Translucence perception is not dependent on cortical areas critical for processing colour or texture

Angus Chadwick, C.a. Heywood, Hannah E. Smithson, Robert W. KentridgeNeuropsychologia 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether the perception of translucence, a key material property, relies on the same brain regions as color and texture processing. By testing a patient with severe color blindness (achromatopsia) who also struggles with color and texture discrimination, the researchers found that he could still systematically perceive and rank differences in translucence. This suggests that specialized neural pathways for translucence perception exist independently of those for color and texture.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how we perceive material properties is crucial for object recognition and interaction with the world. While we know that different visual features like color, texture, and shape are processed in distinct brain areas, the neural basis for perceiving other important material properties, such as translucence, remains less clear. Translucence, the property of allowing light to pass through but scattering it, is vital for judging the ripeness of fruit, the freshness of meat, or the strength of a drink. Previous research has shown that patients with cortical damage can lose color and texture perception while retaining others, like glossiness. This paper aims to determine if translucence perception also dissociates from color and texture processing, implying a separate neural substrate.

Methods

The core of the study involved testing a patient known as "MS," who has extensive bilateral lesions in his ventromedial occipitotemporal cortex, resulting in complete cortical color blindness (achromatopsia) and deficits in color and texture discrimination.

  1. Color Vision Assessment: MS's persistent achromatopsia was confirmed using the Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue Test, a standard color vision assessment.
  2. Translucence Perception Tasks: MS was presented with photographs of real glasses of milky tea. These stimuli were manipulated in two ways:
  3. Tea Strength: Varying tea concentration (affecting light absorption).
  4. Milkiness: Varying milk concentration (affecting light scattering). MS was asked to rank sets of three stimuli based on either tea strength or milkiness.

  5. Control Groups:

    • Color Stimuli: A small group of normal observers (one age-matched, two non-matched) performed the same ranking tasks with the color stimuli.
  6. Greyscale Stimuli: Another group of three normal observers performed the tasks using greyscale versions of the tea stimuli to assess the role of color information.
  7. Image Statistics Analysis: To rule out that MS was relying on simple low-level visual cues (like brightness statistics) rather than genuine translucence perception, the researchers analyzed the images for metrics like hue, saturation, and value. They then simulated observer performance based on these statistics to see if they could predict MS's rankings.

Datasets

The study used photographs of real glasses of milky tea, created to vary systematically in tea strength (absorption) and milkiness (scattering). These stimuli were presented in both color and greyscale versions. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; existing stimuli were adapted for the specific experimental design.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dissociation of Translucence Perception: The most significant finding is that MS, despite his severe deficits in color and texture perception, could systematically rank stimuli based on translucence properties (tea strength and milkiness). This strongly suggests that the neural mechanisms for processing translucence are anatomically distinct from those for color and texture.
  • Beyond Low-Level Cues: The analysis of image statistics revealed that simple low-level cues (like mean saturation or value) could predict the performance of normal observers to some extent, but they failed to explain MS's systematic, albeit less consistent, rankings. This indicates that MS was likely relying on more complex visual analyses of the stimuli, pointing towards specialized processing.
  • Color is Helpful, Not Essential: While normal observers performed slightly better with color stimuli, controls using greyscale images also performed well on the translucence ranking tasks. This demonstrates that color is a useful cue but not strictly necessary for perceiving translucence, further supporting the idea of independent processing pathways.
  • Reverse Ranking for Tea Strength: Interestingly, MS ranked tea strength in the opposite direction to controls. The authors suggest this might be due to his generalized deficits affecting his ability to process absolute lightness values, leading him to interpret "darker" (higher tea concentration) as "less strong" rather than "more strong."

Key Results

  • MS's Performance: MS performed significantly above chance on both the milkiness (p=0.02) and tea strength (p<0.001) ranking tasks, although his performance was less consistent than controls and in the opposite direction for tea strength.
  • Control Performance: All control participants performed very well on both tasks, ranking stimuli significantly above chance and in the correct direction.
  • Greyscale Performance: Controls performing the greyscale tasks also performed well, though slightly less consistently on the milkiness task compared to color stimuli.
  • Image Statistics Fit: For normal observers, image statistics like mean saturation and mean value provided a good fit to their performance. For MS, however, the fits were very poor, indicating he was not relying on these simple cues.

Limitations and Future Work

  • MS's Performance Inconsistency: While MS performed systematically, his rankings were less consistent than controls, and he even reversed the order for tea strength. The authors attribute this, in part, to his broader cognitive deficits and potential issues with processing absolute lightness, rather than a complete lack of translucence perception.
  • Complexity of Translucence Cues: The study acknowledges that translucence perception is complex and likely relies on "pseudocues" (heuristics) that are indirectly driven by physical parameters. The exact nature of these cues and how they are processed remains an area for further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their findings highlight the importance of investigating functional sparing in neuropsychological cases to understand the modularity of visual processing. Future work could involve more detailed neuroimaging studies to pinpoint the specific cortical areas involved in translucence perception and explore how different visual cues are integrated. Further research could also investigate how other material properties, like glossiness, interact with translucence perception.

Summary updated

Abstract

Translucence is an important property of natural materials, and human observers are adept at perceiving changes in translucence. Perceptions of different material properties appear to arise from different cortical regions, and it is therefore plausible that the perception of translucence is dependent on specialised regions, separate from those important for colour and texture processing. To test for anatomical independence between areas necessary for colour, texture and translucence perception we assessed translucency perception in a cortically colour blind observer, who performs at chance on tasks of colour and texture discrimination. Firstly, in order to establish that MS has shown no significant recovery, we assessed his colour perception performance on the Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue Test. Secondly, we tested him with two translucence ranking tasks. In one task, stimuli were images of glasses of tea varying in tea strength. In the other, stimuli were glasses of tea varying only in milkiness. MS was able to systematically rank both strength and milkiness, although less consistently than controls, and for tea strength his rankings were in the opposite order. An additional group of controls tested with greyscale versions of the images succeeded at the tasks, albeit slightly less consistently on the milkiness task, showing that the performance of normal observers cannot be transformed into the performance of MS simply by removing colour information from the stimuli. The systematic performance of MS suggests that some aspects of translucence perception do not depend on regions critical for colour and texture processing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chadwick2017translucence,
  author = {Angus Chadwick and C.A. Heywood and Hannah E. Smithson and Robert W. Kentridge},
  title = {{Translucence perception is not dependent on cortical areas critical for processing colour or texture}},
  booktitle = {Neuropsychologia},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2017.11.009},
}
Figure