Transmission Benefits and Cost Allocation under Ambiguity

Han Shu, Jacob MaysarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper addresses the critical challenge of cost allocation in large-scale electricity transmission expansion. Using a two-stage stochastic optimization model, we demonstrate that traditional project-by-project cost allocation often fails to align with actual benefits under uncertainty. We propose a portfolio-based approach that includes both loads and existing generators as beneficiaries. Our findings highlight a significant divergence between ex ante estimated benefits and ex post realizations, suggesting the need for more robust allocation mechanisms and financial instruments to manage multi-decadal ambiguity.

Introduction

The transition to a decarbonized power grid requires massive investment in transmission infrastructure. However, in the United States, investment is stalled by "cost allocation" disputes. FERC Order 1000 mandates that costs be allocated "commensurate with benefits," but calculating these benefits in a complex, meshed grid over decades is fraught with difficulty. Stakeholders often face "ambiguity"—a state where the probabilities of future scenarios (e.g., fuel prices, demand growth) are contested, leading to disagreements over who should pay for new lines.

Methodology

We develop a two-stage stochastic expansion planning model formulated as a Mixed-Integer Program (MIP). Unlike traditional tools that analyze transmission in isolation, this model co-optimizes transmission (binary decisions) and generation (continuous decisions) expansion.

A key feature is the counterfactual approach: to measure a project's benefit, we compare the optimal system with the project to a baseline where the project is excluded but generation investments are allowed to "optimally readjust." This captures how the market naturally compensates for missing infrastructure. To handle multi-decadal uncertainty, the model utilizes a scenario tree to represent various realizations of load growth and technology costs.

Scenario tree representing multi-decadal uncertainty in transmission planning.

Experimental Setup

The model is tested on a stylized 8-Bus ERCOT (Texas) DC case. Data sources include the NREL Annual Technology Baseline (2022) for generation costs and ERCOT's 2023 Capacity, Demand and Reserves report. We condensed 243 possible realizations of uncertainty into seven representative scenarios to maintain computational tractability while capturing essential variability in load and weather profiles extracted via the Renewables.ninja platform.

Key Insights

  • Portfolio vs. Project-by-Project: Evaluating lines individually can lead to misleading results, as projects often depend on one another to be effective. Portfolio-level allocation better adheres to the "beneficiaries pay" principle and avoids charging stakeholders for projects that only provide value when combined with others.
  • Generator Inclusion: Existing generators in "export" regions often capture significant surplus from new transmission that allows them to reach more customers. Fairness dictates they should be part of the cost-sharing pool, whereas new generators often reach a "zero-profit" equilibrium where they do not capture long-term surplus.
  • Ex Ante vs. Ex Post Divergence: Realized benefits ten years post-construction rarely match initial estimates. This suggests a need for financial contracts to rebalance costs over time as benefits actually materialize, rather than relying solely on static upfront projections.

Results

In the ERCOT numerical study, the model selected six major transmission projects for the first stage (2023). The total expected portfolio benefit was $5.67 Billion. Notably, several individual projects showed negative net benefits when analyzed in isolation, yet were essential to the overall portfolio's success.

Distributional analysis showed that benefits shift significantly over time. For instance, in 2028, benefits were concentrated at Bus 1, but by 2038, they shifted toward Buses 2, 5, and 8 as the resource mix evolved. Furthermore, generators at specific buses captured nearly 70% of total benefits in some scenarios, despite being allocated a much smaller share of costs under traditional methods.

Conclusion

Effective transmission planning requires moving beyond project-by-project analysis toward portfolio-based assessments that account for generator surplus and long-term uncertainty. While this model provides a framework for fairer cost allocation, future work is needed to address the valuation of public policy goals like carbon reduction and the potential for strategic behavior among stakeholders in representing their beliefs about the future.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{shu2024transmission,
  author = {Han Shu and Jacob Mays},
  title = {{Transmission Benefits and Cost Allocation under Ambiguity}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.14803},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14803},
}
Figure