Transport of Silica Colloid through Saturated Porous Media under Different Hydrogeochemical and Hydrodynamic Conditions Considering Managed Aquifer Recharge

Zhuo Wang, Wenjing Zhang, Shuo Li, Jingjing Zhou, Dan LiuWater 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how silica colloids move through saturated porous media under various conditions relevant to managed aquifer recharge (MAR). They found that pH, ionic strength, and flow rate significantly influence colloid deposition and transport, with implications for contaminant migration and aquifer health. The findings highlight the importance of carefully managing recharge water chemistry and flow to prevent undesirable colloid accumulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) is a crucial technique for managing water resources, but injecting recharge water can alter the natural hydrogeochemical and hydrodynamic conditions of groundwater. These changes can significantly impact the behavior of naturally occurring colloids, which play a role in transporting contaminants like heavy metals, bacteria, and viruses. While the importance of colloids is recognized, there's a lack of systematic understanding of how silica colloids, a common inorganic colloid, behave under the dynamic and variable conditions encountered during MAR. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by systematically studying silica colloid transport and deposition under controlled conditions simulating MAR.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of laboratory experiments and numerical simulations.

  • Laboratory Experiments:
    • Column Studies: They used columns packed with glass beads (mimicking porous media) and passed silica colloid suspensions through them.
  • Controlled Variables: Experiments were designed to isolate the effects of:
  • pH: Tested at 5, 7, and 9.
  • Ionic Strength (IS): Tested at <0.0005 M, 0.02 M, and 0.05 M, using both NaCl (monovalent cation) and CaCl₂ (bivalent cation).
  • Flow Rate: Tested at 0.1, 0.2, and 0.4 mL/min.
  • Monitoring: An online UV spectrophotometer was used to continuously monitor colloid concentration in the effluent.
  • Stages: Experiments involved two stages: Stage I for colloid injection and breakthrough curve observation, and Stage II for leaching with deionized water to observe colloid release.
  • Characterization: Particle size and zeta potential of silica colloids were measured using a zetasizer under different conditions.
  • Numerical Simulation:
    • COMSOL Multiphysics: This software was used to simulate colloid migration in porous media.
  • Model: The simulation incorporated convection-diffusion equations, accounting for colloid deposition, ripening, and blocking.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized synthesized silica colloids and prepared experimental conditions rather than relying on pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • pH Matters: Lower pH (acidic conditions) leads to greater silica colloid deposition. This is counterintuitive to some expectations and suggests that acidic recharge water might increase the risk of colloidal pollution by promoting deposition.
  • Ionic Strength is a Double-Edged Sword: Increasing ionic strength generally leads to more colloid deposition, reducing their migration. However, the type of cation is crucial.
  • Bivalent Cations are Potent: Calcium ions (Ca²⁺) have a much stronger effect on colloid deposition and reduced migration than sodium ions (Na⁺) at the same ionic strength. This is likely due to stronger electrostatic interactions and potential bridging effects.
  • Flow Rate Enhances Migration: Higher flow rates increase the migration ability of silica colloids. This is attributed to a better balance of forces between colloids and the porous medium, reduced contact time, and potentially increased shear forces leading to desorption.
  • Straining is a Factor: Under certain conditions (specifically with high ionic strength and bivalent cations like Ca²⁺), the silica colloid particles can become large enough to get physically trapped (strained) in the pore spaces, further hindering their movement.
  • MAR Water Quality is Critical: The study underscores that the chemical composition (pH, ionic strength, cation type) and flow rate of recharge water during MAR can significantly alter colloid behavior, impacting aquifer porosity and contaminant transport.

Key Results

  • pH: As pH increased from 5 to 9, the peak breakthrough curve value increased from 93% to 97%, indicating less deposition at higher pH. Deposition rate coefficients decreased with increasing pH.
  • Ionic Strength (NaCl): Increasing IS from <0.0005 M to 0.05 M decreased the peak breakthrough curve value from 0.95 to 0.85, signifying increased adsorption. Deposition rate coefficients increased significantly with IS.
  • Ionic Strength (CaCl₂): Similar to NaCl, increasing IS with CaCl₂ also reduced migration, with the peak breakthrough curve decreasing from 0.95 to 0.82 at 0.05 M. Bivalent cations showed a greater impact than monovalent ones.
  • Flow Rate: As flow rate increased from 0.1 to 0.4 mL/min, the peak breakthrough curve increased from 85% to 98%. Deposition coefficients decreased significantly with increasing flow rate.
  • Simulation: The COMSOL simulations generally matched the experimental data, validating the model's ability to predict colloid transport under these conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Conditions: The study used glass beads as the porous medium and synthesized silica colloids. Future work could investigate these phenomena in more complex, heterogeneous natural porous media with a wider range of natural colloid types.
  • Single Colloid Type: The study focused on silica colloids. Future research could explore the transport of mixed colloid populations (e.g., organic and inorganic colloids) and their interactions.
  • Limited Contaminant Interaction: While the paper mentions the role of colloids in contaminant transport, it did not directly study the co-transport of contaminants with silica colloids. This is a crucial area for future investigation.
  • Long-Term Effects: The experiments focused on short-term breakthrough and leaching. Long-term MAR scenarios might involve more complex processes like ripening and blocking, which warrant further study.
  • Recommendations for MAR: The authors recommend maintaining a pH around 7 and a flow rate close to or slightly greater than the natural groundwater flow rate during MAR to protect the groundwater environment. They also suggest careful consideration of bivalent cation concentrations in recharge water.

Summary updated

Abstract

Colloids may have an important role in regulating the structure and function of groundwater ecosystems, and may influence the migration of low solubility contaminants in groundwater. There is, however, a degree of uncertainty about how colloids behave under the variable hydrogeochemical and hydrodynamic conditions that occur during managed aquifer recharge. We used an online monitoring system to monitor the transport of silica colloid in saturated porous media under different hydrogeochemical conditions, including a range of pH values (5, 7, and 9), ionic strengths (&lt;0.0005, 0.02, and 0.05 M), cation valences (Na+, Ca2+), flow rates (0.1, 0.2, and 0.4 mL/min). The results showed that silica colloid was more likely to deposit on the surface of porous media in acidic conditions (pH = 5) than in alkaline conditions (pH = 9), indicating that the risks of pollution from colloidal interactions would be higher when the pH of the recharge water was higher. Colloid deposition occurred when the ionic strength of the colloidal suspension increased, and bivalent cations had a greater effect than monovalent cations. This suggests that bivalent cation-rich recharge water might affect the porosity of the porous medium because of colloid deposition during the managed aquifer recharge process. As the flow rate increased, the migration ability of silica colloid increased. We simulated the migration of silica colloid in porous media with the COMSOL Multiphysics model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2016transport,
  author = {Zhuo Wang and Wenjing Zhang and Shuo Li and Jingjing Zhou and Dan Liu},
  title = {{Transport of Silica Colloid through Saturated Porous Media under Different Hydrogeochemical and Hydrodynamic Conditions Considering Managed Aquifer Recharge}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/w8120555},
}
Figure