Transport moments beyond the leading order

Gregory Berkolaiko, Jack KuipersNew 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a powerful semiclassical diagrammatic technique to calculate higher-order transport properties in chaotic cavities, going beyond the leading-order approximations. The authors derive generating functions for various quantities, including transmission, reflection, Wigner delay times, and the density of states in Andreev billiards, providing insights into the robustness of phenomena like the hard gap.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding electron transport in mesoscopic systems, particularly chaotic cavities, is crucial for developing novel electronic devices. While Random Matrix Theory (RMT) offers powerful statistical descriptions, a semiclassical approach, which connects transport to classical trajectories, provides a more intuitive and detailed picture. However, existing semiclassical methods have been limited to calculating only the leading-order contributions (in terms of inverse channel number, 1/N) for many transport quantities. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a systematic semiclassical framework to calculate transport moments beyond the leading order, up to the third subleading order, for systems with and without time-reversal symmetry. This allows for a more accurate and comprehensive understanding of phenomena like conductance, shot noise, and the density of states.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a semiclassical diagrammatic technique. This approach approximates the scattering matrix elements by sums over classical trajectories. The key innovation is the development of a diagrammatic expansion where these trajectories are represented as "ribbon graphs." The authors introduce a method of grafting "subtrees" onto "base diagrams" to systematically generate diagrams contributing to higher orders in the inverse channel number (1/N).

  • Tree Recursions: The paper utilizes recursive relations for generating functions of these subtrees, which are then combined to form the generating functions for the transport quantities.
  • Base Structures: For higher orders, the diagrams are decomposed into "base structures" (graphs with a low number of cycles) onto which subtrees are appended.
  • Symmetry Considerations: The authors carefully account for the symmetries of these diagrams, particularly for systems with time-reversal symmetry, which leads to a richer set of contributing diagrams.
  • Moment Generating Functions: The primary output of the technique is the derivation of moment generating functions, which allow for the calculation of arbitrary moments of transport quantities.

This approach builds upon previous semiclassical work but extends it to systematically handle higher-order corrections, offering a more complete picture than purely RMT-based calculations for these specific orders.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and calculations based on established physical principles and mathematical frameworks, rather than empirical data or simulations on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Systematic Approach to Higher Orders: The paper provides a unified and systematic way to calculate transport properties beyond the leading order, which was a significant limitation of previous semiclassical methods.
  • Robustness of the Hard Gap: For Andreev billiards, the authors find that the "hard gap" in the density of states, observed at leading order, persists even when subleading corrections are included, suggesting its fundamental nature.
  • Simplicity of Generating Functions: Despite the complexity of the underlying diagrams, the resulting generating functions for various transport quantities are surprisingly simple, offering a powerful tool for further analysis.
  • Connection to RMT: The derived semiclassical results are shown to agree with RMT predictions, validating both approaches and suggesting that the semiclassical method can simplify the interpretation of RMT results, particularly in asymptotic expansions.
  • Diagrammatic Interpretation of Transport: The work provides a deeper combinatorial understanding of transport phenomena by mapping them onto specific types of graphs and their recursive generation.

Key Results

The paper successfully derives generating functions for the $n$-th moment of various transport quantities, including:

  • Transmission and Reflection Eigenvalues: For systems with and without time-reversal symmetry, up to the third subleading order in 1/N.
  • Wigner Delay Times: Moments of the Wigner delay times are also calculated.
  • Density of States of Andreev Billiards: The authors show that the hard gap persists for the next two orders, and the corrections are negative with a singular peak.
  • Cross-Correlation of Transport Moments: The technique is extended to calculate non-linear statistics, specifically the cross-correlation between transport moments.

The authors provide explicit formulas for these generating functions and demonstrate their agreement with existing RMT results for low orders. For instance, they derive expressions for the first and second subleading corrections to the density of states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the method is systematic, the number of diagrams grows rapidly with the order of the expansion, posing a computational challenge for very high orders. The paper notes that for the next contributing order in the unitary case, there are 1848 base diagrams.
  • Focus on Perfectly Coupled Leads: The derivations are for perfectly coupled leads. The authors acknowledge that the more experimentally relevant case of non-ideal coupling (with tunnel barriers) would introduce new diagrams and require modifications to the current framework.
  • Ehrenfest Time: The paper suggests that the effect of the Ehrenfest time could potentially be incorporated into the graphical recursions, which would be an interesting avenue for future research.
  • Higher-Order Non-Linear Statistics: Extending the analysis to non-linear statistics involving more than two traces (e.g., three traces) would require treating base structures with more cycles, presenting a significant challenge.
  • Arbitrary Channel Number RMT: The authors highlight the need for RMT results for arbitrary channel numbers to fully complement their semiclassical findings and clarify phenomena like the persistence of the gap.

Summary updated

Abstract

For chaotic cavities with scattering leads attached, transport properties can be approximated in terms of the classical trajectories which enter and exit the system. With a semiclassical treatment involving fine correlations between such trajectories we develop a diagrammatic technique to calculate the moments of various transport quantities. Namely, we find the moments of the transmission and reflection eigenvalues for systems with and without time reversal symmetry. We also derive related quantities involving an energy dependence: the moments of the Wigner delay times and the density of states of chaotic Andreev billiards, where we find that the gap in the density persists when subleading corrections are included. Finally, we show how to adapt our techniques to non-linear statistics by calculating the correlation between transport moments. In each setting, the answer for the $n$-th moment is obtained for arbitrary $n$ (in the form of a moment generating function) and for up to the three leading orders in terms of the inverse channel number. Our results suggest patterns which should hold for further corrections and by matching with the low order moments available from random matrix theory we derive likely higher order generating functions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berkolaiko2011transport,
  author = {Gregory Berkolaiko and Jack Kuipers},
  title = {{Transport moments beyond the leading order}},
  booktitle = {New},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1088/1367-2630/13/6/063020},
}
Figure