Transmissibility of hand, foot, and mouth disease in 97 counties of China.

Wei Zhang, Jia Rui, Xiaoqing Cheng, Bin Deng, Hesong Zhang, Lijing Huang, Lexin Zhang, Simiao Zuo, Junru Li, XingCheng Huang, Yanhua Su, Benhua Zhao, Yan D. Niu, Hongwei Li, Jianli Hu, Tianmu ChenResearch 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Hand, Foot, and Mouth Disease (HFMD) remains a significant public health challenge in the Asia-Pacific region, particularly affecting children under five. While provincial and national trends are well-documented, these broad perspectives often mask the "micro-epidemics" occurring at the county level. This study aims to bridge this gap by analyzing the transmissibility of HFMD across 97 counties in Jiangsu Province, China, from 2015 to 2020. By calculating the effective reproduction number ($R_{eff}$), researchers seek to provide local health authorities with the granular data necessary for targeted interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a seasonal Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Asymptomatic-Removed (SEIAR) model. This framework is particularly suited for HFMD as it accounts for both the incubation period (Exposed) and asymptomatic carriers, who play a critical role in the virus's spread.

Daily incidence data from the China Information System for Disease Control and Prevention and demographic data from the Statistical Yearbook of Jiangsu Province were used to fit the model. The infection rate coefficient ($\beta$) was estimated to calculate $R_{eff}$ using Berkeley Madonna software. To categorize the 97 counties, the study utilized Rank-sum ratio (RSR) analysis, Probit regression, and fast cluster analysis to group regions with similar transmission patterns.

Results

The study revealed a median $R_{eff}$ of 1.54 (quartile range: 0.49–2.50) for Jiangsu Province. The SEIAR model demonstrated strong performance, with a mean coefficient of determination ($R^2$) of 0.50 ± 0.15.

Key temporal trends included:

  • 2017 Nadir: $R_{eff}$ reached its lowest point in 2017 ($P < 0.05$), coinciding with the 2016 rollout of the Enterovirus 71 (EV71) vaccine.
  • 2018 Rebound: Transmissibility surged again in 2018. This is attributed to a "serotype shift," where non-EV71 strains like Coxsackievirus A16 (CA16) and CA6 became dominant.
  • 2020 Decline: HFMD incidence dropped to record lows in 2020, likely a secondary benefit of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) implemented to combat COVID-19, such as school closures and enhanced hygiene.

Regional analysis identified Rugao (Central Jiangsu) and Jianhu (Northern Jiangsu) as hotspots with the highest transmissibility. Interestingly, while Southern Jiangsu—the most developed region—had high incidence rates due to population density, the "speed" of transmission ($R_{eff}$) was often higher in rural Northern and Central areas.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings highlight the dynamic nature of HFMD transmission. The 2018 rebound underscores a critical limitation of current public health strategies: the EV71 vaccine, while effective against its target, does not protect against other emerging serotypes. There is an urgent need for the development and deployment of multivalent vaccines.

Furthermore, the success of COVID-19 NPIs in reducing HFMD transmission suggests that simple behavioral interventions remain highly effective. Future efforts should focus on integrating real-time meteorological data into transmission models to develop early-warning systems, allowing for even more precise, county-level public health responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Hand, foot, and mouth disease (HFMD) has been a serious disease burden in the Asia Pacific region represented by China, and the transmission characteristics of HFMD in regions haven’t been clear. This study calculated the transmissibility of HFMD at county levels in Jiangsu Province, China, analyzed the differences of transmissibility and explored the reasons. Methods We built susceptible-exposed-infectious-asymptomatic-removed (SEIAR) model for seasonal characteristics of HFMD, estimated effective reproduction number ( R eff ) by fitting the incidence of HFMD in 97 counties of Jiangsu Province from 2015 to 2020, compared incidence rate and transmissibility in different counties by non -parametric test, rapid cluster analysis and rank-sum ratio. Results The average daily incidence rate was between 0 and 4 per 100,000 in Jiangsu province from 2015–2020. The 97 counties could be divided into three levels: low incidence, medium incidence and high incidence, and occurred that the average daily incidence rate dropped sharply in 2016–2017, and increased sharply in 2017–2018 years. The Quartile of Reff in Jiangsu Province from 2015 to 2020 was 1.54 (0.49, 2.50), Rugao district in Central Jiangsu and Jianhu district in Northern Jiangsu had the highest transmissibility by rank-sum ratio. R eff generally decreased in 2017 and increased in 2018 in most counties, and the median level of R eff was lowest in 2017 ( P &lt; 0.05). Conclusion Transmissibility was different in 97 counties of Jiangsu Province, and the reasons for the differences may be related to the climate, demographic characteristics, virus subtypes, vaccination and other infectious diseases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2021transmissibility,
  author = {Wei Zhang and Jia Rui and Xiaoqing Cheng and Bin Deng and Hesong Zhang and Lijing Huang and Lexin Zhang and Simiao Zuo and Junru Li and XingCheng Huang and Yanhua Su and Benhua Zhao and Yan D. Niu and Hongwei Li and Jianli Hu and Tianmu Chen},
  title = {{Transmissibility of hand, foot, and mouth disease in 97 counties of China.}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-735005/v1},
}
Figure