Transport analysis and source attribution of seasonal and interannual variability of CO in the tropical upper troposphere and lower stratosphere

Jun S. Liu, Jennifer A. Logan, Lee T. Murray, H. C. Pumphrey, M. Schwartz, I. A. MegretskaiaAtmospheric 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses the GEOS-Chem model and satellite observations (MLS) to analyze the seasonal and interannual variability of carbon monoxide (CO) in the tropical upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. The research highlights how biomass burning and atmospheric transport drive CO patterns, revealing discrepancies in model simulations of vertical transport, particularly in the GEOS-5 model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the distribution of trace gases like carbon monoxide (CO) in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere (UTLS) is crucial for atmospheric chemistry and climate studies. CO is a key indicator of pollution and plays a role in ozone formation. The UTLS is a region where air from the troposphere enters the stratosphere, and its composition is influenced by both surface emissions (like biomass burning) and complex atmospheric dynamics, including deep convection and the Brewer-Dobson circulation. Previous studies have observed a "tape recorder" phenomenon in CO, where seasonal signals are preserved as air ascends into the stratosphere. However, accurately simulating these CO patterns and attributing them to specific sources and transport mechanisms has been challenging. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using a sophisticated chemistry-transport model (GEOS-Chem) driven by different meteorological reanalysis datasets (GEOS-4 and GEOS-5) and comparing its output to satellite observations from the Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS) to better understand the drivers of CO variability in this critical atmospheric layer.

Methods

The researchers employed the GEOS-Chem global 3-D chemistry-transport model. To investigate the impact of different atmospheric dynamics, they ran simulations driven by two distinct meteorological reanalysis datasets: GEOS-4 and GEOS-5. To pinpoint the origins of CO, they utilized "tagged CO" simulations, which track CO from specific sources (e.g., biomass burning from different continents, fossil fuel combustion, isoprene oxidation). They also derived vertical velocities by analyzing the phase lag of CO extrema in the MLS satellite data, providing an independent observational constraint on atmospheric transport. This derived vertical velocity was then used to evaluate the transport simulated by the GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 meteorological fields.

Datasets

  • Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS) data: This satellite instrument provided multi-year measurements of CO mixing ratios in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. The study specifically used MLS Version 3.3 data.
  • GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 assimilated meteorological fields: These datasets, derived from data assimilation systems, provided the atmospheric dynamics (winds, convection, etc.) that drove the GEOS-Chem model simulations.
  • Global Fire Emissions Database (GFED2 and GFED3): These datasets provided estimates of biomass burning emissions, used as a key CO source in the model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Tape Recorder" is Driven by a Symphony of Sources and Transport: The study confirms that the seasonal CO patterns observed in the UTLS are not solely due to one factor. Instead, they arise from the interplay of biomass burning from different continents and the seasonal shifts in deep convection, which act as the "tape head" for the stratospheric tape recorder.
  • Northern Hemisphere Fires Ascend Faster: A key finding is that CO from Northern Hemisphere biomass burning is transported to the lower stratosphere more quickly than CO from the Southern Hemisphere. This difference contributes to the transition from a semi-annual CO cycle in the upper troposphere to an annual cycle in the lower stratosphere.
  • Model Transport Deficiencies Revealed: The research highlights significant differences in how the GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 models simulate vertical transport. GEOS-5, in particular, appears to have inadequate upward transport, especially during spring and summer, leading to an underestimation of CO at higher altitudes compared to MLS observations.
  • Droughts Amplify CO Peaks: The study links exceptionally high CO peaks in the tape recorder signal to severe droughts, particularly those in Indonesia and South America, underscoring the climate-driven nature of major emission events.

Key Results

  • Both GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 models capture many of the observed seasonal and interannual CO patterns in the UTLS, including the transition from semi-annual to annual cycles.
  • The models generally show a semi-annual cycle in CO around 200 hPa and a strong annual cycle above 68 hPa, consistent with MLS data.
  • GEOS-4 vertical velocities are found to be more consistent with MLS-derived velocities between 215 hPa and 125 hPa than GEOS-5.
  • GEOS-5 exhibits lower vertical velocities than GEOS-4, particularly in spring and summer, leading to less effective transport of CO from the Southern Hemisphere.
  • The models underestimate CO maxima from Southern Hemisphere biomass burning above 147 hPa, with the signal nearly disappearing by 100 hPa in GEOS-5.
  • The strongest interannual CO peaks in the tape recorder were observed in late 2004, 2006, and 2010, linked to major fires in Indonesia and South America, often associated with droughts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the GEOS-Chem model captures many features, there are still discrepancies, particularly in the simulation of vertical transport. The GEOS-5 model, for instance, shows downward motion in the tropics during boreal summer, which contradicts established understanding of tropical upward transport. The study suggests that the CO tape recorder is a valuable tool for testing vertical transport in models, especially in the UTLS, and recommends its implementation in various model configurations. Future work could focus on refining the representation of convective transport in models and further investigating the role of inter-hemispheric transport. The authors also note that while GFED3 emissions showed some improvements, they did not fully resolve all model biases, suggesting that transport is a significant factor.

Summary updated

Abstract

We used the GEOS-Chem chemistry-transport model to investigate impacts of surface emissions and dynamical processes on the spatial and temporal patterns of CO observed by the Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS) in the upper troposphere (UT) and lower stratosphere (LS). Model simulations driven by GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 assimilated fields present many features of the seasonal and inter-annual variation of CO in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. Both model simulations and the MLS data show a transition from semi-annual variations in the UT to annual variations in the LS. Tagged CO simulations indicate that the semi-annual variation of CO in the UT is determined mainly by the temporal overlapping of surface biomass burning from different continents as well as the north-south shifts of deep convection. Both GEOS-4 and GEOS-5 have maximum upward transport in April and May with a minimum in July to September. The CO peaks from the Northern Hemisphere (NH) fires propagate faster to the LS than do those from the Southern Hemisphere (SH) fires. Thus the transition from a semi-annual to an annual cycle around 80 hPa is induced by a combination of the CO signal at the tropopause and the annual cycle of the Brewer-Dobson circulation. In GEOS-5, the shift to an annual cycle occurs at a lower altitude than in MLS CO, a result of inadequate upward transport. We deduce vertical velocities from MLS CO, and use them to evaluate the velocities derived from the archived GEOS meteorological fields. We find that GEOS-4 velocities are similar to those from MLS CO between 215 hPa and 125 hPa, while the velocities in GEOS-5 are too low in spring and summer. The mean tropical vertical velocities from both models are lower than those inferred from MLS CO above 100 hPa, particularly in GEOS-5, with mean downward, rather than upward motion in boreal summer. Thus the models' CO maxima from SH burning are transported less effectively than those in MLS CO above 147 hPa and almost disappear by 100 hPa. The strongest peaks in the CO tape-recorder are in late 2004, 2006, and 2010, with the first two resulting from major fires in Indonesia and the last from severe burning in South America, all associated with intense droughts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2013transport,
  author = {Jun S. Liu and Jennifer A. Logan and Lee T. Murray and H. C. Pumphrey and M. Schwartz and I. A. Megretskaia},
  title = {{Transport analysis and source attribution of seasonal and interannual variability of CO in the tropical upper troposphere and lower stratosphere}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-13-129-2013},
}
Figure