was used to monitor odor levels near the CF containers.
  • pH Measurement: pH test papers were used to determine the pH of the cutting fluids.

Datasets

The study utilized two types of in-use cutting fluids (CFs) collected from two different cutting machines over a period of several months.

  • Emulsion-type cutting fluid (E-CF): Collected from a Yamazaki Giken YZ-500 SG machine, used for cutting various steels. Total volume approximately 200 L.
  • Soluble-type cutting fluid (S-CF): Collected from an OKK Corporation MCH 630 machine, also used for cutting various steels. Total volume approximately 600-700 L.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing real-world spent cutting fluids.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Invisible" Threat: The study highlights that spent cutting fluids contain a significant amount of very fine metal particles (~1 µm) that are not effectively captured by standard filtration methods. These particles are detrimental to machining precision.
  • MiBs as Particle Magnets: Microbubbles are not just for aeration; their unique surface properties allow them to effectively adsorb and aggregate these fine metal particles, bringing them to the surface for easy removal.
  • Doubling Lifespan, Halving Waste: The MiB treatment, combined with skimming, not only removes problematic particles but also appears to double the useful lifespan of the cutting fluids, leading to a substantial reduction in waste generation.
  • Odor Control Power: Beyond particle removal, MiB bubbling significantly suppresses the odor associated with spent cutting fluids, improving the working environment.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The proposed method offers a tangible economic advantage, being approximately 12% cheaper than traditional treatment methods over a two-year period.

Key Results

  • MFP Removal: Microbubble bubbling and skimming significantly reduced the concentration of iron fine particles (IFPs) in both E-CF and S-CF.
  • CF Lifespan Extension: The lifetime of the cutting fluids was observed to double with the MiB treatment.
  • Odor Reduction: Odor levels were reduced from over 1000 relative units to below 200 relative units (below the odor detection threshold).
  • Cost Savings: The MiB treatment was estimated to be 12% cheaper than conventional treatment methods over a two-year period.
  • Waste Reduction: The amount of harmful CF waste was reduced by approximately 50%.
  • Organic Matter: While MiB bubbling did not significantly decrease the concentration of organic carbon and nitrogen during the machining process, it effectively suppressed their accumulation and associated odor problems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Organic Matter Composition: The study acknowledges that the chemical composition of the organic matter in the waste CFs was not determined. Future work should investigate the specific chemicals that contribute to odor problems and how MiBs affect their composition.
  • Mechanism of Organic Matter Suppression: While odor was suppressed, the exact mechanism by which MiBs prevent the accumulation of organic matter needs further investigation.
  • Scalability and Long-Term Effects: While the study demonstrates effectiveness on a laboratory/pilot scale, further research on the scalability of this process for industrial applications and its long-term effects on different types of cutting fluids would be beneficial.
  • Specific MFP Characterization: While IFPs were focused on, a more comprehensive characterization of all MFPs present in spent CFs would provide a more complete understanding of the removal process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cutting fluids (CFs) are chemical liquids or aqueous emulsions of mineral (or synthetic) oil widely used in metal-machining processes. They contain toxic organic compounds and petroleum products, and spent CFs contain numerous small metal particles derived from the processing of metal workpieces. The iron fine particles (IFPs) in CFs can diminish the quality and precision of machine products. Machining industries purchase large amounts of CFs, which they must treat appropriately and from which they must remove the IFPs; therefore, cost-effective ways to treat spent CFs are needed. In this study, we evaluated the effectiveness of collecting and separating the IFPs and treating organic matter in spent CFs using microbubbles (MiBs). We found that numerous IFPs with sizes of ~1 μm were suspended in spent CFs and that they could be very effectively removed by bubbling with MiBs and skimming the surface of the CFs. The lifetime of the CFs could be doubled via this treatment. The cost for treating spent CFs using MiBs was 12% lower than the cost of traditional treatment. These results strongly suggest that bubbling with MiBs is a cost-effective and eco-friendly way to treat spent CFs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fukami2022treatment,
  author = {Kimio Fukami and Namiko Ogata and Kenji Yamamoto and Kazuki Kawamura and I Mitani and Masaoki Sakamoto},
  title = {{Treatment and Effective Removal of Metal Fine Particles from Waste Cutting Fluids by Flotation via Microbubbles and Skimming}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14162575},
}
Figure