Transpiling Quantum Circuits Using the Pentagon Equation

Christos Aravanis, Georgios Korpas, Jakub MarečekSSRN 2022

TL;DR

This paper explores how a mathematical identity called the "pentagon equation," originating from integrable systems theory, can be used to simplify quantum circuits. By finding specific solutions to this equation, the authors demonstrate a method to "transpile" circuits, effectively reducing their depth and complexity, particularly for circuits involving non-local interactions. This offers a novel approach to optimizing quantum computations for current and future quantum hardware.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantum computers, especially those in the current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, are limited by factors like coherence times, gate fidelities, and qubit connectivity. A key bottleneck is the "depth" of a quantum circuit, which is the number of sequential gate operations. Deep circuits are more susceptible to errors and harder to implement. Furthermore, many quantum algorithms require non-local interactions (interactions between qubits that are not physically adjacent). Implementing these non-local interactions often necessitates the use of expensive SWAP gates, which themselves can be composed of multiple basic gates, further increasing circuit depth and complexity. Circuit transpilation aims to address these issues by rewriting a given quantum circuit into an equivalent one that is more efficient or compatible with specific hardware. Existing transpilation techniques are often heuristic and multi-pass. This paper tackles the problem of circuit depth reduction, specifically for circuits involving non-local interactions, by leveraging a less commonly applied mathematical tool: the pentagon equation.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in applying the pentagon equation, a fundamental identity in integrable systems, to quantum circuit transpilation. The pentagon equation, when represented as a quantum circuit, involves a specific arrangement of "fusion operators" (solutions to the equation) and wire twists. The authors show that if a 2-qubit gate is a solution to the pentagon equation, it can act as a "fusion operator" that enables circuit compression.

Specifically, they:

  • Introduce the Pentagon Equation: Define the pentagon equation ($T_{23}T_{12} = T_{12}T_{13}T_{23}$) and its representation as a quantum circuit.
  • Connect to Fusion Operators: Explain that solutions to the pentagon equation are called "fusion operators" and can be related to algebraic structures like bialgebras.
  • Explore Duality: Demonstrate a "local/non-local duality." This means that circuits with non-local interactions can be transformed into equivalent circuits with local interactions, and vice-versa, by using fusion operators. This duality is key to compression.
  • Analyze Specific Gates: Investigate whether specific quantum gates, namely the "A gate" (a three-parameter gate designed for efficient non-local operations) and the evolution operator of the 1D Heisenberg model (for N=2 qubits), satisfy the pentagon equation under certain parameter constraints.
  • Develop Transpilation Strategy: Show how a circuit component involving a fusion operator and SWAP gates can be replaced by a simpler component using the same fusion operator, effectively reducing depth.

The paper contrasts the pentagon equation with the more widely known Yang-Baxter equation, highlighting their similarities and differences.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pentagon Equation as a Circuit Tool: The paper reveals that the pentagon equation, typically studied in abstract mathematics, has a direct and useful interpretation as a quantum circuit. This opens up new avenues for circuit manipulation.
  • Fusion Operators Enable Compression: The central insight is that specific gates satisfying the pentagon equation act as "fusion operators" that can facilitate circuit compression, particularly by replacing sequences of non-local gates and SWAPs with more efficient structures.
  • Local-Non-Local Duality for Optimization: The identified duality between local and non-local interactions, mediated by fusion operators, provides a powerful conceptual framework for circuit optimization. It suggests that complex non-local operations might be simplified or that local operations could be used to implement non-local ones, depending on the available tools and desired outcome.
  • A Gate and Heisenberg Model as Potential Fusion Operators: The analysis of the A gate and the 1D Heisenberg model shows that under specific parameter settings, they can indeed be solutions to the pentagon equation, making them candidates for fusion operators in practical transpilation.

Key Results

  • Circuit Compression Scheme: The paper presents a concrete method (Theorem 6) for transpiling a quantum circuit component involving a unitary gate $T$ and two SWAP gates into a simpler component with just the gate $T$, provided $T$ is a fusion operator satisfying the pentagon equation. This directly reduces circuit depth.
  • Conditions for A Gate and Heisenberg Model: The paper derives the specific conditions on the parameters of the A gate (Fig. 11) and the 1D Heisenberg model evolution operator (Fig. 10) for them to be solutions to the pentagon equation. For the A gate, this requires $c_1=c_2=0$ and $c_3 = -2\pi k$ for $k \in \mathbb{Z}$. For the Heisenberg model, it requires $\theta_x = \theta_y = 0$ and $\theta_z = -k\pi$ for $k \in \mathbb{Z}$.
  • Limited Usefulness of Found Solutions: While the A gate and Heisenberg model can be fusion operators under these specific conditions, the paper notes that these conditions lead to limited use cases, such as the triple eigenvalue of 1, which restricts their ability to act as perfect entanglers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Parameter Space: The paper acknowledges that the derived conditions for the A gate and Heisenberg model to be fusion operators are quite restrictive, leading to limited practical utility for these specific instances.
  • Finding More General Solutions: The authors express interest in finding more general solutions to the pentagon equation that could be more broadly applicable for circuit transpilation. They suggest exploring other integrable systems and algebraic structures like group rings (e.g., $C[U(4)]$) as potential sources for new fusion operators.
  • Hardware Implementation: While the paper discusses the theoretical benefits, the practical implementation of these fusion operators on current NISQ hardware, especially concerning the control of non-local interactions and avoiding cross-talk, remains a challenge. The authors mention that some architectures (like neutral atom systems) might offer more direct control over such interactions.
  • Broader Applicability: The paper focuses on the A gate and the 1D Heisenberg model. Future work could explore other quantum gates and Hamiltonians to see if they satisfy the pentagon equation and can be used for circuit compression.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the application of the pentagon equation in the context of quantum circuit compression. We show that if solutions to the pentagon equation are found, one can transpile a circuit involving non-Heisenberg-type interactions to a circuit involving only Heisenberg-type interactions while, in parallel, reducing the depth of a circuit. In this context, we consider a model of non-local two-qubit operations of Zhang \emph{et. al.} (the $A$ gate), and show that for certain parameters it is a solution of the pentagon equation.
BibTeX
@misc{aravanis2022transpiling,
  author = {Christos Aravanis and Georgios Korpas and Jakub Mareček},
  title = {{Transpiling Quantum Circuits Using the Pentagon Equation}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.14356},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.14356},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure